Login with:

Facebook

Twitter

Tumblr

Google

Yahoo

Aol.

Mibba

Your info will not be visible on the site. After logging in for the first time you'll be able to choose your display name.

Never Gonna Happen

Never Gonna Happen

“…I feel like I had it all,
back before I lost it all,
Now I just wait for you to talk to me,
but you won’t even look at me, baby…”
~fun. (Stars)

~Jordan~

“You didn’t seem very welcoming to James,” Lia said as she traced her fingers over my chest. I sighed. James had left a couple hours ago, and Lia and I were lying in bed, quietly chatting.

“He keeps trying to go after Jenna,” I said simply, “and I don’t think that’s what she wants right now. Or needs, for that matter.”

“But didn’t you see her, Jordan?” Lia asked. “She looked happy. I haven’t seen her smile in so long. I think…” She sighed, snuggling into me. “I think it’s good for her. James clearly cares about her. He’s not going to hurt her.”

“But it could hurt Sid.”

Lia lifted her head to give me a confused look. “But you’re mad at Sidney,” she said. “Why would you be concerned about that?”

I stroked her hair and kissed her forehead and pulled her back against me. “I am mad. He was such an idiot. But in the end, he loves Jenna, a lot. I know that. Nealer should know it, too.”

“But -”

“Besides, Lia,” I continued, “you shouldn’t keep encouraging James to go after her. It’s unfair.”

“How is it unfair? If he wants to be with her, why shouldn’t he have a chance?”

I looked into Lia’s pretty brown eyes and sighed. “You know it’s never gonna happen, Lia. He’s setting himself up for failure.”

~Jenna~

I woke up on Lia and Jordan’s couch, just like I had on all the other mornings. And also like other mornings, I thought about what had happened the past couple weeks. But for the first time, it didn’t feel like I was being hit by a brick wall. It didn’t make me want to cry or fall back asleep and never wake up. I didn’t feel great. But I felt better.

I quickly folded up the blankets I had used and went into the bathroom to change and brush my teeth. When I came out, Lia and Jordan were in the kitchen, dressed to go out.

“We’re going out for brunch,” Jordan said. “Want to come?”

I shook my head. “I’m going to go for a run.”

“Bring your phone this time,” said Lia firmly. I nodded.

***

The run was good, and the April air was crisp and fresh. When I rounded the street corner, though, I was surprised to see another car in Jordan and Lia’s spot. It wasn’t theirs. But it did belong to someone I know.

The door opened, and Sidney - my Sidney - got out. “Jenna!” he said as I slowed to a silent stop. “I knocked, and no one answered. I thought…I wasn’t sure if you were home.”

I said nothing. What could I say, anyway? But he cleared his throat and continued. “Well, um, I came because…I missed you,” he began. Still, I said nothing, but I could feel my entire body tensing up at the mere sight of him. Sid swallowed. “Well…I know I’m probably the last person you want to see right now,” he said nervously, “but I really need to talk to you. Because I want to try and make things right.”

I looked at him incredulously. “No,” I choked, trying to walk past him and to the door of the building. But he grabbed me by the wrist - not harshly. But firmly. He didn’t want to let me go so easily. I yanked my arm away from him, but turned back to face him.

“Look, Jenna,” he said softly, “I just…I just want you to forgive me. I’m so sorry and I know what I did was a horrible mistake. And if I could take it back, I would. Because I love you. Jenna…” His big brown eyes searched mine. “I would give anything to have you back. You have to understand that.”

I stepped back. “Please, just leave, Sidney,” I said quietly. I couldn’t ignore what he’d just said, but at the same time, I couldn’t forget what he’d done to put us in this position.

“I don’t want to leave without you,” he murmured. “Please, Jenna, just think about it. Won’t you come back? Please? Please, forgive me.”

“Sid, please, leave me alone.”

He looked at me, his eyes lost and defeated. Slowly, he reached into his pocket and pulled out a necklace - the one that once belonged to me. “Please take it,” he said. “It’s yours; I want you to have it.”

I shook my head. “I don’t want it.”

“Well,” he said, “it’s not mine to take back.” He pressed the necklace into my hand, looked at me for just a moment, and turned around to head back to his car. Halfway there, he looked back at me. “Jenna, I understand if you’re upset with me. I even understand if you hate me. But to think that you won’t give me a second chance…that kills me. Because I love you. I’ve never cared for another person the way I care about you.” He turned again and left.

My vision blurred with tears, I unlocked the door and headed inside.

~James~

Tough loss. Very tough loss. 8-5. Usually five was enough to win a game. Not tonight, apparently. For the most part, I couldn’t keep my mind off of the heartbreaking playoff loss to our rival team - for the most part. But every time I got down about it, I thought about Jenna. And that made me feel a little better.

After I got home, I went back and forth with the idea of calling her. Finally, I decided I would, only when I picked up my phone, I already had a text from Lia waiting for me.

“James,” it read, “Jenna left a note saying she’d gone to Diesel and that she’d take a cab home. But I’m worried about her and Jordan’s already sleeping…”

“I’ll get her,” I quickly texted back. I kept waiting and waiting for a chance to rescue Jenna. Maybe this was it.

***

It didn’t take me long to find Jenna, as most of the club was lively and dancing, and she was sitting alone…drinking. I never knew Jenna to drink away her problems - ever. But for the second time in three days, Jenna was drunk. And crying. “Jenna!”

Her red eyes found mine, and she sniffled. “Oh, James…”

“Come on, Jenna, we’re leaving. I’m going to take you back to my place, okay?”

I expected a protest, an argument, anything…but she only shrugged and nodded, not putting up any sort of fight. So I wrapped one arm supportively around her shoulders and led her out of the club. As we drove back to my place, hundreds of questions ran through my head. What was she doing out so late? Why was she drunk and crying? But I didn’t ask anything. Poor Jenna. Honestly, she didn’t deserve questioning. What she deserved was to be taken care of.

~Becca~

He wasn’t home. Weird. Usually after losses, James was happy to have me visit, so tonight I headed over soon after the game ended. But I knocked on the door several times to no avail. I was about to give up when I heard a voice from down the hall.

“Come on, Jenna, almost there.” I turned sharply to see James, leading a very drunk-looking Jenna toward his apartment. This surprised me; James had only every described Jenna as put-together and mentally strong - not one to let herself go drinking.

“Becca?” James asked, reaching the door.

“Hi, James,” I replied, wondering if it was really even a good time, considering he had Jenna with him. Jenna, who he…loved. “I, you know,” I looked down sadly, “I can leave. Come back some other time.”

James was silent as he unlocked his door, but after opening it, he turned to me. “No, it’s okay. Actually, there’s something we need to talk about.” He held the door for me and Jenna. “Jenna, hon, go into my closet and see if you can find a shirt to change into, okay?” She sniffled and nodded, leaving just me and James in the kitchen.

“I’m really sorry, James, I didn’t know this was a bad time…Really, I’ll just go home and come some other time…”

“No, Becca, see…I’m not sure we should keep doing this at all.” I blinked, not quite understanding what he meant. Or at least, not wanting to understand it. “I think we should end this relationship,” he clarified.

All the air escaped my lungs, and all I could manage to say was, “oh.”

“I really like what we had,” he continued. My heart felt both heavy and empty at the same time. I wasn’t sure what to think yet. “It was a lot of fun.” I nodded, unable to speak. James didn’t want me anymore. He never needed me at all. “But I think that I might finally have a chance with Jenna, you know?” His eyes were bright and innocently oblivious to the fact that he was breaking my heart.

I swallowed hard. “That’s great,” I managed to say - although it was quite the opposite from what I was feeling.

“And that’s why you’re amazing,” he said with a smile, “because you’re so understanding like this. And now, maybe, I can actually have a serious relationship with Jenna.” I nodded emotionlessly. “I just fell like this is my chance to be her knight in shining armor. This is it.”

I swallowed again. “Well,” I choked. “Good luck, James. You know me.” I forced a smile. “I only ever wanted you to be happy.”

I was numb to the friendly hug he gave me after, to the tears that fell down my cheeks as I went to my car, to the ache in my heart as I sat in the driver’s seat as I broke down. So I was the fool, I thought to myself, to follow something that was never gonna happen.

~James~

I found Jenna sitting on my bed, crying her eyes out. I quickly changed into a t-shirt and sweats before returning and sitting next to her, placing a hand on her shoulder.

“What happened?” I asked quietly.

“S-Sidney…” she replied and proceeded to tell the story of how Sid had shown up unannounced at Staal’s apartment and essentially broke her heart all over again.

“Come here,” I said gently, taking her into my arms. She sobbed into my shoulder.

“J-James,” she cried.

“Yeah?”

“I still love him.” Well. That was a little hard to take.

“Well,” I said slowly, “once you’re ready, I suppose you’ll have to let him go. “I mean, it’ll take time. But at some point, you’re going to have to put it behind you - how happy he made you, how he loved you, how he held you when you cried, how -”

“Sid never saw me cry,” she whispered. “I had to be perfect.”

“Jenna, no one’s perfect -”

“N-no, James, you don’t understand.” She sniffled. “Sidney’s perfect. I had to be perfect for him. I had to be his rock, he needed me to be perfect.” She looked up at me, her eyes red. “I don’t have to be perfect for you, though; you already like me for who I am.”

“Of course,” I replied quickly. “Jenna, I lo- I mean, I like you no matter what.” But Jenna was drunk, sleepy, and upset. Honestly, she was a little out of it. She curled up and rested her head against my chest. For a while, I thought she might be sleeping. But she spoke up again.

“You understand me, James,” she whispered. I stroked her hair. “You’re so good to me.”

Soon after, she did fall asleep. Choosing to do the right thing, I slipped out from Jenna’s weak hold and got out of the bed, placing a blanket over her. I placed a hand on hers. Her fist was clenched, and I opened it to find a necklace. The one Sid had given her. Defeated, I took it and placed it on the nightstand. I kissed her forehead, and with my thoughts on the necklace that she held on to with such devotion, I went to the sofa and hoped to God I’d fall asleep soon.

Prequel

Forever

NC-17 Romance Drama

Lia Morgan has had a lifelong battle against depression and anorexia. But once she meets Jordan Staal, could things change for the better?

1/6/13

Completed ✓
9.7 19 Votes

Comments

@nanshil87
I actually updated recently on Mibba and will try to post that here today. Glad you like the story!!

leecasper17
12/9/13
This is an interesting story. When are you going to update again?
nanshil87 nanshil87
12/5/13
This is such a great story, I love it. I still don't know who to choose Sid/Jenna or James/Jenna
Sidster87 Sidster87
4/9/13
Jenna/Sid!!
puckme69 puckme69
2/12/13
i am in love with jordan and lia. now i just want jenna to make up her mind of who she wants. someone has to give because the egos are a bit much...
ldw choice ldw choice
1/14/13