Login with:

Facebook

Twitter

Tumblr

Google

Yahoo

Aol.

Mibba

Your info will not be visible on the site. After logging in for the first time you'll be able to choose your display name.

It Was Always You

for my whole life





The next few months flew by, much to the relief of Tandoori. She spent her time either at work, or with James; there was no In-between. As much as Tandy wanted to support James by attending his home games, and as much as she knew he'd appreciate it, she couldn't bring herself to do it.

Matt had still been playing for the Marlies, and as far as she knew, things were going okay for him. She had moved everything out of the apartment they shared and moved a little closer to work, with the help of James and Jacob.

The other wives and girlfriends, as nice as they were, continued to pester her about why her and Matt were done. As much as she wanted the world to know how much of a scum bag he really was, she couldn't bring herself to tell anyone, with the exception of James and Jacob, the truth about him.

She had blocked his number, and she stayed in the kitchen most nights, so as far as she knew he had kept away from her; to her pleasure. The last thing she needed to deal with was Matt showing up at work, she thought as she closed down the restaurant a little bit late.

James and the Leafs were on their California road trip, playing game two of four, and losing, being shut out again. Things seemed to be going down hill fast for the Leafs who ever since firing their head coach had been slipping deeper and deeper out of playoff contention.

But despite his team not doing well, and not performing to his own standards, James still had time to be there for Tandy. Whenever she needed to talk, to vent, anything; he was there. There was no way she could repay him for all the nice things he had done since the break up with Matt.

"Good, Tandy, wait" she heard a voice call. Her hair stood up on the back of her neck, and a chill ran down her spine; she recognized that voice. A voice she had never hoped to hear ever again; the voice belonging to Matt Frattin,

"What do you want" she spoke coolly, trying her best to appear more confident than she felt. Her long blonde hair was tied up in a messy bun, her black apron a hot mess from a particularly busy Tuesday night, and her make up half ass done. She felt exposed, and cold, wrapping her jacket tighter around her tiny frame.

"I want to talk" he pleaded, looking genuinely upset.

"I think it's a little late for that, don't you think?" She answered with a scowl, inching closer to her car with every word. She held her key out in her hand, like a weapon, in case he tried anything funny. Looking at her watch she noticed it was well after 2 AM; there would be nobody around to hear her scream at this hour.

"Tandy I'm sorry" he blurted out, for lack of a better word.

"I beg your pardon?" Tandy gasped, not even allowing him to finish his sentence. "Well doesn't that just make everything better now" she rolled her eyes, her words dripping with hatred.

"Fuck Tandy I made a damn mistake!" He roared, a little louder than he had intended. He saw her wince, and felt terrible for a fraction of a second; had he done this to her? It was obvious she was on edge, from the moment he followed her from the restaurant.

"You hit me" she said, the words making it feel more real. "Do you have any idea- ANY idea how much damage you caused me? How much stress? You fucking hit me" she could feel the tears in her eyes, but held herself composed. It was no secret she still loved him; how could one move on so quickly?

"I love you, Tandy" he whispered, looking at her with puppy dog eyes.

"You're a different person when you're sober, Matthew" he flinched at the use of his full first name.

"I can change" he urged, desperate to patch things up. He knew he was having a rough patch not being able to play for the Leafs, but being sent down to the Marlies. Things were falling apart for him, and with Tandy being gone so much he fell apart.

"I can't trust you again; I'm sorry" Tandy whispered, one single tear falling down her cheek.

With that, Matt let her get into her car and drive away, watching as his whole world drove away from him. Wishing he had treated her differently, and vowing to show her he could change.





"Are you sure youre okay?" James asked for thousandth time. Tandy laughed, happy at how concerned he was for her.

"Yes, I'm fine" she laughed, filling up his water. It was a slow morning at the restaurant, and James had stopped by after getting back from the long and gruelling road trip. They lost every game, only scoring three goals in the four games played. Things were not well in Leafs Land.

"I keep having the urge to hit him when I see him" James confessed, sipping on his water. "But I know nobody else knows and would wonder why I'm suddenly so violent" he added the last part a little more tensely. It was no secret James wanted Matt exposed for his indecent behaviour, but Tandy was having no part of that.

"I appreciate you keeping the secret you know" Tandy smiled hearing someone walk in the door.

"Hey James, ready to go?" It was Bozie, offering up James a ride on his way to practice.

"Yeah, man, sure" James nodded towards Tandy. "Have a good one, Tand" he smiled, wanting so desperately to kiss her. She said her goodbyes, watching the pair both walk out of the restaurant. She was so busy cleaning up the mess she had just made she didn't even notice Tyler walk back in.

"Jesus christ" she muttered, her hand over her heart as it beat rapidly in her chest.

"No, it's just me" he laughed, awkwardly putting his hand behind his head and scratching lightly. "Listen, Tandy, there's something I wanted to talk to you about"

"Oh?" She asked a little taken aback.

"James really likes you" he blurted out, causing Tandy to let out a nervous sigh.

"Well I'd hope so, I mean-"

"No Tandy, I mean like he really likes you" he emphasized the word "like", hoping this time she would catch his drift. She made a small 'o' shape with her lips, unsure of how to respond.

"I don't think so" she shook her head, not believing it. He was way out of her league; he was handsome, charming, hilarious, nice, caring, giving... Everything she wanted in a guy, but everything she knew was too good for her.

"Trust me Tandy" Tyler reasoned looking from her to the door. "Just- please take it easy on him. I know Matt and you are a thing and all-"

"Wait what?" Tandy asked, cutting him off completely.

"You and Matt? I mean, he talks about you all the time? You live together?" Tyler asked, an eyebrow raised. "Don't you?"

Tandy stood in her place, fuming mad. Was Matt still walking around telling everyone they were together?

"No, we're not together" she scoffed, wanting to beat the living day lights out of him. "We broke up months ago.. He-" she paused for a moment, wondering if she should confess her biggest secret. She knew James would be in favour, and now she understood why.

"He- I- oh I'm sorry" Tyler blurted out, unsure of how to react.

"He hit me" she let out, proud of herself for not crying. "I didn't tell anybody because I didn't want this to ruin his career or whatever, but-"

"Tandy on my god- why didn't you say anything?" Tyler stammered, wide eyed. No wonder James hated Matt so much. It was just James being in love with Tandy; it was something worse.

"I know- I should have said something" she sighed heavily, trying to read the confusing expression on Tyler's face.

"Look, I have to go to practice- I told James I had to pee- but we are coming back to talk about this after" he assured me, putting his hand lightly on my shoulder. "Promise"

And with that he left the restaurant, leaving Tandy even more terrified and confused than before

Notes

Comments

I'm happy that you're back to writing this! But wtf whyyyy lol

ACupOf_Pudding
6/17/16

Oh no why? Is she back with him? I just want to slap her

panthers1391 panthers1391
6/17/16

@Mapleleafer
Can't wait for the next update

Hawksfan1988 Hawksfan1988
11/28/14

@Hawksfan1988
:)

Mapleleafer
11/27/14

Thumbs up

Hawksfan1988 Hawksfan1988
11/26/14