Login with:

Facebook

Twitter

Tumblr

Google

Yahoo

Aol.

Mibba

Your info will not be visible on the site. After logging in for the first time you'll be able to choose your display name.

Can't Remember to Forget You

Chapter 001

With his hat pulled down low and his eyes focused completely on the tile in front of him, it would've been easy for Sidney to miss her. He'd stopped in at his usual time, roughly forty minutes before closing, knowing he only needed a few essentials. Milk. Cereal. Maybe a couple boxes of those granola bars his sister had told him about...

He stared at the shelf in front of him, lips pursed out as he chewed thoughtfully on the inside of his mouth. Before he could be tempted to text his sister, he suddenly felt the hairs on the back of his neck raise up; he could feel himself being watched. Unlike most people's, his instinct was to keep his gaze focused directly in front of him as not make a scene or raise an alarm. But, when he saw the person's figure flick quickly out of his peripheral vision, he couldn't help but become curious. Sure, most fans came up to speak to him. Some opted to stare from afar as if he was an exhibit at the zoo. Rarely, however, did they quickly disappear.

Turning his head, his eyes found the figure that'd nearly made it to the end of the aisle. A tiny frame of a woman, with long wavy brown hair, and an ass -

Sidney's grip loosed from the basket he held and he barely noticed the loud clatter it made when it fell to the ground. He knew that ass all too well.

"Tara!" he yelled out, instantly springing from his position to catch up with her at the end of the aisle. "Tara, wait!"

She stopped when she heard her name, her shoulders tense. Sid stopped a couple of feet behind her, shoving his large hands into the pockets of his jeans. She used to call that his defense mechanism. She wasn't wrong.

Slowly, she turned around, a look of sheer disbelief on her face. "Hello, Sidney," she mumbled, her voice low as her gaze turned down to the floor.

A heavy wall of awkwardness and tension fell between them. In all of his scenarios of how it'd be when he found her again, this had not been in Sidney's plan. Most of his dreams involved profusely apologizing, then taking her back to his bed to apologize in another way. He had no delusions that he was anything but a caveman when it came to women.

"What are you doing here?" He finally asked, piercing through the thick atmosphere between them. Tara crossed her arms before finally lifting her gaze to meet his eyes. Little had changed about her appearance; her face had thinned a bit, but her nose was still straight as an arrow, only widening at the end, her lips still full, and her brown eyes still large and bright. Her skin had a much brighter glow, but he wasn't sure if that was because she'd started caring about it more or because she no longer went out to party every day of the week. Or maybe Sidney's brain just hadn't been focused on how her skin should look in his dreams.

"Free country." Tara's reply was sharp and cut deep; however, her eyes widened slightly and her face reddened. That was the closest he supposed he'd ever get to an apology for getting such a short answer. "Got a job working here at one of the corporate steel offices. Just moving my way up the corporate ladder, you know..."

"We should talk," Sidney said suddenly, his mouth blurting out what he really wanted. There was time to talk about jobs and plans and what the hell they'd both been up to.

"No, Sid, that's exactly what I don't want to do. I'm not here to make nice and be friends with everyone again. Even you. Especially you." This was definitely not the simulation he'd run over in his mind so many times. She was supposed to agree to talk with him for Christ's sake.

Sidney didn't have to ask why. He doubted there was anything in common with her and the other guys. All of their partying days were over; with the exception of himself and Geno, everyone else was married and had kids. Quite a few of them had been traded away to various distances. There wouldn't have been many for her to make nice to, no one with any common interests... himself the exception, of course.

"I'm not asking you to be friends with them, Tara. I'm just asking for another chance for me. I know I fucked things up, but you just... left. Just left and didn't tell anyone! How was I supposed to find you?"

"You weren't," Tara interjected sharply, deflating Sid's demeanor entirely. "What do you want from me, Sidney? I trusted you. You became my closest friend. And when I needed you more than anything, you showed you were only in it to fuck me!"

"That's not true, Tara," Sid hissed, fighting as hard as she was to keep their voices low. No need for the two of them to make a huge scene in Whole Foods with twenty minutes 'til close.

"What do you want, Sid?" she repeated, her eyes narrowing further.

"I just want to make it up to you," he replied lamely, sighing. He wasn't sure how he could exactly make it up. Spilling your guts out to a girl about how much you love her and how you couldn't wait to pick up the pieces her ex-boyfriend had just left behind hours before wasn't exactly the best way to start a relationship. The money, the notoriety, and even his good looks weren't enough to make him good with women.

"I forgive you, Sid," Tara sighed softly. "I forgave you a long time ago, or at least I thought I did until I saw you tonight...

"Look, I've moved on in my life. I actually have a steady career. I'm not plastered four nights out of the week. I'm making something of myself. I have something more fulfilling in my life than Max and working to keep him happy. I have no interest in getting mixed up in that lifestyle again... not now, or ever."

"'That lifestyle'", Sid replied using his fingers as air quotes, "was a result of us being young. Everyone has grown up and moved on. Hell, we had to. If you don't want to try to be apart of my life again, fine, but don't blame it on a reason that isn't even true anymore."

"Fine. I don't want to be in your life again because you're an ass," Tara hissed, gracefully turning on her heel as she began to push her basket down the end of the aisle again.

Sid stood stock still, verbally slapped with her words. However, at the sight of her basket making a sharp right turn at the end of the aisle, he picked his jaw up and followed after her. He had to be careful now; they didn't have the protection of the aisle to keep them out of sight. One wrong move and he'd risk being physically slapped right in the middle of the produce section.

"Tara, please, I'm sorry!" Sidney grabbed a hold of the side of the basket, halting her forward motion. She pushed harder, but his grip was unmovable. That had always been part of her frustration surrounded by athletes - she was so small that she was easily overpowered with even the slightest efforts.

Grunting, she gave up and looked up at him, meeting his eyes again. "Please, Sid... this is an important stepping stone for me. It wasn't easy leaving and it sure as hell wasn't easy coming back. All I want is to spend my time here in peace before I get promoted again and sent somewhere out of your hair. You don't know how on edge I've been whenever I leave my condo to go out for anything... I've been afraid of this exact moment since I was sent here."

"I know it's hard for you, Tara. But don't act like it hasn't been hard for me. This isn't the best place for this kind of conversation, I know... Maybe, if you could... maybe we could get lunch one day? Just... catch up, y'know? Just one lunch and I swear, if it all goes wrong, I will never try to find you or contact you while you're here," Sid let out, feeling his heart pound as he waited for her answer.

Eyes narrowing slightly, Tara reached into her purse and pulled out a pen. Tearing off the bottom of her shopping list, she tentatively wrote down a number on the piece of paper. Sid noted that it was different than what her number had been years ago; that much wasn't a surprise. Her number had gone out of service not long after she left Pittsburgh. But this new one had a Pittsburgh area code and he couldn't help but shake the feeling he was getting the number to a local pizza chain.

"My work number," Tara said tersely, handing it over before putting the cap back on her pen. "You've got one lunch. One. Call me when you're available and I'll check my schedule."

Sidney let go of the cart and Tara started forward without another word just as an announcement sounded throughout the store that they were closing in ten minutes. He was still skeptical that he'd received an actual working number from her, but he'd gotten in all of the time he knew he would get tonight. Pocketing the number, Sid retreated back down the aisle to pick up the small handbasket he'd dropped from earlier. After grabbing a random pack of granola bars, he walked briskly to the check-out counters, ready to make it home.

____________________________________________________________________________
July 01, 2011

Shakily, Tara brought up her arm and banged hard on Sidney's apartment door. It didn't take him long to answer. Once he saw her red, splotchy face, he pulled her into his arms into a tight hug.

"I'm sorry, Tare," he said softly, rubbing her back supportively. He was caught between a rock and a hard place with this one - Max was a long-time friend, but then, so was she.

"He didn't even tell me," she choked out, pulling away from Sid to wipe her eyes with the back of his hands. "I had to find out through a fucking text alert from the NHL!"

"None of us knew," Sid replied, lying through his teeth. He'd known as soon as it was clear Max wouldn't be resigned - from the source and from Ray Shero. He'd known Max had planned to break up with her weeks before it happened. He'd known that Max had fallen so far out of love with her that he'd given Sid permission to date her a couple weeks prior with no hints of sarcasm or venom and without the standard "you hurt her, I hurt you" warning. But he didn't know that Max wouldn't tell her and that he'd dump everything on her in a very quick succession.

Tara believed him whole-heartedly... he wouldn't lie. Not Sid. He was the most innocent out of all of them, nothing but hard work and dedication to his game. His slip ups included drinking a couple glasses of whiskey properly (no shots for the Golden Boy) and having occasional one-night-stands that he always bought breakfast for in the mornings. They'd bonded over history and their shared interest in World War II and him constantly kicking her ass whenever it came to video games. He'd never made salacious remarks about her tits or ass or ever made her uncomfortable in any way. He was her best friend in Pittsburgh and she just knew he would be her rock...

"What am I going to do?" Tara asked quietly. "I should've listened to my mom, finished up my degree while I was here. God, I can't go back to Birmingham..."

"Then stay here," Sid said softly, stepping closer to her. He tucked a lock of wavy, brunette hair behind her ear and gave her a genuine smile. "Or, better yet, you could come back up to Nova Scotia with me... spend some time away."

Tara smiled despite the ache in her chest. "I don't know if a good view can make up for how beautiful Montreal was. Besides, I do have a very, very important job, y'know. How will all of those clothes in the boutique sell themselves?"

Sid cupped her cheek, running his thumb carefully under her eye. Tara stiffened slightly; they were used to hugs and back scratches and the occasional shoulder rub and she'd walked in on him naked a few times, but that seemed so different. Way too intimate...

"I should probably go... pack my stuff and all..." Tara mumbled, pulling away with all the grace and dignity she could muster.

"You don't have to leave..." Sidney let his arm fall to his side. He felt his stomach begin to flop and his chest start to swell. "This doesn't have to be a bad thing... you can stay and we could try it. Take it slow. I can't help but feel like maybe this is our chance... I'm in love with you, Tara..."

Fighting the urge to burst into tears all over again, Tara shook her head fervently, as if she could shake the words right out of her head and out of her memory. She'd always suspected and Max had always made bawdy jokes... but hearing it straight from Sid's lips just felt wrong.

"I'm sorry, Sid, I can't, okay? You've been like a brother -"

"A brother... seriously?!" Sid interrupted, all of the wind knocked hard from his sails. "That's all that I am to you?"

"Well, yes, Sid!" Tara replied, the urge to cry leaving just as the urge to kill rose. "Contrary to popular belief, not every woman who comes near you wants you to stick your dick in them!"

Flabbergasted, Sid sputtered, "How could you love Max fucking Talbot but you won't even give me a chance?"

"It wasn't like it was love at first sight, you idiot!" Tara yelled, feeling more betrayed then ever. First her boyfriend, the one and only man she had ever wanted to be with left her, and now she was losing her best friend as well? The world was not fair. "I met him independently of you, I grew to love him independently of you. You were just a bonus when I realized I could have more than two friends in this city. But, clearly, I was wrong."

"What, because I fell in love with you too, I can't be your friend?" Sid asked, his brows furrowed hard as he looked at her.

"No. Because if you were my friend and you truly gave a shit about me, your first instinct wouldn't be to 'claim me' as soon as I become single. If you knew anything about me at all, you'd know how much I'm hurting right now, and you'd give me time instead of piling this on to everything else," Tara replied, her voice low.

Biting her lip, she made her way to the door, and Sidney felt powerless to stop her. As she closed the door behind her, the lights in the hallway outside reflected what was obviously a new batch of tears falling down her face.

It would take two years for him to understand how he'd hurt her so badly.




Notes

Comments

Love it so far!!

hockey718729 hockey718729
2/5/15