When We Were Young
One Night
Jamie’s P.O.V.
After Sarah walked out the door, I decided to stay a little longer. I sat back down at the table and thought about how many amazing times we had together and how everyone said we were the “power couple”. I couldn’t help but smile until the memory of the night she walked out of my life made it’s way into my head.
********
I had just gotten back from a Florida trip Tyler, Jordie, and I decided to take after we were eliminated in the playoffs. I first drove to the house we had just purchased thinking she was there unpacking some of the boxes we had moved the week before. When the house was empty I made my way to our apartment and walked through the door to the sound of her crying.
I instantly rushed to the bedroom to see that she was packing some clothes in a suitcase. I went to her side on the floor, pulled her in close to me, and asked her “Babe, what’s wrong?”
Before I could fully pull her into me, she pushed away from me and spat back “you don’t get to call me that. Not anymore”.
“Sarah, what’s going on?”
“We’re done, Jamie.” She said through her sobs.
“What? Why?” I asked. I was genuinely confused at what had happened. We were fine a few days ago when I left. More than fine actually.
“Are you seriously asking me that?”
“Sarah, I have no idea what you are talking about. Can you please tell me so I can make it right?”
“You can’t. It’s too late.”
After a few minutes of me trying anything just to get her to talk to me, she finally yelled, “YOU WANNA KNOW WHAT HAPPENED?!”
“Yes!”
“Remember when we first started dating and you came down here for the season but I stayed back home?”
Confused by where this was heading I responded saying, “yes, but what does that have to do with us now?”
“Remember what you said to me as you were getting in the taxi cab?”
“I told you I wanted to be with you and only you and I wanted you to do the same.”
“EXACTLY!” she started, “I held up MY part of that deal but apparently YOU didn’t care enough to keep up yours. I’m just crazy that I didn’t know sooner. I’m such an idiot”.
“What are you talking about?! If you’re hinting that I cheated on you during one of those road trips, you’re fucking insane!” I responded started to get angry at what she was accusing me of.
“I saw it with my own eyes Jamie.”
“YOU SAW WHAT?!”
“YOU KISSING THAT BLONDE BIMBO IN FLORIDA. Do you even check your social media anymore? Because that picture has been circulating like crazy! You not only hurt me, but you embarrassed me. All of Dallas, hell people all over the world are probably saying how dumb I am for being with a cheater. I don’t know how many times this has happened, but I’m not going to wait around for it to happen again. I’m done. I’m leaving.”
I instantly knew what she was talking about and my heart dropped into the pit of my stomach. “Sarah, it’s not what you think” I finally managed to get out.
“IT’S NOT WHAT I THINK?!” She yelled while marching over to the bed, grabbing her phone and pulling up the picture of me kissing the girl I had met one night in Florida. She then showed me the picture and yelled again “IT’S NOT WHAT I THINK?! YOU’RE KISSING ANOTHER GIRL.”
She was right, I did kiss that girl; but the moment I realized that she wasn’t Sarah, I stopped. Was what I did acceptable? Absolutely not. At this point I just wanted to pull her into a kiss to shut her up and hopefully make her realize that I love her and only her, but I knew if I did that it would only cause more problems.
I couldn’t find the words to say because there was no denying what I had done. I wasn’t planning on keeping this a secret from her; I just wanted to confess on my own terms.
“Unbelievable” she said breaking the silence. I watched her zip up her suitcase and head out of the bedroom door. Right when she was getting ready to turn the handle of the front door, I stopped her by asking what I thought would be a harmless question: “Where are you going?”
“Why do you care?!”
“Because I care about you.” I let out a sigh before continuing, “Sarah, you’re the love of my life.”
She just did a fake laugh at the sound of that before saying “Oh yeah? Is that why you cheated on me? You just love me SO much you’d rather make out with some fake orange bimbo who is probably a puck slut?!”
In that moment I said something I instantly regretted. I dropped a bomb and I knew in a matter of minutes, the apartment would be engulfed in flames. “SHUT UP SARAH. YOU KNOW I ONLY LOVE YOU BUT YOU’RE BEING A FUCKING CUNT RIGHT NOW. RUN AWAY LIKE YOU ALWAYS HAVE WHEN THINGS WEREN’T GOING YOUR WAY.”
She instantly slapped me as she started crying. She then turned around and walked out the door and out of my life.
********
To this day, I still don’t know where she went when she left our apartment. I just knew I didn’t talk to her again until I ran into her at the bar three months later. She ran away from our relationship just like a plane runs away from the departing city: effortlessly.
I wish I would have gone after her but I just didn’t know what to do. That night in Florida still haunts me to this day. I don’t really remember the night too much but I remember a girl all over me, obviously hoping I would take her home. Tyler was off trying to find his own girl to hookup with and Jordie just kept feeding me drinks. I took the elimination the hardest since I was supposed to lead the team to the cup.
After about an hour of the blonde trying to have her way with me, she finally just grabbed my face and crashed her lips into mine. She did it the exact way Sarah would do it when she wanted to have sex and for a moment, I thought it was Sarah. That is why I kissed her back. I realized it wasn’t her when Tyler yelled my name from across the bar before dragging me out of there. I remember feeling like the scum of the earth the rest of the trip knowing I had cheated on the only girl I had ever loved.
It only took one night to fuck up my entire life.
After Sarah walked out the door, I decided to stay a little longer. I sat back down at the table and thought about how many amazing times we had together and how everyone said we were the “power couple”. I couldn’t help but smile until the memory of the night she walked out of my life made it’s way into my head.
********
I had just gotten back from a Florida trip Tyler, Jordie, and I decided to take after we were eliminated in the playoffs. I first drove to the house we had just purchased thinking she was there unpacking some of the boxes we had moved the week before. When the house was empty I made my way to our apartment and walked through the door to the sound of her crying.
I instantly rushed to the bedroom to see that she was packing some clothes in a suitcase. I went to her side on the floor, pulled her in close to me, and asked her “Babe, what’s wrong?”
Before I could fully pull her into me, she pushed away from me and spat back “you don’t get to call me that. Not anymore”.
“Sarah, what’s going on?”
“We’re done, Jamie.” She said through her sobs.
“What? Why?” I asked. I was genuinely confused at what had happened. We were fine a few days ago when I left. More than fine actually.
“Are you seriously asking me that?”
“Sarah, I have no idea what you are talking about. Can you please tell me so I can make it right?”
“You can’t. It’s too late.”
After a few minutes of me trying anything just to get her to talk to me, she finally yelled, “YOU WANNA KNOW WHAT HAPPENED?!”
“Yes!”
“Remember when we first started dating and you came down here for the season but I stayed back home?”
Confused by where this was heading I responded saying, “yes, but what does that have to do with us now?”
“Remember what you said to me as you were getting in the taxi cab?”
“I told you I wanted to be with you and only you and I wanted you to do the same.”
“EXACTLY!” she started, “I held up MY part of that deal but apparently YOU didn’t care enough to keep up yours. I’m just crazy that I didn’t know sooner. I’m such an idiot”.
“What are you talking about?! If you’re hinting that I cheated on you during one of those road trips, you’re fucking insane!” I responded started to get angry at what she was accusing me of.
“I saw it with my own eyes Jamie.”
“YOU SAW WHAT?!”
“YOU KISSING THAT BLONDE BIMBO IN FLORIDA. Do you even check your social media anymore? Because that picture has been circulating like crazy! You not only hurt me, but you embarrassed me. All of Dallas, hell people all over the world are probably saying how dumb I am for being with a cheater. I don’t know how many times this has happened, but I’m not going to wait around for it to happen again. I’m done. I’m leaving.”
I instantly knew what she was talking about and my heart dropped into the pit of my stomach. “Sarah, it’s not what you think” I finally managed to get out.
“IT’S NOT WHAT I THINK?!” She yelled while marching over to the bed, grabbing her phone and pulling up the picture of me kissing the girl I had met one night in Florida. She then showed me the picture and yelled again “IT’S NOT WHAT I THINK?! YOU’RE KISSING ANOTHER GIRL.”
She was right, I did kiss that girl; but the moment I realized that she wasn’t Sarah, I stopped. Was what I did acceptable? Absolutely not. At this point I just wanted to pull her into a kiss to shut her up and hopefully make her realize that I love her and only her, but I knew if I did that it would only cause more problems.
I couldn’t find the words to say because there was no denying what I had done. I wasn’t planning on keeping this a secret from her; I just wanted to confess on my own terms.
“Unbelievable” she said breaking the silence. I watched her zip up her suitcase and head out of the bedroom door. Right when she was getting ready to turn the handle of the front door, I stopped her by asking what I thought would be a harmless question: “Where are you going?”
“Why do you care?!”
“Because I care about you.” I let out a sigh before continuing, “Sarah, you’re the love of my life.”
She just did a fake laugh at the sound of that before saying “Oh yeah? Is that why you cheated on me? You just love me SO much you’d rather make out with some fake orange bimbo who is probably a puck slut?!”
In that moment I said something I instantly regretted. I dropped a bomb and I knew in a matter of minutes, the apartment would be engulfed in flames. “SHUT UP SARAH. YOU KNOW I ONLY LOVE YOU BUT YOU’RE BEING A FUCKING CUNT RIGHT NOW. RUN AWAY LIKE YOU ALWAYS HAVE WHEN THINGS WEREN’T GOING YOUR WAY.”
She instantly slapped me as she started crying. She then turned around and walked out the door and out of my life.
********
To this day, I still don’t know where she went when she left our apartment. I just knew I didn’t talk to her again until I ran into her at the bar three months later. She ran away from our relationship just like a plane runs away from the departing city: effortlessly.
I wish I would have gone after her but I just didn’t know what to do. That night in Florida still haunts me to this day. I don’t really remember the night too much but I remember a girl all over me, obviously hoping I would take her home. Tyler was off trying to find his own girl to hookup with and Jordie just kept feeding me drinks. I took the elimination the hardest since I was supposed to lead the team to the cup.
After about an hour of the blonde trying to have her way with me, she finally just grabbed my face and crashed her lips into mine. She did it the exact way Sarah would do it when she wanted to have sex and for a moment, I thought it was Sarah. That is why I kissed her back. I realized it wasn’t her when Tyler yelled my name from across the bar before dragging me out of there. I remember feeling like the scum of the earth the rest of the trip knowing I had cheated on the only girl I had ever loved.
It only took one night to fuck up my entire life.
No yay I love this!!
4/7/16