When We Were Young
Kelowna to Dallas
Sarah’s P.O.V.
All this talking about the past really made me miss the times when life was easy with Jamie. Sure the distance to Kelowna wasn’t ideal but that was nothing compared to everything else that was thrown our way.
**********
After the summer spent together, he had to go back to Kelowna; a time we both knew was approaching. In order to make things easier, we decided that we would be together, but keep our relationship open that way if Jamie found himself celebrating a big win he wouldn’t have to feel guilty about wanting to sleep with a girl.
I was really happy we made that agreement when I saw a girl tag pictures on multiple occasions on Facebook of them looking pretty cozy. Yes, it hurt like hell but I had no reason to be mad because it was my idea to not keep the relationship just between the two of us. I figured if rules were set saying that it was okay, then it wouldn’t hurt as much when he hooked up with a random girl.
After that day I didn’t feel like we were a couple for the rest of the season. We instantly went back to being best friends in my mind and although we never officially “broke up” it was something we both kind of understood.
A few years later he got that call that everyone waits for: he was needed in Dallas in a week.
“Come with me” he said after telling me the news of being called up.
“Jamie, I can’t.”
“Yes you can. You’re my best friend. I can’t move to a new city without my best friend. Please Sarah” he begged.
“My whole life is here. My family, friends, school, it’s all here”
“So I’m not a part of your life anymore?”
“You know that’s not what I mean Jamie. I will go down there for the first game of the season, I will visit as much as I can, and I will be at every game you play in Vancouver, but I can’t just pick up my life and move.”
“You promise you will be at every game you can?”
“Cross my heart and hope to die” I responded smiling. That had always been our little saying. We thought it was so clever back when we first started hanging out and it just had stuck ever since.
***********
“I was crushed when you wouldn’t come with me. I was nervous about the move to begin with but not having you with me made it that much more scary” He confessed before taking a sip of his coffee.
Jamie’s P.O.V.
I still couldn’t blame her for not coming with me the moment I got that call to head to Dallas. She couldn’t just leave like I could. Being a professional athlete, it was something that you knew would happen. You’re nice and comfortable in one city one moment and the next you’re being shipped somewhere new. Although it sucked going from Kelowna to Dallas, it was my dream: I FINALLY got a chance to play in the NHL.
“Do you remember what I told you the day I left for Dallas?” I asked her knowing that she hadn’t forgotten.
“Which part? The part where you were telling me the girls you got with?”
“After that…”
********
It was my last couple of hours in Victoria before heading to Dallas and of course I wanted to spend it with no one else but Sarah. I hadn’t seen her since the day I left for Kelowna and although I had a few last minute things to do, she was my number one priority.
“I really wish you could come with me” I said hoping to guilt her into tagging along.
“You know I want to, but I can’t” she replied. I could see the sadness in her eyes knowing that I would now be even further away.
I sat there for a few moments in silence with her, perfectly content. She broke the silence when she asked me if I would have remained faithful if she didn’t suggest leaving our relationship open when I went to Kelowna for my second season.
“You know I would have, Sarah” I responded after a moment. I was taken aback by the question because it was never brought up until now. “I would never cheat on you.”
“Then why did you replace me?” she asked.
I never could replace her and I thought she knew that. There was no one in the world I would rather have in my life than her and it honestly hurt to think that she thought I could replace her.
“I never replaced you. You’re irreplaceable” I said knowing this was going to lead into a fight – the last thing I wanted today.
“Then why did you start seeing that girl? The one who posted pictures all the time of you guys together.”
“You’re the one who wanted to keep the relationship open. I know I shouldn’t have started to see her, but I did out of spite. I thought ‘hell if Sarah wants to see other guys while I am gone, then I’m going to see other girls too’ and that is just what I did. When I came back home I expected our relationship to be just us but you went back to treating me like your best friend and once again, I knew having you in my life as a friend was better than not having you at all” I responded starting to raise my voice a little.
“If I didn’t suggest for us to keep things open, then I would have been heartbroken when you cheated on me. I thought it would hurt less knowing I wasn’t being cheated on but it hurt just as bad. I spent the rest of the season hearing from everyone that you had your zip code girls and I just knew I deserved better than that. I knew I loved you but I wouldn’t allow myself to be made a fool out of because my boyfriend didn’t love me.”
“I know I made mistakes. I was gone for months while you were back here and while I was gone I did things I shouldn’t have. Things you wouldn’t want to know.”
Right then, as if almost on cue, she stood up and I could tell she was angrier than I’ve ever seen her before. “GET OUT” she yelled pointing towards the door.
“Sar-“
“GET THE HELL OUT OF MY HOUSE JAMIE”
I had no choice but to leave. I hurt her enough and didn’t want to do it anymore. As I was walking to the front door I knew she was following me. The moment I stepped out of the door threshold I turned around just to try to talk to her one last time. Before I was completely facing her, she slammed the door in my face. I fucked up and I knew it.
Knowing Sarah, I knew that she was still on the other side of the door waiting for me to leave. This was my last chance to talk to her before getting on that airplane so I knew anything I wanted to say had to be said right then and there, even if I knew she wouldn’t respond.
“Sarah, if I would have known you didn’t want the open relationship for you, I never would have agreed to it. I was being selfish by leaving you to pursue my dream that I knew I couldn’t continue being selfish making you stay tied down to me. I thought you wanted to see other guys while I was gone and I knew it wasn’t right for me to stop you since you never stopped me from doing anything. When I got back, I tried my hardest to be the boyfriend you used to have but I knew by the way you were acting that our relationship was done. You think you’re just another name on a list but you’re the only one I am going to miss when I step on that plane and head to Dallas. I know you can hear me and I just want you to know that I love you.”
I stood there for a moment hoping she would open the door and things would be okay but there was only silence. I retreated back to my truck and drove back home knowing that that encounter with Sarah could potentially be my last.
**********
Sarah’s P.O.V.
“I sat with my back to the door for an hour after you left. I probably would have sat there the rest of the night if my dad didn’t come home” I confessed to him. It was the first time I ever told him this and you could tell by the look in his face that this just cut deeper in the already salted wound.
"But yes" I continued, "that was the day you first told me you loved me."
All this talking about the past really made me miss the times when life was easy with Jamie. Sure the distance to Kelowna wasn’t ideal but that was nothing compared to everything else that was thrown our way.
**********
After the summer spent together, he had to go back to Kelowna; a time we both knew was approaching. In order to make things easier, we decided that we would be together, but keep our relationship open that way if Jamie found himself celebrating a big win he wouldn’t have to feel guilty about wanting to sleep with a girl.
I was really happy we made that agreement when I saw a girl tag pictures on multiple occasions on Facebook of them looking pretty cozy. Yes, it hurt like hell but I had no reason to be mad because it was my idea to not keep the relationship just between the two of us. I figured if rules were set saying that it was okay, then it wouldn’t hurt as much when he hooked up with a random girl.
After that day I didn’t feel like we were a couple for the rest of the season. We instantly went back to being best friends in my mind and although we never officially “broke up” it was something we both kind of understood.
A few years later he got that call that everyone waits for: he was needed in Dallas in a week.
“Come with me” he said after telling me the news of being called up.
“Jamie, I can’t.”
“Yes you can. You’re my best friend. I can’t move to a new city without my best friend. Please Sarah” he begged.
“My whole life is here. My family, friends, school, it’s all here”
“So I’m not a part of your life anymore?”
“You know that’s not what I mean Jamie. I will go down there for the first game of the season, I will visit as much as I can, and I will be at every game you play in Vancouver, but I can’t just pick up my life and move.”
“You promise you will be at every game you can?”
“Cross my heart and hope to die” I responded smiling. That had always been our little saying. We thought it was so clever back when we first started hanging out and it just had stuck ever since.
***********
“I was crushed when you wouldn’t come with me. I was nervous about the move to begin with but not having you with me made it that much more scary” He confessed before taking a sip of his coffee.
Jamie’s P.O.V.
I still couldn’t blame her for not coming with me the moment I got that call to head to Dallas. She couldn’t just leave like I could. Being a professional athlete, it was something that you knew would happen. You’re nice and comfortable in one city one moment and the next you’re being shipped somewhere new. Although it sucked going from Kelowna to Dallas, it was my dream: I FINALLY got a chance to play in the NHL.
“Do you remember what I told you the day I left for Dallas?” I asked her knowing that she hadn’t forgotten.
“Which part? The part where you were telling me the girls you got with?”
“After that…”
********
It was my last couple of hours in Victoria before heading to Dallas and of course I wanted to spend it with no one else but Sarah. I hadn’t seen her since the day I left for Kelowna and although I had a few last minute things to do, she was my number one priority.
“I really wish you could come with me” I said hoping to guilt her into tagging along.
“You know I want to, but I can’t” she replied. I could see the sadness in her eyes knowing that I would now be even further away.
I sat there for a few moments in silence with her, perfectly content. She broke the silence when she asked me if I would have remained faithful if she didn’t suggest leaving our relationship open when I went to Kelowna for my second season.
“You know I would have, Sarah” I responded after a moment. I was taken aback by the question because it was never brought up until now. “I would never cheat on you.”
“Then why did you replace me?” she asked.
I never could replace her and I thought she knew that. There was no one in the world I would rather have in my life than her and it honestly hurt to think that she thought I could replace her.
“I never replaced you. You’re irreplaceable” I said knowing this was going to lead into a fight – the last thing I wanted today.
“Then why did you start seeing that girl? The one who posted pictures all the time of you guys together.”
“You’re the one who wanted to keep the relationship open. I know I shouldn’t have started to see her, but I did out of spite. I thought ‘hell if Sarah wants to see other guys while I am gone, then I’m going to see other girls too’ and that is just what I did. When I came back home I expected our relationship to be just us but you went back to treating me like your best friend and once again, I knew having you in my life as a friend was better than not having you at all” I responded starting to raise my voice a little.
“If I didn’t suggest for us to keep things open, then I would have been heartbroken when you cheated on me. I thought it would hurt less knowing I wasn’t being cheated on but it hurt just as bad. I spent the rest of the season hearing from everyone that you had your zip code girls and I just knew I deserved better than that. I knew I loved you but I wouldn’t allow myself to be made a fool out of because my boyfriend didn’t love me.”
“I know I made mistakes. I was gone for months while you were back here and while I was gone I did things I shouldn’t have. Things you wouldn’t want to know.”
Right then, as if almost on cue, she stood up and I could tell she was angrier than I’ve ever seen her before. “GET OUT” she yelled pointing towards the door.
“Sar-“
“GET THE HELL OUT OF MY HOUSE JAMIE”
I had no choice but to leave. I hurt her enough and didn’t want to do it anymore. As I was walking to the front door I knew she was following me. The moment I stepped out of the door threshold I turned around just to try to talk to her one last time. Before I was completely facing her, she slammed the door in my face. I fucked up and I knew it.
Knowing Sarah, I knew that she was still on the other side of the door waiting for me to leave. This was my last chance to talk to her before getting on that airplane so I knew anything I wanted to say had to be said right then and there, even if I knew she wouldn’t respond.
“Sarah, if I would have known you didn’t want the open relationship for you, I never would have agreed to it. I was being selfish by leaving you to pursue my dream that I knew I couldn’t continue being selfish making you stay tied down to me. I thought you wanted to see other guys while I was gone and I knew it wasn’t right for me to stop you since you never stopped me from doing anything. When I got back, I tried my hardest to be the boyfriend you used to have but I knew by the way you were acting that our relationship was done. You think you’re just another name on a list but you’re the only one I am going to miss when I step on that plane and head to Dallas. I know you can hear me and I just want you to know that I love you.”
I stood there for a moment hoping she would open the door and things would be okay but there was only silence. I retreated back to my truck and drove back home knowing that that encounter with Sarah could potentially be my last.
**********
Sarah’s P.O.V.
“I sat with my back to the door for an hour after you left. I probably would have sat there the rest of the night if my dad didn’t come home” I confessed to him. It was the first time I ever told him this and you could tell by the look in his face that this just cut deeper in the already salted wound.
"But yes" I continued, "that was the day you first told me you loved me."
Notes
Told you it would be longer :)
Let me know what you think about the story thus far/what you think is going to happen!
They're so cute!!!
5/12/16