Hurricane
Six
Katie wasn’t sure if her eyes were deceiving her – was she looking at the ghost of herself from just a few days ago, or was that Ciara Price wrapped in a white fluffy towel walking out of Tyler’s bathroom? She felt ridiculous holding the coffee and breakfast she had picked up on her way to Tyler’s to surprise him after his first day of early workouts, but apparently she should have called first. When he didn’t answer the door but she found it unlocked, Katie figured he had just fallen back to sleep so she wandered through the apartment to his bedroom to find her new worst nightmare.
“I – I’m sorry…” Katie doubled back on her heels and high-tailed it out of the bedroom, down the hall, through the living room and out the front door much faster than she thought her legs could carry her.
Tyler was climbing the stairs in his building up to his 10th floor apartment, headphones in, hood up, and his phone in his hands. His legs burned from the conditioning he had just endured but he couldn’t get lazy with the elevator now that summer training was in full swing. He started typing a text to Katie that he was home if she wanted to stop by, when she came into sight the next flight up. He was surprised to see her moving so quickly away from his apartment, and with such a sour look on her face. He pulled his earbuds out and prepared to ask her what was wrong when she made the eye contact that she could no longer avoid with him.
“If you’re going to fuck Ciara too, at least have the decency to tell me,” she snarled, storming down the stairs.
Did he hear her right? Tyler felt a wave of confusion wash over him, and Katie was moving so quickly that by the time he tried to catch up with her, she was already on a warpath, moving as fast as she could away from him. But then this disgusting feeling grew in the pit of his stomach, so instead of chasing Katie he climbed the stairs three at a time to get to his place, and see what the fuss was about. He could fix things with Katie later, once he got to the bottom of it.
Tyler walked into his place and found Ciara in just a thong, hair and skin still wet from what appeared to be a recent shower, reaching up into one of the cabinets in the kitchen to grab a cereal box. He tried not to really look at her – which was easy because all he really saw was red. Ciara turned around when she heard the door close behind him, shamelessly standing there almost completely naked.
“You know, your girlfriend should really learn to knock,” Ciara said, and poured the cereal into a bowl.
“What the fuck are you doing here?” Tyler growled, not moving from his post by the door. “And go put some fucking clothes on.”
“Ooh, ouch,” Ciara sarcastically whined, making a fake pouty face. “Did you think I’d be gone long or something?”
Actually yes.
“Seriously, get out of my house.” He didn’t want Ciara meddling in what he had going on with Katie and it seemed like he was just a minute too late to prevent it all from happening.
Ciara poured milk into the bowl and took a bite, crunching loudly. “Fred gave me the key,” she said, still chewing. “Take it up with him.”
Fred didn’t even pay Tyler rent to live there, and he knew that Tyler really liked Katie, so why would he even let Ciara back at their place? And while he was at practice so she could just sneak in and make herself at home? If Freddy was home Tyler probably would’ve handed his ass to him then, but he had no idea where his roommate was. As Ciara stood in his kitchen, every move of her jaw made his body tense, and finally he took large strides to his room, knowing that’s where she was most likely keeping her stuff. Her suitcase was at least 50 pounds but he lifted it more easily than he had hoisted the Stanley Cup, carried it across the house, and set it out in the hallway by the top of the stairs.
“Get the fuck out.”
Katie couldn’t help but let her eyes well with tears as she sat on her couch, thinking about literally everything that came to her mind. How could she be so stupid? Of course Tyler was fucking Ciara too – she had heard all about his disgusting ways when his name would float around during Saturday brunch at the dining hall after a wild night out. He liked to have a good time, and that always involved alcohol and women. So why would she expect him to change just for her - some girl from Maine who had a mangled body and a heart too big to know what to do with. Ciara was blonde, tan, pretty. She didn’t have nasty marks all over her body and she had no problem posing nude on the cover of a magazine. Katie wasn’t those things. She was livid, but not sure if she was angrier with Tyler for living up to his reputation, or with herself for thinking he wasn’t the way he was.
This was the last thing she needed. She had already been heartbroken one too many times recently, and had been through enough shit to last a lifetime, so she should’ve expected Tyler to let her down. How could it even work between the two of them? She would be busy with school and Tyler had a city to defend, pucks to battle for, sluts to cater to. She hated herself for trusting him, for visualizing herself possibly having a place in his future, and him in hers. They had only been friends for a few weeks. Friends, is that what they were? It was the first Wednesday of July and her classes started back up in less than two weeks. She hoped she’d be busy enough to just forget about him.
She thought about the couple of times she had completely given herself up to him and wanted nothing more than to take back the vulnerability she had expressed. She was tough. She was a warrior. She didn’t need him.
She didn’t need him.
“Hey Kate, it’s me. Listen, I just wanted to explain – Freddy let Ciara in while I was at practice. I guess she thought it okay to just make herself at home. There’s nothing going on with her and me. I’m sorry, I had no idea she was there and I wish you didn’t have to deal with that. Give me a call back, let’s get dinner or something.”
Tyler hung up his phone after leaving a voicemail following the third time Katie had failed to pick up her phone. Ciara finally left, unwillingly at best, and he spent a good hour scrubbing the bathroom tile and cleaning the shower. He needed to bleach her out of his life and didn’t want to wait four days for the cleaning lady to do it. He was done with her. So fucking done. He typed out a text to Ciara after he showered in one of the guest rooms, making sure she got the picture.
9:58 AM
Stay away from me. Whatever little thing we had three years ago is done. I’m seeing someone else and if you fuck it up you can bet your washed up ass it won’t be pretty.
Ciara replied back quickly, probably not having even really read the text, with a simple ‘k.’
Tyler tried to nap before his second workout started at 2:30 but he couldn’t stop staring at his phone after he put it on his bedside table. He wanted to keep calling Katie but he knew she was angry enough to ignore him so he resisted every temptation to keep calling and calling until she realized that he was being serious.
He didn't know if Ciara had said anything to Katie or what exactly had gone down between the two of them and that made his thoughts race. He felt guilty that Katie had found Ciara before he had, and if he didn't take the extra 20 minutes talking to Brad about what his next move with Katie should be, then he would've had the situation dealt with and Katie would be in his bed next to him. And that's unfortunately how the situation didn't go. But the one thing he did know is that if he wanted a real shot with Katie, things with Ciara had to be over, and now they were. Brad made it clear that if Katie found out about what exactly went on with him and Ciara, then it would have to be from him and not the playmate.
Too bad nothing went the way it should've, but with nothing to do but just wait for Katie to call him back, he found his eyes growing heavy and eventually drifted off to sleep.
Cora and Megan took turns listening to the voicemail. Katie sat between them and Avery, at their favorite Tapas place on Newbury Street, and rolled her eyes. She knew what she saw and that didn't look like 'nothing.'
"Are you gonna call him back?" Cora looked like she was on Tyler's side after listening to the voicemail for the third time. "At least let him explain everything?"
"I don't know, I'm afraid if I talk to him I'll get too angry," Katie answered, and it was true. She wanted to hurt him as badly as he hurt her, and the best way she knew how at this point was to give him the silent treatment. "Not tonight anyway."
"I know he likes you, Katie. Do you notice the way he looks at you?" Avery chimed in and it seemed like no one was deciding to stick up for her tonight. Before Katie could respond, Avery was changing the subject. "So do we all agree on a Fourth of July party tomorrow?"
Everyone seemed in agreement for the party and Katie volunteered her house as usual, as long as the other girls helped her clean it. They agreed, deciding that since they had recently had a change of plans which involved them not moving in with Katie, then that was fair. Avery and Megan didn't want to invade Katie's space if this thing with Tyler was going to go anywhere so they signed on for another six months at their apartment. If Katie decided she was serious about not forgiving Tyler then they could revisit the living situation in the winter.
They ate dinner and planned the party simultaneously, sending out a mass last minute Facebook event to all of their friends. They had a lot to do to get ready for it, but Katie welcomed the distraction and it would be a good way to celebrate the almost-end of her mini summer break.
Tyler woke up the next morning for practice and resisted the poisonous urge to call Katie. He was disappointed that she didn't call him back yesterday but knew she probably needed space. He knew Katie was a rational person, but she was also a girl, and Tyler tried to put himself in her shoes as she walked into his apartment and found Ciara. He shuddered at the thought, pulled himself out of bed, and got ready to go to Ristuccia Arena in Wilmington where they usually practiced. It was a holiday so the team didn't have an afternoon practice, and Tyler didn't think he'd even be able to push through a second workout with the amount of stuff coursing through his mind.
He went through the motions of practice. They weren't on the ice yesterday for pure dry land conditioning, but he didn't really think much about the amount effort his team was expecting from him or what he should be contributing. His team was frustrated as Tyler fumbled with the puck, missed easy one-timers and seemed completely out of sync as they went through drills and then scrimmaged.
They got off the ice and headed to the locker room to get their gear off. Tyler couldn't rip his off fast enough, and after he showered quickly and packed his bag, he started to walk down the hallway, and Brad caught up with him.
"What happened, man?" Brad could tell it was a Katie thing - Tyler usually never let girl drama bog him down but Katie was different. Hell, if Brad was with her he would feel like shit too if he hurt her. Katie was the type of girl his friend needed, and he was going to help him keep her.
"I don't even know, I guess Fred let Ciara crash at our place while I was at the Garden yesterday morning and Katie came over and found her before I got home."
Tyler pushed the back doors of the practice rink open to fans waiting for them to emerge. He turned it on for them... if they saw an upset Tyler then it probably wouldn't go over well, so he and his liney happily signed jerseys and shirts and took pictures before breaking through the crowd to their cars, where Tyler could talk to Brad without the chaos of eager fans.
"Are you serious? Dude, tell Freddy to get the hell out. He doesn't pay you to live there, like hell he's gonna fuck things up between you and Katie." Brad leaned against his Range Rover while Tyler rested against the Maserati. It was convenient that they had parked next to each other.
Tyler knew he'd have to talk to Freddy, but his roommate didn't come home last night, or at all yesterday while Tyler was there so he wasn’t sure exactly when that was going to happen. Fred was one of his best friends, and he didn't want to have to ask him to leave. It would create a weird tension between them, and Freddy would get pissed if it was all 'because of a girl' even though it wasn't. It was about a Playmate, and she was nothing like the girl he wanted to be with.
"I know. I can't just tell him to leave, he's my best friend. But I don't know why he would let Ciara have the spare key."
"Well then find out why." Brad had a simple way of doing things and maybe that's what Tyler needed to do. "But girl drama aside, what are you doing tonight?"
Tyler had almost forgotten it was the Fourth of July. "Uh, you tell me I guess."
"Get the situation with Freddy figured out, pull yourself together, then meet at my place at 9."
Avery and Cora hung red and blue streamers and big-bulbed white Christmas lights around the living room. The furniture was pushed aside and breakables were stashed to make room for a dance floor and Megan hung a bunch of little American flags around the first floor. Numerous other decorations littered the house and Katie got to work filling the downstairs bathtub up with ice, settling 30 racks of PBR and Sam Adams into it. She had more cases of beer on the back burner in the coat closet. A few bottles of cheap champagne, handles of Absolut and a couple boxes of Franzia were already hidden in Katie's bathtub upstairs. The hard, good stuff was for her and the girls, the guys and everyone else could deal with beer unless they brought their own alcohol.
"So how many people are coming, exactly?" Katie had let Avery take over the day-of planning and just listened to the orders she barked.
"I don't know, it's our friends though. You'll know everyone here."
It’s my house, I better know everyone here, she thought.
Their friend Jake came to set up his speakers and laptop for music at around 9 and everyone started to trickle in around 10. Katie did know mostly everyone, but as soon as the lights turned off it was hard to tell exactly who was who and as she started to increase her drink count, she didn’t really care. Jake was a great DJ and their friend Will was helping him.
Avery knew how to put together a party, alright. Music pumped throughout the house, everyone had a drink in each hand, and no one felt too awkward to dance. A lot of their friends from BU made it, and it was nice to see so many of them before they started up their real-life jobs after graduating. But the decorations were fantastic, everyone was dressed in red, white and blue, or anything along the America theme suggested by the holiday and the Facebook invitation, and it was getting sloppy kind of quickly, which was certainly okay.
Katie left the makeshift dance floor of her living room around 11:30 to go up to her bathroom to grab a bottle of André. She had stuck with mostly vodka and the concoction in the kitchen that Avery referred to as jungle juice but it was more like gasoline, and was ready for the bubbly. She had something to celebrate, and she tried to figure out exactly what that was – Being single? Alive? Realizing Tyler Seguin was an asshole like she had heard? She decided to drink to all of it, and popped the bottle open before she made it back down the stairs.
She walked down the narrow hallway back to the main area of her first floor when Cora stopped her midway.
“Katie, I just want to let you know that it wasn’t my idea. It wasn’t my idea at all.” Cora’s hands were on Katie’s shoulders and all she wanted to do was drink out of her bottle of champagne while she danced on her marble countertops. Why was Cora telling her this?
“What wasn’t your idea?” Katie asked, trying to push past her, but Cora held her there.
“Katie please, just don’t freak.”
She moved past her until she had a visual on the heart of the party and realized everyone had pretty much stopped what they were doing, and were looking at three guys standing with their backs to Katie. Avery’s eyes found Katie’s from across the room with an apologetic look, but Katie didn’t dare enter the living room. The guy that stood in the middle noticed the exchange of expressions as he stood in front of Avery and turned around, locking his perfect caramel colored eyes with Katie’s.
Fuck.
10/21/13