Login with:

Facebook

Twitter

Tumblr

Google

Yahoo

Aol.

Mibba

Your info will not be visible on the site. After logging in for the first time you'll be able to choose your display name.

If I Saw You Now

Reunited Part 2

They kissed until Jamie slipped his hand too far up Livy’s thigh for her comfort. She broke their kiss and leaned back against the tall booth. “We’re in public, Jame,” she said breathlessly.
Jamie took a deep breath before apologizing. “I’ve been waiting so long to see you again.” He took a sip of water and said, “I’m sorry.”

Livy watched him fidget nervously with the wine cork the waiter had left on the table and she grinned. “I’m flattered.”

His face brightened as the nervousness was quickly replaced with a hint of mischief. “Yeah?” he asked and leaned in to kiss her on the cheek.

“Yeah,” Livy whispered as Jamie kissed down to her neck. He felt her stifle a moan with a hard swallow and smiled into her neck before kissing his way up to her ear. “Have I told you how beautiful you are?” He asked quietly. She nodded to affirm that he had and gripped his thigh tightly under the table in an attempt to keep her hands from roaming. “Good,” he breathed across her ear before kissing her earlobe gently and pulling away. Once again, Livy found herself trying to catch her breath. Jamie smiled knowingly at her, rested his hand on her thigh, and began to rub soft circles with his thumb.

They’d finished appetizers, dinner, two bottles of wine, and dessert. There was no reason for them to stay at the restaurant any longer, but Livy didn’t want to leave. She was afraid of what might happen if he took her home at that point. She did not want them to end up in bed together. Okay, that was a lie; she very much wanted to end up in bed with Jamie, but not the first time seeing him in so many years. They’d been apart for so long that she considered their meeting as a first date. A first date on which she’d already broken so many of ‘the rules’ of first dates, of course, but it was still a first date. Sort of.

“I feel awful, I haven’t even asked about your family,” she said with a too bright smile that had ’let’s not have sex in this booth right now’ written all over it.

Jamie laughed at Livy’s obvious attempt to steer the direction of their evening away from sex. “Okay, Liv, I get it,” he said.

“Well, I haven’t,” she said with a shrug. More seriously, she added, “Your mom. Does she hate me?”

“What? No way,” he answered quickly. “Hell, I think she’s still grieving the loss of her fourth kid.” Jamie rolled his eyes in mock jealousy.

“Stop it, really?” Livy had loved Jamie’s mom so much. His mother was the only adult she had ever truly trusted, the only adult who made her feel like everything really would be okay, and Livy was still grateful for that.

Jamie sighed before making eye contact with her. “Liv, my family loves you. They know why you thought you had to do what you did,” he said before shaking his head. “They don’t understand it. And I don’t understand it, but your intentions were good, I guess. That was obvious. No hard feelings from them.”

“No hard feelings from them,” she parroted. “But what about from you?” she asked, bracing herself for the post-breakup conversation they’d never had.

“Well, that’s more complicated,” Jamie answered softly.

Livy put her hand over his and said, “Explain it to me.”

“It was basically that you didn’t trust me.”

“That was never the issue, Jame,” she said, giving his hand a squeeze for emphasis.

“You didn’t let me finish,” he said firmly as he removed his hand from hers.

Livy folded her hands in her lap and said, “Sorry.”

“You didn’t trust my feelings for you, Liv. You never did believe that I loved you as much as I did.” His use of the past tense shot right through her, the pain harsh and stinging. “And I don’t know why. I have no idea why you never believed me.” He shook his head and calmed slightly before continuing. “I tried to show you all the time, you know. I really tried to break through that fucking insecurity of yours,” he said, shaking his head. Jamie leaned back from the table and sighed before adding, “It was never enough for you, I guess. You took the fucking easy way out,” And there it was. There was the anger Livy had been expecting from him for years but he’d never expressed before then.

“You think that was easy?” She asked incredulously. Her head was spinning with a million thoughts at once as she wanted to make things clear to him – wanted to make things better.
Jamie shrugged dismissively and said, “It sure looked easy the way you walked out of my room and never looked back. The way you left me there crying and alone.”

She kept her eyes wide and unblinking to deny the tears that so desperately wanted to fall. “I walked away from the best thing in my life so he could have a better life than he ever could have had with me around.”

“You act like it was some grand, selfless gesture.” He said before finishing the remains of his wine. “You don’t always get to be the martyr, you know.”

The hate behind his words stunned her. It was as if he was downplaying the abuse she’d suffered for so many years of her life. She never once used her situation to gain sympathy. At her core, she was certain Jamie knew that about her. She’d hurt him and he was lashing out. So many years of therapy helped her recognize that quickly. She took a deep breath and let it go. “It was hard on me, too, Jamie,” she said as calmly as possible.

Even though she knew it needed to be done, Livy wished she’d never changed the subject. She had once again, ruined something perfect between them.

“You gave up, Liv. You never even gave us a chance to fail. You decided we’d fail and acted as if it were written in fucking stone. That’s weak.”

She gave up trying to keep up appearances and let her tears fall. “You’re right,” she admitted as the tears finally streamed down her cheeks. “You are right, and I’m so, so sorry.” They sat quietly for just a few moments before she added, “You deserved better.” Jamie nodded but said nothing.

“I’m going to the restroom to compose myself. I’ll understand if you’re not here when I get out,” Livy said before grabbing her bag and scooting out of the booth.

In the restroom, she locked herself in a stall and cried for several minutes as she thought about their conversation. Jamie had every right to be angry with her, and she knew that. On one hand, she was glad his anger was coming to the surface. It was better to get it out in the open before they had a chance to get too deeply involved again. On the other hand, their night together had been so perfect. It had been exactly what she’d been dreaming of for years and she hated the sour turn it had taken. Just as she told Jamie she would, she composed herself before leaving the stall and standing in front of the mirror. After using a damp paper towel to calm the redness of her eyes and cheeks, she reapplied her makeup. Before entering the dining room of the restaurant, she prepared herself for the possibility of seeing an empty booth where Jamie once sat. She’d given him that option, after all.

There he was, though. He was still there for her. Jamie stood up from the booth and opened his arms, inviting her into his embrace. Livy hurried over to him and wrapped her arms around him. They stood like that for several minutes before he rubbed her back and said, “We’re done here. Let’s go.” Livy nodded as he took her hand and led her out of the restaurant.

Jamie handed his ticket to the valet before draping his arm around Livy’s shoulders. “We’re good, yeah?” he said and placed a kiss to the top of her head.

She wrapped her arms tightly around his waist and nodded. “Thank you, Jame,” she said. He squeezed her more tightly into his side before they separated to get into his car.

The ride to Livy’s apartment was silent as they were both lost in thought and exhausted from the emotional roller coaster of their reunion. Jamie pulled to a stop in front of her building, and turned to face her. “Goodnight, Liv.”

“Goodnight, Jame,” she said, placing her hand on his shoulder. “Thank you for tonight.”

“Yeah, right,” he huffed with a smile.

“No, really,” she said. “This is exactly what we needed. It had to happen.” Jamie nodded. She added, “Thank you for a great night. I hope you call me again.”

He leaned over and gave her a chaste kiss on the cheek. “You can count on it.”

Livy smiled and nodded before hopping out of his car and disappearing into her building.

Notes

Thank you, thank you, thank you for reading, voting, and subscribing. Thank you especially for comments! Comments make this so much more rewarding. Let me know what you think. :)

Comments

I'm so happy you updated!!!!! I'm not so happy about Benny boy being a cheating douchebag. God damn it Jamie!!!! And I just reread the last chapter again to see what had happened last time. He told her he didn't need to chase other women, and this is true. That he only, willingly needed and wanted to chase her. And he loves her and only her. What the fuck Jamie Benn?!?!?!? This is going to break Livy... Please update soon. Preferably not after 2 months or so. ;)

CavalierDrummer CavalierDrummer
2/11/16

Agreed with lovexpink. STUPID JAMIE! This is going to crush Livy... Ugh.

I'm so happy you updated!!

tigercat13 tigercat13
2/11/16

STUPID, STUPID JAMIE

lovexpink
2/11/16

Ok hi!!! I love this!!!!

addiegregory addiegregory
12/9/15

WOW this was great I'm loving all these updates!!

lovexpink
12/5/15