If I Saw You Now
In the Eye of the Beholder
“It doesn’t matter what they think, Livy,” Hannah reminded her friend for approximately the one hundredth time since they’d been on the phone. “I don’t know what else to tell you at this point.” She’d been trying to calm, reassure, and just generally talk some sense into Livy about her fear of meeting Jamie’s teammates. She was at her wits’ end.
“I’m sorry,” Livy said. “I guess you’re right.”
“You don’t have to guess, Livy. There’s no guesswork here. Jamie doesn’t care what other people think. He’s proven it to you time and time again.”
Livy nodded to herself before saying, “Okay, I won’t go on about it anymore.” She listened to her friend’s sigh of relief before adding, “I just don’t want it to cause tension for them.”
“Oh. My. God!” Hannah yelped. “Jamie’s a big boy. If your description of him is anything to go on, he’s a very big boy.” She paused as Livy giggled. “He’ll be fine, Livy, he’ll be just fine. Don’t you dare ruin this because you’re worried about what people think. Because if this causes an issue, I can guarantee it’ll be on you, not him.”
---
Jordie, Tyler, and Jason were already seated when Jamie made his way into the restaurant. Jason started waving his arms over his head wildly to get Jamie’s attention.
“Pretty sure he sees us, Daddy. Take it down a notch or seven, will ya?” Jordie said, shaking his head.
Jamie was barely seated before Jason started in on him. “Sooo,” he said with a grin, his blue eyes twinkling with excitement, “your date - how’d it go?”
Jamie ducked his head slightly. “It went okay.”
Jason looked positively crestfallen at the less than juicy response. “That’s it? It went okay?” he asked.
Tyler prodded, “C’mon, Chubbs. You showed up super late for your date and, judging by the repeat performance of your outfit from yesterday, you got to stay the night. Tell us how your magic works. Teach us your ways with women.”
Jamie blushed. “It was good.” Jordie seemed satisfied, but Tyler and Jason continued to stare at their captain waiting for more. “Jeez, guys, you don’t care about this.”
“That’s where you’re wrong,” Jason said, pointing his finger at Jamie. “We care very much. Tell us about this mystery woman who’s swept you - Mr. Forever Single - off your feet in just a few days.”
“Not a few days,” Jordie stepped in to give his brother a break. “They dated in high school, idiot. You knew that.”
“I did?” Jason asked, obviously having forgotten Jamie’s speech at the bar the night before.
Jamie breathed a sigh of relief as the waiter came to take their order. He hoped the subject would change after they’d ordered. He had no such luck as Jason started right back in when the waiter took their menus and left. “Friend from high school? So she’s here visiting you?”
“She just moved here for work. Well, about a month ago now, I guess.” Jamie answered.
“What’s she do?” Tyler asked.
Jamie grinned thinking of her. “Historic preservation.” His answer was met with blank stares so he continued. “Like saving old buildings.”
“Whoa, so she chains herself to them to stop bulldozers and shit?” Jason asked excitedly.
“How have you even survived into adulthood?” Jordie wondered and Jason looked hurt.
“No,” Jamie answered, “she works to get them, um, registered as historic places so they can’t tear them down to build new ones. I guess so they have to restore them instead.” He shook his head realizing how little he knew of her work. “She tries to get grants for them and stuff.”
Tyler couldn’t stand it anymore and asked the one thing that had been on his mind since Jamie made it clear the morning after their first date that Livy was not, in fact, hot, “Do you have pictures? What’s she look like?”
Eyes wide with excitement, Jason pulled his own phone from his pocket, “Yeah. What’s her Insta?”
Jamie’s face was beyond blush, he’d gone to full red as he answered, “She doesn’t have one.” He didn’t add that I know of, but he thought it. He suddenly thought of so many things he no longer knew about her.
“No Instagram?” Tyler asked incredulously. “Wow. Okay.”
“I’m not surprised,” Jordie offered. “That doesn’t sound like Livy. It’s probably not her kind of thing.”
His impatience evident, Jason pointed at Jordie and declared, “That’s right! You know her. Jordie, tell us everything he won’t.”
Jordie shot a quick look over to his brother, Jamie nodded his permission before Jordie said, “I haven’t seen her since she’s been in Dallas, but she’s nice. She’s a nice kid.”
“She’s not a kid,” Jamie mumbled under his breath.
“Yeah, okay, she’s not a kid anymore, I guess. But in high school, she was smart. She was just as shy as this one but way smarter.” He shoved Jamie’s shoulder playfully. Jamie’s smile encouraged Jordie to continue. “They were inseparable. Kinda gross, actually, how into each other they were.” Jamie’s smile widened at the memories coming back to him of those four years with Livy.
Tyler was already bored with the fluff, he wanted juicy. “So if you guys were so perfect, what happened? Why’d you break it off?”
“I didn’t,” Jamie said quietly, “she did. She broke up with me.”
That kind of detail was more Tyler’s speed. He was unabashedly excited at the prospect of drama. “No shit? What’d you do?” His smiled slyly at Jamie, “Did you cheat on her, Chubbs? You player.”
“No!” Jamie snapped. “I wouldn’t. I didn’t ever do that.”
Jason was starting to feel for his captain. “Wow, Chubbs. You still hurting over that break up?”
Jordie took over. “She left, just walked out. It wasn’t as dramatic as you guys are hoping for, okay? She thought she was doing him a favor. Honestly, she was probably right.”
With a pained expression, Jamie looked at his brother. “The hell, Jordie? She was not. She was not right.”
Jason looked at Tyler, obviously uncomfortable.
Jamie was too focused on his feeling of perceived betrayal at Jordie’s comments to care that they had an audience. “Why would you say that?”
Jordie sighed. “You needed to pay attention to hockey, Jamie. Your career. You wouldn’t have focused like you needed to if you had to worry about defending her all the time. How many fights did you get into?” Jason and Tyler’s eyes widened at that new information.
“Fights?” Tyler asked.
“Defending her?” Jason asked over Tyler’s question.
Obviously mad, Jamie said, “Go on, Jordie, tell them everything. Tell them what you really think,” before leaning back in his chair and folding his arms over his chest.
Jordie knew Jamie was pissed, knew he wished they’d drop it. But he also knew this was the perfect time to introduce the subject. The four men at that table were the closest on the team. These were Jamie’s hockey brothers. He liked and got along with everyone on the team of course, as their captain and their teammate. At the lunch table that day sat his true hockey family. If Jordie could plant this seed with Tyler and Jason, it would make everything easier for Jamie from then on out. So he did what he felt he had to do, he prepared to spill everything about Livy and her insecurities and Jamie’s fierce, protective love for her.
Just as Jordie decided he needed to give the guys more detail, their food arrived. The table fell quiet as they prepared their food and began eating. Eventually, Jordie spoke. “Jamie, let me tell them okay?” He nodded and gave Jamie a look that said ’It’ll be okay.’ before he began.
“First things first - Jamie loves her,” Jordie started. Jamie stopped eating and stared at Jordie. It wasn’t what he’d expected to hear, and he grinned realizing he should have known to trust his brother more than he had. Jordie continued, “Like, Jamie loves Livy more than he loves himself, and that’s why she left.”
Tyler groaned. “Great job, Darth. That’s really sweet, compelling storytelling, dude, but just give us the facts.” All four of them laughed, and Jamie was glad for it. He really didn’t want their lunch to become a chick flick.
Jordie nodded, “Okay, then, let me bottom line it for you simpletons. Livy doesn’t look like what you’re probably expecting. I mean, I haven’t seen her in several years so maybe she’s changed.”
Jamie shook his head slightly, “Not really. She mostly looks like I remember her.”
“Okay, then,” Jordie said, nodding. “She doesn’t look like most of the WAGs you’re used to seeing, okay? Livy’s not being offered modeling contracts, or anything. Understand?”
Tyler and Jason looked uncomfortable. They wondered if they were about to witness a fight like Jordie’d described Jamie having so often in the past. Instead, Jamie smiled and said, “No, she doesn’t look like a model. She’s beautiful.”
Jason and Tyler’s confusion at that statement faded as they watched Jamie continue to smile thinking about her.
“Hey, man,” Jason said, “I’m happy for you. I really hope it works this time.”
Tyler, on the other hand, needed a little more clarification. “So the fights? They were because…”
Jamie cut him off, finally feeling comfortable enough to provide the information for himself rather than depending on Jordie, “Guys used to always chirp me about my…,” he paused and pursed his lips before continuing. “They’d chirp me about my dumpy girlfriend. Telling me I didn’t have to settle and shit, like because I was captain and I deserved better. I wasn’t settling,” he said firmly. “I never had to settle with Liv. She was – she still is – everything I could ever ask for, okay?” He paused for a second to calm down again. “Does she take everyone’s breath away when she walks into the room? No. But she takes mine.” He nodded to himself thinking about her.
The table fell silent at Jamie’s admission. It was a much, much heavier conversation than they usually shared at Saturday lunches. Jordie sensed the tension and smiled. “Make no mistake, boys. Jamie will beat the life out of anyone who questions this. Teammate or not, he doesn’t care, he’ll kill you. I’ve seen it happen a million times. No one had better ever talk shit about Livy.”
Jason and Tyler seemed to be waiting for the laugh, the punchline. Instead Jamie nodded and said, “He’s right. I will.”
Notes
So many new subscribers! Thank you all! Hey, I hate to sound like a broken record, but don't be afraid to leave a comment. I can't tell you how much comments help. Thanks for reading!!
I'm so happy you updated!!!!! I'm not so happy about Benny boy being a cheating douchebag. God damn it Jamie!!!! And I just reread the last chapter again to see what had happened last time. He told her he didn't need to chase other women, and this is true. That he only, willingly needed and wanted to chase her. And he loves her and only her. What the fuck Jamie Benn?!?!?!? This is going to break Livy... Please update soon. Preferably not after 2 months or so. ;)
2/11/16