If I Saw You Now
Goodbye My Friend
The next time Livy went to Jamie’s house, his mother took the opportunity to speak with Livy when Jamie went to the restroom. “Livy,” she asked gently, “could I talk to you about something?”
Livy froze just like she did whenever she was put in a position to have to speak with an adult, but she managed a nod that encouraged Jamie’s mom to continue. “Jamie told me about Rick.” The look on Livy’s face was a mixture of embarrassment and fear. Jamie’s mom moved closer to her and said, “It’s okay, honey. I don’t want to make anything harder for you or your mom, okay. I promise you that. Trust me?”
The tone in her voice softened Livy. It was the motherly tone Livy had dreamt about hearing from her own mother. Her own mother, however, was too stressed and busy to ever have that tone in her voice. Livy wanted to hear Jamie’s mom talk like that, she craved it. She nodded and Jamie’s mom felt confident about pressing the subject.
Just as Livy imagined most moms would, Jamie’s mom reached over and rubbed her back as she spoke softly. “I want you to know that we’re here for you. If you ever need us, honey, we’re here. Okay?” Livy nodded and finally looked Mrs. Benn in the eyes. “You have a place to come if you ever need it. Do you understand what I’m saying?”
“Yes, ma’am, I do,” Livy answered. “Thank you.”
Jamie’s mom wrapped her arms around Livy and said, “You don’t need to thank me, sweetie, just promise me that you’ll always be honest and let us know if you ever need anything.” Livy nodded into Mrs. Benn’s shoulder and tried not to cry. “Anything at all,” she added, “we’re here for you, Livy.”
Livy’s voice was small and especially childlike as she spoke into Mrs. Benn’s shoulder. “Please don’t tell anyone.” Jamie’s mother’s heart broke at the sound of it.
“I can’t promise that,” she said honestly. “But I want you to know that you’re not alone anymore. We’re here for you.” Livy couldn’t hold back her tears any longer. She cried quietly as Jamie’s mom added, “If I feel like you and your mom need help, I’ll do what I have to do to see that you get it.” Livy nodded and hugged his mother more tightly.
“What happened?” Jamie asked as he reentered the kitchen. “I was gone for five minutes.” He gently pulled Livy from his mother’s arms and hugged her himself. “What’d you do, Mom?” a look of accusation on his face as he waited for her answer.
“She didn’t do anything,” Livy said into Jamie’s chest before ending their hug and wiping tears from her cheeks. “It’s good, Jamie.” She smiled at his mom before adding, “Everything’s going to be okay.” His mom nodded at her and smiled before leaving the two of them alone.
Livy looked up at Jamie and said, “You’re lucky to have her, you know. You’re lucky to have this whole family. I hope you really appreciate them, Jame.”
Pulling her back into his arms, he assured her, “I do. I mean, I will.” She squeezed him even more tightly as he said for the first time, “I love you, Livy.”
Livy looked up into his eyes, losing herself in their warmth and earnest honesty before she said, “Thank you.”
With a smile, Jamie said, “I don’t want you to thank me, Liv, I want you to love me back.”
She smiled back at him and said, “I love you, too, Jamie. I’ve never felt safer or more loved in my life.” Before he leaned down to kiss her, she again said, “Thank you.” He kissed her sweetly before resting his forehead against hers.
That was the turning point. That’s when Livy’s visits to the Benn home became less silent. That’s when she took a huge step into the accepting realm of the Benn family. And, just as Jamie planned, he and Livy remained inseparable through high school. His teammates never did understand his attraction to the ‘dumpy’ girl, but they learned not to voice their opinions in front of him.
***
The growth spurt Jamie experienced during the summer before their senior year was truly remarkable and did not go unnoticed by the girls at their school. Livy was quiet but she was neither deaf nor blind. She saw the looks Jamie was suddenly getting from other girls – beautiful girls, the popular girls. She heard the whispers of disbelief about her relationship with the boy who was now the captain of the hockey team. Livy hadn’t been so physically lucky over the summer. She was still much shorter and rounder than she would have liked. Luckily for her, Jamie seemed oblivious to the attention he was getting from other girls. It seemed his amazing growth spurt was noticeable to everyone but him. He held himself no differently and was still awkward and painfully shy. The only place his personality had blossomed was on the ice while fulfilling the duties of team captain.
Livy attended all of Jamie’s home games and traveled with his family to away games whenever she was able. Unlike Jamie, Livy hadn’t accomplished anything extraordinary, nothing that would boost her self-confidence. She even refrained from wearing his number in the stands at his games. Wearing his number attracted unwanted attention from female classmates. She reasoned with herself that sitting with his family was enough to make it clear that she was there to support him. He knew why she was there and that was enough. Having his name stitched across the back of her jersey was unnecessary and not having his name there allowed her to enjoy the game without being the target of stares and whispers.
As their senior year went on, Livy and Jamie explored their options for the future. Jamie was offered a full hockey scholarship to the University of Alaska, so she applied there at his urging. She wasn’t in love with the idea of going to university in Alaska, but she did want to keep all options open.
Once she was accepted to U of Alaska, Jamie spoke of their future together at the school as a certainty. Livy was much less certain. Despite his never giving her a reason to think so, she believed she was holding him back. In her mind, Jamie deserved much more, much better, than she could offer, and it was only a matter of time before he would realize that. She didn’t want to be around when he finally figured it out. No, going to university together was not a good idea in her mind. Jamie needed space and time to take advantage of all he deserved. He deserved beautiful girls. He deserved flings. He deserved all the things that came as a result of the tireless effort he put in to excel at hockey and to become, as Livy thought, a perfect physical specimen. Livy was not those things. She was soft and squishy, not toned or defined.
On top of those fears, Livy felt increasingly guilty about leaving her mother. Spending so much time with the Benn family left her mother to fend for herself more than Livy was comfortable with. Her mother had assured her that it was okay, that she was relieved Livy had found a safe place with the Benns, but that didn’t make Livy feel better. Her little brother told her how much worse things had gotten in Livy’s absence with their mother taking all of Rick’s angry focus. She knew she had to make a decision - she had to either be there for her mother always or never. As a backup plan, Livy applied for school in the United States at the University of Vermont. She kept her acceptance and the full need-based scholarship she was awarded a secret.
Livy’s opinions about holding Jamie back from bigger and better things were validated at their Senior Prom when she stood off to the side and watched as her boyfriend of three years ascended the steps to the stage to accept the title of Prom King. With a painful smile on her face, Livy kept her eyes wide and unblinking in an effort to deny the tears that threatened to fall as she watched him dance with the Prom Queen. Dancing together, they looked to Livy like a couple out of a magazine. They were both tall and proportioned. They were both accomplished in the high school universe. He deserved that. That’s where Jamie belonged, she decided. She found herself rooting for him to ‘get the girl’ even though that girl wasn’t her. He belonged with the best of the best and she knew that wasn’t who she was. Yes, she decided, she would definitely be attending the University of Vermont.
The week after prom, they had ‘the talk’. “I’m not going to Alaska,” she said as they lay on his bed in each other’s arms.
Jamie sat up quickly. “What?” A look of confusion consumed his face. “What do you mean?”
Livy stood up from his bed and said, “I can’t go to Alaska.”
Shaking his head in disbelief, he asked, “Why? Your mom won’t let you go? That’s not fair, Livy. She needs to know you need to get away.”
She took a deep breath before she said, “It was my decision, not hers.”
Jamie stood up from the bed and said, “Why? You can’t stay here, Livy. You just can’t. Your family’s a fucking train wreck.”
Taking a step back from him, she nodded and said, “I know. I know that.” Finally looking him in the eyes, she said, “I’m not staying here.”
“So what?” he asked loudly, “What then?”
“I’m going to the University of Vermont.”
He shook his head in disbelief and said, “What? That’s, like, as far from Alaska as possible? What the hell, Liv?”
“They gave me a full scholarship.”
“So did Alaska,” Jamie snapped angrily.
She couldn’t look at him anymore, the pain in his eyes was too much for her to handle. Looking down to the floor, she said, “We shouldn’t be together anymore, Jame.”
Jamie sat on the edge of the bed as quickly as if someone had pushed him and asked, “You’re breaking up with me?”
Livy nodded. “That’s the best thing for you.” She paused before adding, “For us.”
“How?” he asked. “How is this the best?” The tone of his voice was pained, his eyes were pleading for answers. The whole scene was killing her, but she knew she had to stay strong.
“It just is, Jame. Trust me.”
“I can’t trust you right now, Liv, you’re being insane.” He shook his head and added, “I love you. This doesn’t make sense.”
“You’ll be better for it,” she said quietly. “This is the best thing for you.”
“Stop saying that!” He shouted. “Stop saying this is the best thing for me. It’s not!”
Livy sat beside him on the bed and said quietly, “Please don’t yell, Jame. Please.”
Jamie rolled his eyes and said, “No. I can’t help it. You’re killing me, here, Liv.” He took a deep breath and said, “I deserve a fucking explanation.”
“You’re better than this, Jamie. You’re going to do great things with your life,” she paused before adding unconvincingly, “Maybe I will, too, but we won’t do those things together.”
He knew she was insecure, knew that she didn’t understand their relationship. Suddenly things started clicking with him. “If you're pushing me away because you don't want me, fine. Tell me that. But if you're pushing me away for my own good or whatever other bullshit reason you think is protecting me from something, stop it. Just fucking stop it because it's not working. You're not protecting me, you're killing me.” He began to cry quietly.
Her stomach in knots, she whispered, “I'm sorry, Jame. I'm so sorry.”
“Don't be sorry," he said, his voice cracking with emotion rawer than he'd ever known. He sniffed and looked into her eyes. "Just stop doing it, Liv." In a whisper, he added, "Please."
Shaking her head, she stood and walked out of his room, out of his house, and out of his life.
Notes
The song this chapter title was based on can be heard here: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=tunFhCeOxA4
Thank you for reading! As usual, comments and feedback make me happy. :)
I'm so happy you updated!!!!! I'm not so happy about Benny boy being a cheating douchebag. God damn it Jamie!!!! And I just reread the last chapter again to see what had happened last time. He told her he didn't need to chase other women, and this is true. That he only, willingly needed and wanted to chase her. And he loves her and only her. What the fuck Jamie Benn?!?!?!? This is going to break Livy... Please update soon. Preferably not after 2 months or so. ;)
2/11/16