Truth or Dare
Truth or Dare
“Kaitlin! Kaitlin! Open up! Kaitlin!”
Between the fists pounding on the door, the non-stop ringing of the doorbell and the two voices hollering my name, I am going to kill someone. Today had been long – excruciatingly long – and I do not have the patience to deal with two absolutely wasted boys trying to bust down my front door at 1AM. Not even if they are two of the best hockey players in the world. Not to mention my best friends. Nope, I am going to kill them.
“Jamie Benn and Tyler Seguin, you’re going to get the cops called on me,” I say with a hiss, flinging the door open. It’s chilly for early spring in Texas, and I am dressed in a pair of running shorts and a thin t-shirt. Gooseflesh instantly races up my bare arms.
“You weren’t answering your phone,” Jamie says like it’s a perfectly valid excuse. Apparently it never occurred to him I might have been ignoring my phone for a reason. “Tyler got kicked out of the club,” he adds.
My gaze shifts from Jamie and his doe eyes and aw-shucks grin to his accomplice who is currently leaning against my porch railing, sporting a cat-who-ate-the-canary grin. For someone who’d only days before kicked the proverbial hornet nest by getting scratched from the last game of the season, getting kicked out of clubs was the last thing Tyler needed to be seen doing. And the look on his face tells me he is entirely too proud of himself for doing it.
“I… Do I even want to know?” I ask, shaking my head in disbelief. Before he can answer, I take a step back into the house and motion for them to come inside. Something tells me I might end up yelling in a second, and I really, really do not want to deal with police officers tonight.
“I punched him,” Tyler says with a smirk as I latch the door.
“You punched who?” I ask, spinning on my toes, my long brunette locks whipping around my shoulders as I do. Dear god, please don’t say Brandon, please don’t say Brandon, I silently plead.
“Brandon.” Mother. Fucker.
“Damn it Tyler, please tell me you’re kidding,” I say, sitting down on one of the bar stools along my kitchen island and bury my head in my hands. Maybe if I can’t physically see him, it can’t be true.
“Nope, totally serious. The piece of shit had it coming,” he says with zero remorse in his voice. I can hear the sounds of him rummaging through my refrigerator followed by the distinctive “pop-pop-pop” of beers being opened and then a cold glass bottle is pressed against my arm. I can hear Jamie and Tyler clink their own bottles and then the sound of my TV turning on in the living room. Picking my head up, I look around my now-empty kitchen and sigh. So much for a quiet night alone.
I guess now is a good time to explain a few things. Brandon is my fiancé. Well, now ex-fiancé. We had been the epitome of a power couple: him a well-established real estate lawyer, me finishing up my final year of residency. More importantly, I had been certain he was The One. Imagine my surprise when I’d come home to find him balls deep in his secretary in our bed. There’d been screaming and yelling, a thrown book or two and threats of cutting off certain parts of his anatomy. I wasn’t proud of it but given the circumstances I’d say my reaction was understandable. But the worst part of everything was his reaction. Instead of apologizing and begging for forgiveness, Brandon had simply shrugged his shoulders and told me I needed to get over it. I told him I would get over it the day he dropped dead.
And thus ended our engagement.
My plan had been to mope. I would spend a few days in bed, wearing pajamas and watching Gilmore Girls, eating ice cream and washing it down with a bottle of wine before getting on with the nasty business of informing friends and family the wedding was off. It’s probably what would have happened, too, but I’d made the mistake of telling Jamie what had happened in a text message. He’d been trying to get me to go out with him and some of the team to blow off some steam before they cleared out for the summer, and I stupidly thought telling him the love of my life had smashed my heart to pieces would have been enough get him to leave me alone.
Obviously not.
“Kaitlin. Drink your beer, stop pouting and come join us,” Tyler’s voice drifts into the kitchen. I pick up the beer bottle, eyeing it like it might be dangerous, and then decide “fuck it,” tossing my head back and take a long, long gulp. What’s the worst that can happen now?
The moment I see Kaitlin, I’m instantly struck with two thoughts. One, how amazingly gorgeous she is with her long wavy brown hair with golden highlights and espresso-colored eyes, the dimple on her cheek and her bright red lips which formed the perfect pout. My second thought is maybe coming here was a bad idea. Upon further inspection, I can see her eyes are rimmed red from crying, and it looks like she hasn’t slept in a few days. She’s wearing the smallest pair of running shorts I have ever seen and a plain white t-shirt. I look away once it becomes evident in the cool air she is not wearing a bra. She was clearly not expecting company and is looking at us like we’re the enemy. Even then, I still have to control myself from rushing over and wrapping her up in my arms. Instead, I do my best to play it cool.
“You weren’t answering your phone,” I say. I know it sounds lame, so I quickly add, “Tyler got kicked out of the club.” This last bit seems to do the trick, and Kaitlin shoos us into the house. I’m glad for the moment to have the attention shifted off me as Tyler tells her about how he punched her scumbag of an ex-fiancé.
The guy had truly deserved it. We knew Brandon through Kaitlin but never really considered him more than an acquaintance. For one, he was kind of a prick, always bragging about something great he did, and well, I have my other reasons for not liking the guy much. Still, we tolerated him when he came along with Kaitlin to various events out of respect for her. She saw something in him, and that was all that mattered. Is it wrong to say I was relieved when she told me he’d cheated on her? I don’t wish my friend pain, but I won’t lie. I was happy to no longer have to pretend to be nice to him. Finding him at the club with his tongue down some girl’s throat, his hand up her skirt and downright gloating about “getting away” with cheating on Kaitlin for the past year was the final straw. Yeah, he’d deserved it.
Tyler hands me a beer he scavenged from Kaitlin’s fridge, and I follow him into the other room. I can tell she needs a minute to let what Tyler told her sink in.
“Dude, are you sure this is a good idea?” I say as I take a seat on the couch keeping my voice low so she can’t hear me.
Tyler turns on the TV and begins flipping through channels at random. I can’t tell if he’s actually paying attention to what he’s doing or merely pushing buttons out of habit. “Yes. And you know why? That piece of shit doesn’t deserve her tears. Kaitlin should be out having the time of her life, not holing up like a spinster cat lady and increasing Blue Bell’s profits.”
He’s drunk – so am I if I’m being honest – and quickly lapsing into no-filter-mode, but he has a point. She shouldn’t be the one hurting. I smile thinking about the shiner Brandon was going to wake up to in the morning.
“Kaitlin. Drink your beer, stop pouting and come join us,” he hollers, settling the TV on ESPN. A minute later she appears in the doorway of the living room looking small and fragile, and once again I’m forced to acknowledge how badly I want to be the one to comfort her. I’m here though, so hey, that’s a start, right?
Tyler pats the cushion on the couch and as she moves slowly to join us my eyes flit around the room, afraid if I make eye contact with her Kaitlin might see more than just friendly concern in my eyes.
I’ve never really thought about it, but I think I’ve had a crush on Kaitlin since the day we met. It was during my second season with the Stars, and I had the rare Sunday to myself so I took the opportunity to hit up a bar near my place and watch some of the Seahawks game. Kaitlin had been there too, in a Seahawks jersey and cheering loudly, the only other person besides myself not focused on the Cowboys game. It’d taken until nearly the end of the third quarter for me to get the nerve up to speak to her, but in the end I did. The rest, they say, is history.
I don’t know why I never asked her out, maybe because I’ve seen how other men throw themselves at her, and by now, it’s a lost cause. Shortly after I met Kaitlin she started dating Brandon, and I was firmly in the friend zone. She’d seemed happy, so I did my best not to dwell on it. Now though? I feel like it’s taking every ounce of control not to do something I might regret, and I’m pretty sure it’s the reason I agreed to come over here when Tyler suggested it.
Her small frame is pressed up against my leg on the couch, not quite enough room for all three of us to sit without touching, and she smells good. Like vanilla and lavender. Looking nervously around the room I spot a row of brightly colored cards lined up along her fireplace mantel. And then it hits me. How could I be such an idiot and have forgotten?
“Kait,” I blurt out, “Is today your birthday?”
She nods and closes her eyes, clearly trying to hold back tears, and I look over at Tyler at a complete loss for words.
“Okay, that’s it. Enough of this fucking pity party bullshit,” I say with authority. Emotional shit is so not my thing. I don’t think I had a plan per se when I talked Jamie into coming over here, but now I do. It’s Kaitlin’s birthday? And she’s sitting at home crying over some loser douchebag? Oh hell no. It’s now my mission to make sure this girl, who I’ve come to consider one of my best friends, has the time of her life tonight.
Leaving her and Jamie sitting on the couch, I storm off into the kitchen. We’ve been over to Kaitlin’s house enough times I know my way around, and I head straight for the cabinet where I know she keeps a bottle of Jameson. Next, I grab a stack of shot glasses, a fresh round of beers and return to the living room with my bounty. Alcohol isn’t a magical cure – I learned that the hard way in Boston – but it does have a time and place. Right now is it.
Lining up five shot glasses on the table, I fill them to the brim and push one over to Jamie and keep one for myself. The remaining three I push in front of Kaitlin. She’s eyeing me with suspicion, but I know her boundaries. I’ve seen this girl put away enough liquor in the past to know three shots is enough to get her to forget about what’s-his-name and maybe salvage the rest of the night.
The thing is, Kaitlin is easily the best girl I know. She’s the total package: smart, strong, and fucking sexy as hell. She’s the girl other girls dream of being. When Jamie first introduced me to her, I spent several months trying to convince her to ditch Brandon and hook up with me. That’s how I learned how fiercely loyal she can be. I’m also not a complete idiot. I could see the way Jamie looked at her, and I knew my boy had it bad, even if he would never admit it. So I backed off, and I’m probably a better man for it. Hindsight and all, I know I would have broken her heart the same way Brandon did if anything serious had ever happened between us. And I’m not sure Jamie would have ever forgiven me.
But I can bring a party. And if she and Jamie aren’t done pussy footing around the fact that he’s had a torch burning for her, I’m ready to push boundaries and have some fun. I’ve seen the way she looks at me sometimes, I’m not stupid. No, Kaitlin isn’t in love with me, but I don’t think she would say no if the circumstances are right. She can laugh it off tomorrow as a drunken mistake, and we can go back to being friends. Either way, it’s party time.
“You get three wishes,” I say, putting on my biggest smile. “Happy birthday, Kait!”
“Truth or dare?” It’s a question I haven’t been asked probably since I was thirteen. Am I really playing truth or dare with Tyler and Jamie? Next thing you know we’ll be playing Spin the Bottle or Seven Minutes in Heaven. It was Tyler’s idea, and although I know he’s up to something, for now I think it’s better to go along and not ask questions. In truth, this is the first time in days I haven’t thought about what’s-his-name, the first time I’ve laughed, let alone smiled, the first time I’ve felt like things might really be okay.
“Uh, dare?” The second I say it, I know I’m going to regret it.
Tyler’s mega-watt grin tells me I’m right. “Show us your sexiest pair of panties.”
“You’re a fucking perv,” I laugh and saunter down the hallway to my bedroom. He never specified I had to model them, so if he wants to check out my undie drawer, whatever. Easy dare.
A few minutes later I return with a lacy black thong and fling it at Tyler. I watch him hold them up and whistle. Seriously, is he five? I roll my eyes and take a seat on the edge of my coffee table, facing the boys. “Keep ‘em. They’ll look better on you than me anyway,” I say and stick out my tongue. In reality they were a present from Brandon, and I’m okay never seeing them again.
“Okay your turn Jamie. Truth or dare?”
“Truth,” he says, and for the second time tonight I catch him giving me a look I’ve never seen before. It’s intense and goes straight to my core, making me shift uncomfortably in my seat.
“What really happened on New Year’s Eve?” Tyler busts out laughing the second I ask the question. Tyler had thrown a massive New Year’s Eve bash, and Jamie had spent a good portion of the night getting to know some friend of a friend girl who’d shown up. It’d really seemed like they hit it off and as soon as the clock struck midnight they’d disappeared, presumably to hook up. When we asked Jamie about it the next day though, he’d turned the brightest red I have ever seen and absolutely refused to talk about it. There was more to the story than a gentleman refusing to kiss and tell.
“She, uh, was into some kind of kinky stuff,” he mumbles, once again turning beet red.
“Such as?” Tyler asks, egging him on.
“I think the term is ‘furry’?” Jamie says and coughs.
Tyler absolutely loses it at that. “Dude, you banged a furry? Wait… what animal was she? What animal were YOU?” I’m doing my best not to giggle myself, but the mental image is too much.
“Dude, no. She brought it up during the car ride to her place. I dropped her off , politely declined her offer and went home. I might have an open mind, but uh, not that open,” he says, hitting Tyler with one of the couch pillows. “And, she was a hamster,” he adds. We all erupt into peals of laughter at that.
I can’t believe Kaitlin asked me about New Years. That was a story I’d been quite happy to never tell. The part I left out was even though the girl, Julie I think was her name, had inquired whether I would be willing to indulge her in her particular kink, I had no intention of sleeping with her before that. Weird sexual fetish aside, she was a nice girl and good looking too, but the real reason I’d wanted to leave the party was I’d grown sick of watching Brandon be an absolute dick to Kaitlin.
She didn’t see it, love really is blind I guess, but I’d listened to him subtly and not-so-subtly put her down for hours while she worshipped the ground he walked on. He would make comments like, “Are you sure you should be eating that?” when she took an hors d’oeuvre or suggested she might “take a few minutes to adjust her make up in the restroom.” Meanwhile she talked on and on about how wonderful he was and practically tripped over herself to get him a new drink whenever he needed. If I hadn’t left with Julie, I was going to say or do something I’d regret.
Still, I know I’m never going to hear the end of “Julie the Hamster” from Tyler so I decide to push his buttons a little.
“Okay, Tyler, truth or dare?”
“Truth.”
“What’s YOUR secret fantasy or fetish?” I’d heard him talk enough in the locker room to know Tyler had an adventurous streak in the bedroom and hoped my question would make him stop giggling like a teen boy who had just seen his first pair of tits.
“I’ve always wanted to have a threesome,” he says with a completely straight face.
Kaitlin looks at him suspiciously. “I thought you and those two chicks hooked up last summer?” I wondered the same thing. We’d all listened to him brag about that one.
“We did. I don’t mean two girls. That shit is exhausting. I’ve always wanted to share a girl, no sword crossing or anything, but...”
“… you know, I like seeing a girl completely satisfied. And with a little teamwork? I think it’d be hot,” I say, purposefully looking at the ground so it seems like I’m embarrassed. Maybe what I’m doing is manipulative, but deep down I think Kaitlin and Jamie want it just as much as I do. He’ll never make a move if I don’t, and she would never choose between us because it would threaten the friendship. But we’re all drunk, our guard is down, and I’m pretty sure I can push things in the right direction.
“Me too,” Kaitlin says quietly. Jamie’s eyes go wide with surprise, and I grin. Jackpot.
“Oh yeah?”
She moves from her perch on the coffee table so she’s once again sitting between us. She leans her head on my shoulder and lets out a long sigh. “Can I tell you guys something?”
“Anything,” I say.
“Sex with Brandon was horrible. Like, really bad. I can count the number of times I got off with him on one hand. The rest of the time I faked it. Not that he even cared if I got off or not.” Poor Jamie looks like he’s about to have a heart attack, but all I hear is Kaitlin giving us the green light. Why else would she tell us this?
Testing the water, I shift so she’s leaning against my chest and use my new position to massage her shoulders. When she doesn’t move away, but instead closes her eyes and lets out a sigh of content, I grin over at Jamie. He looks uncomfortable, but I can tell he also doesn’t want to be left out so he pulls her legs up across his lap and gives her calf a firm squeeze. This elicits another moan from Kaitlin, and I know we’ve won.
Leaning in close, I whisper in her ear, “I think we can help you make up for some lost time.”
Tyler’s hot breath on my neck sends a shiver down my spine and awakens sensations further south I hadn’t felt in a long time. Not to mention Jamie’s strong hands working magic on my legs and making it difficult to think. If someone had asked me how things got to this point, I wouldn’t even know where to begin. And I’m not entirely sure I care anymore.
Normally, I’m the cautious type. I don’t take risks, and I think my actions through before doing anything. But between Brandon turning out to be a world class loser and it being my birthday, I desperately want to stop being the scared, little girl. For once, I want to do something because I want to and not because I’ve analyzed the situation from every angle and decided it was the best option. Maybe fucking your two best friends is a bad idea, but my body is in complete revolt.
“I will be in my room,” I say as I stand up and begin to make my way down the hallway. “You both are welcome to join me.” I grin when I hear two sets of footsteps following close behind me.
I’m either going to kill Tyler or owe him big time. Kaitlin actually wants to have a threesome! It’s not really my thing, but there’s also no way I’m going to say no and let Tyler have her to himself. So I follow them both down the hallway, not sure what to expect. A million questions about who does what when and where flood my mind, and I try to recall every last porn I’d ever seen for guidance.
Once in her room, I watch Tyler pull off his t-shirt before stepping behind her, pressing his tall frame against her. My body takes control where my head won’t, and I’m in front of her and leaning in to kiss her, trying to ignore Tyler’s presence. It doesn’t take much. Her lips are so soft, and her tongue teases mine as I realize she’s really, truly into this. Something Tyler does, a hand pushing up her shirt, causes her to moan, and I double my own efforts.
She pulls away briefly when Tyler removes her shirt, and I soak in the view of her exposed breasts. She’s fucking perfect. From behind, Tyler cups her breasts and squeezes her nipples, causing them to instantly harden and her eyes to roll back with pleasure. Next, I take off my shirt, noting the appreciative grin she gives me, before kneeling down in front of her, hands sliding up along the velvety smooth skin of her legs. When I reach the waistband of her shorts, I tug them down and feel my cock throb in my pants. She is wearing the smallest pair of panties I have ever seen, and I think these are much sexier than the ones she showed Tyler earlier. I can hear her breathing harder, and somewhere in the back of my head I’m pleading that this isn’t crossing too many lines. Who I am kidding? It’s crossed all the lines but no one seems to care. I swallow hard and then remove the last bit of fabric covering Kaitlin, the white lace panties pooling at her feet.
I look up at her and feel grateful her eyes are closed so she can’t see me staring. There’s still a piece of me that wants to yell “Stop!” A piece that screams I should tell Kaitlin how I feel about her, how I don’t want to share her, how I just want it to be me. And then Tyler catches me looking at her and it’s like the bastard can read my thoughts. He tugs her nipples between his fingers which causes her to roll her hips and let out a squeal. Sheer adrenaline urges me on and I use the distraction to pull one of her legs over my shoulder, opening her inner core to me. Whether I kill Tyler or thank him later (and really, I’ll probably do both), right now there’s one thing on my mind and it’s making Kaitlin scream my name.
I have to give it to Jamie. He has impeccable taste in women. Kaitlin’s naked body writhing against mine while he eats her out has to be one of the most amazing sights I’ve ever seen. It’s like live porn, only better because I also get to touch. And trust me, I intend to touch a lot of Kaitlin.
As Jamie continues his oral exploration, her knees buckle, and I wrap a hand around her waist to keep her from collapsing. She’s getting close, and I decide to push her over the edge.
“Are you going to cum?” I whisper in her ear. She doesn’t answer with words but instead moans louder. “Cum for us baby,” I tease, pulling on her earlobe with my teeth, kissing and sucking along her neck and collarbone. “Tell me you’re going to cum.” The combination of dirty talk and my efforts have their desired effect, and I feel her body tense up.
“Oh god, I’m coming,” she cries, shaking in my arms. It’s like watching a tornado rip through her body, her body quivering shuddering as Jamie continues to lavish her pussy with his tongue. It is minutes before she stops trembling and opens her eyes. Neither she nor Jamie seems to know how to make the next move as she surveys the scene before her, and Jamie moves to stand up.
Thankfully, I’m here. “I think it’s your turn Kaitlin,” I murmur in her ear. “Truth or dare?”
You should totally make a second part to this!
10/2/15