Be Yours
chapter sixteen - I don't know what to say
“She’s what!?” Jamie and I exploded at the same time. Tyler and Avery looked at each other weakly, before nodding in confirmation. What we had heard was true; Avery was pregnant.
“I’m terrified” Tyler blurted out, a few tears in his eyes. “I’m absolutely fucking terrified” he added in a hushed, worried tone.
“Is that why you’ve been so weird lately?” I asked, still trying to digest the information we had been given. I still was having a hard time processing it; I could only imagine the way Jamie must have been feeling in this moment; the girl he was in love with was pregnant by his best friend.
“Two months along” Avery whispered quietly. “We wanted to wait until we were three months along before telling you guys but- well in light of the circumstances” she huffed, rolling her eyes, referring to Tyler and everything he had said to me.
“I-I mean- congratulations!” Jamie stuttered out, unsure of what to make of the news any more than I did.
“Yeah- congrats you guy” I smiled lamely. “Are you guys- are you guys still ok?” I asked tentatively. The pregnancy still didn’t explain why they were being so distant from each other. I knew Tyler’s confession didn’t set well with Avery; she was still so furious and upset with him.
“I don’t know” Avery grumbled, a furious look on her face. “I’m hurt, Tyler. Are you- are you sure you want to be with me?” she asked, eyes growing wide. “Because if you don’t, I want to know now” she trembled with every word she spoke. It seemed she had finally gained the confidence to ask Tyler the words she had been dying to speak. I knew their talk could not have ended on good terms. “Because if you don’t I’m leaving right now” she added, staring daggers at Tyler.
He remained there, silent and stunned into silence. Jamie and I remained stunned into silence, feeling a little awkward to be in the same room as the pair of them as they had what probably was the most difficult conversation of their lives.
“I want to make this work, Aves” Tyler spoke up, looking hurt. “Please don’t leave” he begged, approaching Avery for the first time since she had entered the house. “I want to work through this. For us; for our family” he whispered, putting a hand gently on her stomach.
“Okay” she spoke up, wiping the tears away from her eyes. Tyler smiled widely, pulling Avery close to him, embracing her tightly. He pulled away on slightly, just enough so their lips could meet in a gentle, much needed kiss. “We’ll talk about this more” she added in a near whisper.
“You guys take a night to yourselves, we’ll see you later” Jamie spoke up; and I agreed. To be honest, we probably couldn’t get out of there fast enough.
“Thank you” Avery whispered, before putting her lips back against Tyler’s.
Jamie and I made our way out of their house, still a little shocked by the events that had transpired over the last few hours. They were pregnant; they were expecting a baby together. Any ounce of hope I had of ever being with Tyler vanished the moment the words escaped her lips. And judging by the look on Jamie’s face, he had the same feelings about Avery.
“What do I do” he was the first one to speak.
“Let’s go for a walk” I smiled to him, gesturing towards the sidewalk. It was a decent temperature; perfect for walking in. "It's over" I spoke the harsh words out loud after a few lengthy moments of walking down the street in silence. "There's no sense in hiding the fact anymore Jamie" I added with a grimace. I had to accept it someday, didn’t I?
"I know Emily" he whispered sadly, head hanging low. "I'm sorry" he added, giving me a sympathetic smile.
"I'm sorry too" I answered back, honestly. "I know this isn't what you want to hear, but any girl would be lucky to have you" I wasn't sure what prompted me to say it, but before I even had the chance to stop myself, the words escaped my lips.
"You think so?" He asked, sounding hopeful.
"Of course I do" I smiled, realizing my words were making him feel even slightly better. "You're funny, sweet, kind hearted, super talented, modest... And pretty damn good looking too" I added the last part with a whisper. I looked over to gage his reaction, and noticed a small blush creep up on his cheeks.
"I don't know what to say" he admitted sheepishly.
"You don't have to say anything Jame" I informed him gently. "I just wanted you to know that" and it was true. Ever since meeting him I've thought Avery was stupid to not want to be with him; and not just because I wanted to be with Tyler. Jamie was amazing in so many ways; he would make one lucky girl extremely happy.
We walked in a comfortable silence for a few moments, both absorbed in our individual thoughts.
Walking was always so calming; the air was chilly but felt good against my warm skin. I felt Jamie inch closer towards me, wrapping his arm around my shoulders. We stopped walking for a moment, simply standing on the sidewalk, looking into each other's eyes.
"You know, any guy would be lucky to be with you, Emily" he whispered, maintaining eye contact. "You're beautiful, inside and out. You're always there for people you care about. You're so selfless, so kind hearted, smart, talented..." He trailed off with a smile.
"I don't know what to say" I smirked, copying his words from moments ago. He cracked a smile, shaking his head with a laugh.
"You don't have to" was his witty reply. "I just wanted you to know that" he added, copying my earlier words.
"Have a mentioned how funny you are?" I asked with a grin.
"You might have mentioned it" he winked, snickering, mostly to himself.
"You're amazing, Jame" I told him softly, as we both leaned closer to each other.
Notes
ok so this is a little bit short- but since you've guys have been so amazing I thought I'd post another chapter today :)
happy reading!
You should totally make a sequel, I would love to read it!!
2/24/16