Be Yours
chapter eighteen -
"Emily please, can we talk?" I could practically hear the hurt in his voice; it sounded like his heart was breaking with every word he spoke. I knew I wanted to talk to him; I never not wanted to; I simply felt confused.
It had been three days since he kissed me. Three days since I left him standing on the sidewalk, hurt and confused. He had played a game last night, otherwise he would have been over; he was clear he wanted to make this better. I didn’t resent him for it by any means; nor did I have any intentions of not forgiving him; I just needed some time to collect my thoughts. And to be honest, I was still just as confused as I was when I ran from him three days ago.
I opened up my front door, slowly at first. Relief washed over Jamie's face when I opened the door. He looked so handsome; wearing a tight white t-shirt paired with a pair of black dress pants. His hair was slicked back as per his norm; but his facial expression broke my heart.
His eyes looked worried; almost as if he hadn't slept in a while. The joyous smile he often wore was gone; worry etched into his perfect face.
"Come in" I near whispered, stepping to the side to allow him entrance. He gladly accepted, taking a step inside, brushing by me slightly.
I felt myself shiver at the slight bit of contact; his cologne rushing through my nose rapidly; he always smelt amazing.
"I'm so sorry Emily" Jamie spoke as soon as we took a seat in the living room.
"Jamie..." I trailed off, unsure of what to say.
"No, Emily I truly am sorry. I didn't mean to hurt you- or confuse you-" he cut himself off, unsure of how he wanted to continue. "I really value your friendship Em, I'd never want to do anything to ruin that" he sighed, looking down at his lap nervously.
We sat in a silence for a few moments; I was unsure of how I wanted to proceed. I didn't want to lose Jamie, that was a given. He had become such an important part of my life over the past few months; I couldn't imagine my life without him.
"I don't want to lose you, Jamie" I spoke up, placing a hand on his lap, hoping he'd look up and maintain eye contact. To my pleasure he did, relief washing over his face ever so slightly. "You've become such an important part of my life I- I couldn't imagine my life without you" I added in a near whisper.
"I don't want to lose you either Em" he croaked, a small smile forming on his face. I smiled in return, scooting closer to him and wrapping my arms around him in a hug. I could still tell there was something on his mind; the way he set his head down on my shoulder told me that; when something weighed heavily on his mind he often found comfort in resting his head on my shoulder.
"What's on your mind?" I asked, after allowing him to collect his thoughts for a moment.
"How do you always know?" He asked, a slight smirk on his lips.
"I can read you like a book, Jame"
****************************************************************************************************
Jamie's POV
"What's on your mind?" She asked, after a moment of brief silence, where I collected my thoughts.
"How do you always know?" I asked, smirking.
"I can read you like a book Jame" she replied softly, eyes looking worriedly into mine.
I heavily debated telling her. I have feelings for you Em, I wanted to say. I wanted to tell her how amazing she was, and how amazing she made me feel. I wanted to tell her how she was the one I wanted; and had been for quite some time now.
But she loved Tyler; I had come to that conclusion on my own. She felt bad for kissing me because she loves Tyler. Not me. Tyler.
I never felt more resentment towards him than I did when I saw her walk away. I felt like my heart had been shattered all over again, just after Emily had spent so long fixing it.
But I couldn't lose her. Regardless of how I had her in my life, I needed her. I wanted her in my life, even if it was just as friends. Even if it hurt; because she was worth it.
"I hope this doesn't screw up our friendship, that's all" I murmured, not being able to man up and just tell her the truth. There was something in me telling me not to tell her; and as much as I wanted to, I listened to that feeling.
"It doesn't Jamie" she assured me. "I need you in my life; you're easily my best friend"
I felt relieved at her words; she needed me in her life. She pulled me back into a hug, gently rubbing my back. Maybe one day, I thought to myself with a sigh, I would be able to fess up. But I guess, as unfortunate as it was, that day wasn't today.
*************************************
Emily's POV
I woke up to a pounding headache. After our talk last night, things seemed to be fine between Jamie and me. We enjoyed a night in; ordering Chinese food and binge watching how to get away with murder on Netflix; with wine of course.
Between the two of us we almost had three bottles; to say I was a little hungover would be an understatement. We spent the night chatting and laughing, just like we did before he kissed me. It was as if everything had been forgotten; but of course, it wasn’t.
I wanted so badly to ask him why he kissed me. But something in me dreaded the answer; I didn’t want to hear about how much he loved Avery. It’s always been Avery; for him and for Tyler.
I heard the snores of Jamie next to me; who had appeared to have fallen asleep next to me in my bed. He was fully clothed, and so was I.
hopping up from my bed, I made my way to the bathroom where I searched rapidly for some Advil.
I dreaded today; I had to meet Tyler later on for coffee. I didn't know why I agreed to even go; he just said he really needed someone to talk to.
After showering and getting ready for the day, I decided to see if Jamie was still asleep or not. If not, he was in for a fun wake up. Much to my dismay, he was fully awake, looking just as bad as I felt.
“Here’s some Advil sleepy head” I chuckled, tossing him the two tablets and setting a glass of water in his hand. He smiled in appreciation, taking the pills quickly.
“I’m glad we only have a practice later this afternoon” he grumbled, rubbing his temples. We didn’t get much sleep last night; having only gone to bed around four in the morning. As much as my head told me differently, I didn’t regret it. I never spent a single moment with Jamie that I regretted.
“I’m lucky I don’t work today” I admitted, taking another seat on the bed. Even after my shower I still felt horrible; maybe I needed some more sleep. The past few days had been emotionally draining.
We chatted for another little bit before bidding goodbye; he had to be at the arena soon; he always liked to be early. I decided on taking another nap before meeting Tyler for coffee after their practice.
It didn’t take long for my eyes to flutter shut, taking me into a peaceful dreamland.
“So, what did you wanna talk about?” I asked Tyler, having enough of the small chit chat we were having. After the usual weather small talk, I was ready to get down to business. I didn’t drag myself out of bed and out of the house to talk about how nice it was outside.
“I’m just- I’m scared Emily” he confessed the obvious. “Am I trying to make this work with Avery because of the baby? Or because I think she’s the one?” he rambled on with the same bullshit he did not long ago.
“How are you guys doing lately anyway?” I asked, not wanting to talk about him wanting to possibly leave my best friend.
“As good as we can I guess” he admitted. “She’s slowly getting a little less angry at me” he added in a lower voice.
“Well can you blame her?” I asked him, an eyebrow raised.
“No” he muttered softly. “No I don’t”
“This isn’t fair to her you know” I informed him sternly. “You need to figure out I you want to be with her or not. I know a baby kind of changes that, but you’ll both figure it out; I know you will” I rattled on. “But if you’re not happy, you can’t keep stringing her along. Because in the long run, both of you are going to be hurt, so much worse than if you decide it isn’t what you want now”
I settled myself down, letting my words sink in. Tyler looked deep in thought, so I remained silent, waiting for him to make the next move.
“You’re right” he finally said after a lengthy silence. “But how do I figure out if I want to be with her or not?” he asked, genuinely confused.
“I think you just know” I shrugged, unsure of how else to explain it. “Like I said before. After a long day, is she the one you want to go back to? After a tough loss? Or a victory? Someone you can tell absolutely anything to? Someone you can be serious with, but can joke around with too?” I went on my usual spiel, hoping maybe it would help him with his decision.
At the end of the day, it didn’t matter what I said; it was all up to him.
“All I know, is you need to figure it out. You’ve got less than three months until you get married; don’t forget that” I told him sternly.
“I know” he nodded, understanding. “I’ll figure it out”
Notes
sorry it's a little later than I wanted, but I wanted to try and make it a little longer!!
Once again thank you for all the lovely feedback! The story most definitely will be 30-40 chapters in length :)
You should totally make a sequel, I would love to read it!!
2/24/16