Login with:

Facebook

Twitter

Tumblr

Google

Yahoo

Aol.

Mibba

Your info will not be visible on the site. After logging in for the first time you'll be able to choose your display name.

Be Yours

Chapter Two - secrets bringing us together





I felt a little frozen in my seat; did I just hear correctly? Was the man sitting before me, the man Tyler was using as his best man, just admitting he was in love with Avery? You couldn't get a more confusing love triangle even if you tried, I thought with a grimace.

"I'm sorry to drop that on you, really sorry, it was stupid" Jamie was about to get up from his seat but I stopped him. I held onto Both of his arms still standing at a reasonable distance from him. I looked up into his eyes, my heart shattering with every moment I looked into them. I knew exactly the pain he was experiencing; I understood.

"Jamie it's not stupid" I answered in a soft voice. "I get it; I really do" I whispered quietly. Offering a small smile. "Do you want to start at the beginning?" I then asked. If it were anything like the back story of Tyler and I, I knew it would be of some interest and heartbreak.

"Are you sure you want to know?" Jamie asked, a little surprised.

"I do" I answered back almost immediately. "Unless you're not ready. I mean, we barely know each other right?" It would make more sense to wait, wouldn't it?

"I think it's time I finally find someone to talk about it with, you know? I've been hiding it for so goddamn long" Jamie sighed heavily. Out of my normal character, I pulled him in ,closer to me for a hug. It surprised him at first, but after a few moments he melted into my arms, closing his eyes at my touch. I knew exactly how he was feeling; it was practically the story of my life.

"Does it hurt?" I asked innocently.

"Mhm" he nodded solemnly after we stepped back from the hug, him taking the seat right next to me on the swinging bench, "it never stops hurting" Jamie admitted. Each word he spoke the more my heart broke for him. Sure, he was a stranger; but he was a stranger who just so happened to be going through the same thing as I had been going through for years.

"So you and Avery..." I trailed off, not knowing where to even begin. "How did you guys meet?" Avery and I weren't strangers, but we hadn't known each other for a very extended period of time either. She was looking for a roommate at the same time I moved to the city; a story for another day.

"Jordie was dating her best friend" Jamie began, looking up from his lap and maintaining eye contact. He looked nervous, so I shot an encouraging smile his way. It seemed to work, he visibly seemed to ease up a little bit.


**flashback, third person POV**


It was a chilly, October, Halloween night. Kids littered the streets clad in costumes with pillow cases and buckets looking to pick up some good treats.

Just up the road, the Dallas Stars were having their annual Halloween party. Most years, it didn't happen to even fall on Halloween; but this year, it did.

Putting the last of his costume together, Jamie Benn took another shot of whiskey, surrounded by a handful of his teammates. They were laughing, drinking, and having a good time, the beat of whatever music the DJ decided to play echoing loudly throughout the residence.

"Yo, Jamie!" A voice caught the young captains attention. He whipped his head up from the conversation he was having, smiling when he noticed the familiar face of his brother step into the kitchen.

"Jordie, what up man!" Jamie called from across the room, practically shouting to be heard. Jordie had a red headed girl attached to his hip, completing the "Fred and Daphne" (from scooby-doo) costume look they were going for. They had been dating for a number of years; Jamie was happy for his brother.

"Jame, there's someone I want you to meet" Jordie spoke up once his brother was within decent earshot. He smiled to himself, knowing his baby brother was absolutely going to love who he was going to introduce him to. Her name was Avery, and she was as stunning as they came. Blonde hair, model; the brightest smile you would ever see.

"Oh?" Jamie cocked his head to the side, suddenly interested.

"This is Kara's friend Avery. Ave, this is my baby brother, Jamie" Jordie slid off to the side to allow his brother to take a good look at her. Even with the amount of alcohol in his system, Jamie felt his heart pick up and begin to beat at a rather rapid pace. She was gorgeous; stunning... You could almost say it was love at first sight for Jamie, he couldn't keep his eyes off of her.

She appeared to be starring back, her eyes dancing with joy. She smiled, exposing the amazing smile once more. But what Jamie didn't realize was who she was actually starring at. What Jamie didn't realize, was who was standing right behind him.

Tyler Seguin stood behind his captain, suddenly becoming interested in who he was talking to. He eyed the blonde up and down, a small smile forming on his lips; she was hot; stunning.

From the moment Jamie met her, he was hooked. They chatted, danced, and drank together that night. Jamie in the hopes of getting to know her better; Avery in the hopes that he would introduce her to his hot friend.

**end flashback**


"I thought we had a connection, you know? But turns out all she was interested in was Segs" he sighed heavily, sitting back further on the swinging bench. I nodded, taking in the story of how the pair had met. I remembered the night quite well; I remember picking Avery up from that party.

"I picked her up from that party" I blurted out after a moments thought. "I remember her talking about him... About Tyler" I added the last part in a softer voice, as if it would soften the blow. "I'm sorry"

"You don't have to apologize" Jamie answered quickly, shaking his head. "It's not your fault, it's my own"

"What makes you say it's your fault?" I interrupted him before he even had a chance to finish his train of thought.

"I'm the one who fell for her, maybe if I was better looking- or funnier- or-"

"Don't say that" I shook my head. "You're perfect just the way you are. I've spent so long trying to compare myself to her; to any girl he's really been with. But I can't. We can't. It's not fair" I reasoned, beginning to ramble. I knew I didn't truly believe in the words I was speaking for the most part; but there was something about Jamie that made me want to try.

"Thanks" he blushed nervously. "You're right, but it's so hard not to think that way, you know?"

"Trust me, I know" I nodded my head in agreement. "Doesn't make it hurt any less though" I added with a sigh. Knowing that the pair were up there right now hurt like Hell; I could only imagine Jamie felt the same. "Does Tyler know?" Was my next question.

He hung his head low, nodding his head.

"Yeah, he knows"

"Does Avery?" I inquired.

"I didn't tell her, but it guess Tyler did" he bit his lip. "I mean I never really told Tyler either! he just sort of figured it out. He felt kinda bad, but what was I going to do, tell him not to date her? I couldn't bring myself to do that"

"That's very big of you, Jamie" I informed him with a smile. We heard a strange noise emit from the upstairs window; it didn't take much to guess what was going on up there. "On that note, I guess I better get going" I swallowed the lump in my throat, trying not to think about what was going on upstairs.

"Probably a good idea; I don't think they'll be coming down anytime soon" Jamie spoke quietly, the smile that had been present on his face vanishing in a second. Getting up from the swing, we turned to each other, and pulled in for a hug. "Thanks for listening, it felt really good to actually tell somebody about it" he spoke after a few moments of silence.

"Anytime. And I mean that, you seem like a really cool guy Jamie Benn" I told him with a smirk. He smirked in return, the frown finally disappearing off his face.

"And you're a pretty cool girl, Emily Hughes"

Notes

here is chapter two :) hope you guys like it!!

Comments

You should totally make a sequel, I would love to read it!!

KitoftheKat KitoftheKat
2/24/16

please update soooooonnnn!!!!

bailey08 bailey08
2/13/16

Hey (:
just read your story and wanted to write a comment because i really enjoyed reading it. that were some wonderfull thirty chapters of reading and i am a little sad it is over now. but however your story really catched me and it was hard to stop reading. yeah sure at some point i really hated you :D but there was such a cute happy ending. thanks for that amazing story

blueBird
12/6/15

YAYYYYYYYYY! Heart eye emojis all round!

wen.muller wen.muller
11/22/15

SEQUELLLL!!!!!!

bailey08 bailey08
11/21/15