Be Yours
chapter thirty - I love you
Emily’s POV
I don’t know how I ended up on Tyler’s doorstep. I guess I found a surge of confidence to tell him my decision. Was I ready to tell him? I knew I wouldn’t be able to avoid it forever; time was running out.
I stood on the doorstep, hand hovering over the door, wanting to knock but suddenly lacking the courage. No. Come on Emily. You have to do this. Do it; and do it now.
With a huge and heavy sigh I knocked on the door, heart racing in anticipation. I heard voices on the other side, before the door opened; revealing the man I was not expecting.
“Jamie?” I asked softly, eyes wide, hurt filling up inside me.
“Emily” he answered, just as softly. “What are you- what are you doing here?” he asked, gulping, looking just as nervous as I felt.
“I uh- I came to talk to Tyler about something” I told him, barely being able to maintain his eye contact; he wouldn’t even look me in the eye. I felt hurt and rage; remembering how he kissed Avery. But thinking back to earlier today; if that were true, why would she have told him to stay out of her life?
“Oh- well uh, come in” he gestured for me to enter the house. I obliged, stepping by him, avoiding contact at all costs. I wanted to hate him; I wanted to be angry with him; but god dammit I couldn’t. There wasn’t a damn thing in the world Jamie could do to make me hate him; I loved him with every fiber in my being. We had grown so close over the past few months; I had grown so used to him being around. His absence killed me.
“Emily?” Tyler questioned, eyeing me skeptically.
“Tyler” I breathed, feeling relieved to see him. I feared if I was left beside Jamie too long I might break down and cry; I missed him so much.
“What are you doing here?” he asked me curiously.
“I came here to- to tell you my decision” I informed him with a gulp.
“Your decision about?” Tyler furrowed his brow, very confused.
“About us” I said in a near whisper, eyes finding their way to Jamie who shifted uncomfortably beside Tyler.
“Oh- you- you decided?” Tyler asked, eyebrows raised. I nodded, gulping with nervousness. This wasn’t going to be an easy conversation.
Jamie’s POV
We arrived at Tyler’s house for this ‘bro date’ that he wanted to go on. We ordered a pizza, turned on Netflix, and just planned to sit around, eat pizza, watch movies and drink beer. It sounded good to me; with everything that happened with Avery, we really hadn’t spent a whole lot of time together recently.
“So Demers got someone knocked up, eh?” Tyler told me, as we sat in the kitchen, beers in hand, waiting for the doorbell to ring to get our pizza.
“No way- seriously?” I asked with a laugh, trying to fully get the thought of Emily off of my mind. I knew the more I drank, the more I would forget about her. I knew this wasn’t the answer, but at this point I didn’t know what else to do.
“Yeah- he met her at the bar the other weekend” Tyler rolled his eyes, shaking his head. “He’s really gotta learn to wrap it before he taps it” he scoffed with a laugh.
“Oh yeah, life lessons on one night stands from the expert himself” I teased him, taking the last swig of my second beer. I was about to grab a third when the doorbell rang. “I’ll grab it” I nodded to Tyler, who held the thumbs up as he scrolled through the movie selection.
I opened the door, and if I could have dropped dead right then and there, I absolutely would have.
“Jamie?” she asked me, hurt evident in her voice.
““Emily” I answered, just as softly. “What are you- what are you doing here?” I asked, gulping, nervously. What was she doing here?
“I uh- I came to talk to Tyler about something” she told me I couldn’t even find the nerve to look her in the eyes; I felt incredibly guilty for being such an asshole, and lying to her.
“Oh- well uh, come in” I gestured for her to enter the house. The smell of her familiar perfume sent shivers down my spine. The way she avoided making any form of physical contact with me made my heart sink; I had really fucked this up. She didn’t and never would want anything to do with me. And to be perfectly honest, I didn’t blame her in the slightest.
“Emily?” Tyler questioned, eyeing her skeptically.
“Tyler” she breathed, looking around awkwardly.
“What are you doing here?” he asked her curiously.
“I came here to- to tell you my decision” she informed him with a gulp. Oh my god.
“Your decision about?” Tyler furrowed his brow, very confused.
“About us” she said in a near whisper, eyes finding her way looking directly into mine. I hoped she couldn’t sense how nervous I was.
“Oh- you- you decided?” Tyler asked, eyebrows raised. She nodded, looking at the pair of us nervously.
“Yeah, I have” she looked at him, eyes watery. “Tyler we’ve got so much history” she began, each word breaking my heart a little more. “I’ve loved you for so long; I’ve dreamed of the day you’d tell me you felt the same” she laughed, shaking her head. “I know you didn’t treat me the best, but I can truly see a change in you Ty, a change for the better. Since you came here. Since you- since you met Jamie” she added the part about my name in a near whisper.
I didn’t want to listen any longer; I couldn’t listen any longer. How could I listen to the girl of my dreams confess her longing for Tyler?
“Jamie are you okay?” Emily’s voice broke me out of my thoughts. It took me a moment to realize what was happening; I was crying.
“I- I have to go” I grumbled, wiping the tears away, leaving the house.
“Jamie wait-” she called after but it was too late; I slammed the front door shut and plopped myself down on the porch, wondering how the hell I was ever going to get over this.
Emily’s POV
“Jamie wait-” I called, wanting to ask him why he was crying. He broke up with me. He broke my heart; what was up with him? “Fuck” I mumbled, turning back to face Tyler.
“You really love him, don’t you” Tyler sighed heavily, running his fingers through hs hair. I paused for a moment before nodding.
“Yeah, I do. I’m sorry Ty. I really am” I whispered softly. “But he doesn’t want to be with me anymore; he doesn’t feel the same” I added sadly, a few tears leaking down my cheek. I didn’t even bother to wipe them away, I simply let them fall.
“Yes he does” his words surprised me.
“He- he what?” I asked in shock. “But why did he?” before I could even finish my sentence, Tyler cut me off.
“He broke up with you, so you could be with me” Tyler told me. I stared at him in confusion; what the hell? “He knew how much you loved me- how much you wanted to be with me. He thought that when I ended things with Avery- and I told him why I did, he wanted you to be happy. He thought that it was what you wanted” Tyler told me, choking on his words. “He loves you, Em. He really does”
I let his words sink in. He only broke up with me because he thought I wanted to be with Tyler? I didn’t know what to think; I only knew I needed to find him.
“Go” Tyler instructed. “Go find him, I’ll be fine” he forced a smile on his face.
“Thank you Ty” I whispered, approaching him and kissing him on the cheek. “I meant it when I said you changed for the better” I added, genuinely feeling bad for breaking his heart, even though he broke mine all those years ago. He smiled, pushing me towards the door.
It didn’t take long for me to find Jamie; he didn’t make it any further than the front porch.
“Em?” He asked, looking at me, eyes red.
“Jamie” I smiled pulling him in close to me. He eyed me curiously, before I closed the gap between us and kissed him. He was taken aback and surprised, before pulling me closer into him.
I pulled away, a small smile playing on my lips.
“I love you, Jamie” I told him. “It’s you I want to be with” I whispered in his ear. I don’t think you could have put a bigger smile on his face.
“I love you too Emily” he answered. “I’m so so sor-” I cut him off by pressing my lips to his once more.
“Care to join me?” I asked, holding my hand out for him to take.
“For you?” he answered, taking my hand. “Anything”
Notes
and this is the end! an epilogue to come :)
if you guys wants, I've got some thoughts on a sequel!
let me know what you think, and thank you so much for reading!!
You should totally make a sequel, I would love to read it!!
2/24/16