Be Yours
Chapter Six - awkward situations
"Oh hey Ty-" I made a small smile, trying to ease the anxiety I had once he opened the door. "Is Avery around? She asked me to stop by to show her what I had for plans for the bachelorette party" I spoke nervously, averting eye contact in the least awkward was possible.
After what I considered to be a wasted time and trip, and after Jamie and Tyler and set back out on the road to continue their trip, I decided to make use of my time off and actually begin to plan her party. Things were going so far so good; I had the venue, sent out the invites, ordered t-shirts as well as a bunch of party favors. I was extremely confident she was going to have an amazing night.
"No, she stepped out for a minute. You can come in, she won't be too much longer; I think she just ran to grab milk or something" he shrugged, moving to the side to allow me entrance. I felt a little frozen in my place; memories began to flood back. Before I let them consume me, I stepped inside, taking off my shoes and following Tyler into the kitchen.
To say I didn't feel extremely awkward and uncomfortable would be a complete lie; I wanted nothing more than to run back into the safety of my apartment; call Avery and tell her if she wanted the plans she could come to me.
"I need to talk to you about something" Tyler interrupted my racing thoughts suddenly. I looked up to see him staring directly at me, a weak smile on his gorgeous face. I numbly nodded, vaguely wondering what he wanted to talk about, and honestly half wishing Jamie was beside me.
"Sure Ty, what is it?" I asked, trying to keep the nervousness out of my voice. He bit his lip, causing me to swoon, obviously debating how to begin the conversation.
"I need to apologize"
Well, those were the last words I expected out of his mouth.
"Huh?" I managed to squeak out, confused.
"I never apologized for- for the way things ended between us" he clarified awkwardly. "And for everything else inbetween" he added with a frown.
I simply nodded, wondering where this was coming from, and where he was going with this.
"I always knew how you felt about me; but I didn't care. All I thought about was myself; I was selfish. I hurt you, Em. You were amazing to me; you gave me your everything, and I just- I was a real douchebag" he sighed heavily, running his hands through his hair.
"Tyler, where is this coming from?" I asked before he had a chance to continue on whatever train of thought he was on.
"When you guys showed up in Toronto, it made me remember all the times-" he cut himself off, letting the sentence linger in the air. He remembered all the times I'd travel across the country to be with him; to cheer him on; to comfort him. Whenever he wanted me somewhere, I made no hesitation in being there, regardless of the consequences for me. Tyler and his happiness was what was important to me; and I thought he returned the same amount of care for me.
But he never did. If I ever needed him, he was always preoccupied. He always had an excuse; a practice, team function, game, whatever excuse he could find; he found it. But I was so blindly in love I didn't see it. I didn't see the obvious way he used me; I continued on letting him use me until the fateful day of our conversation; where he told me he didn't feel the same and just wanted to be 'friends'. How could you be friends with someone you were so hopelessly in love with? With someone to whom you gave your everything to?
"I was young, Em. Young and stupid. You didn't deserve what I put you through- and for that I really am truly sorry" he continued as I took an unwelcomed walk through memory lane. "You were there for me through everything- and I know you always wanted more, but you were my best friend; and all I did was use you"
I nodded once more, trying with every fiber in my body not to cry. I didn't want him to know just how much he had broken me; for him to see just how much it still hurt so badly.
"I've grown up a lot since coming here" Tyler continued, taking my silence as permission to continue his train of thought. "And Emily, when I said we could still be friends, I really meant it. I know that's not what you want, and I know it must be hard especially with-" he cut himself off, pausing for a moment. "We haven't really said much to each other these months. If you- if you want to be friends, I'd really like that. If not- I totally understand"
I sat on the bar stool of his and Avery's house, completely stunned. He was apologizing for everything? There were so many thoughts going through my mind. Do I be his friend? Would it make it any easier to get over him? Absolutely not; but nothing seemed to help.
Would it make it easier on Avery? Knowing that I fully accepted Tyler and I being nothing more than friends? I had to admit- Tyler had grown up a lot since I met him that day in Boston. He had matured far faster than I could have imagined.
"Being friends is a mutual thing" I found myself finally being able to find my voice. I felt a surge of confidence fly through me; I could do this; and I could do it whilst holding myself together. "Before- whatever it was we were- I cared so much and you-" I cut myself off, not wanting to take a turn down that road again.
"I know, Em" Tyler frowned, looking genuinely sad and upset by his previous actions. "But I see how much of an amazing friend you are to Avery. I see how much Jamie has made a fast friend in you too. You have such a big heart, Em" he smiled, inching closer to me.
"Do you care?" was the only thing I found myself asking.
"I care, Emily Hughes" Tyler spoke immediately, not pausing for a second. "You're there for two of the most important people in my life. You've always been such a huge part of mine. I really have missed having you as a friend, Em. I've always cared; I just chose a shitty ass way of showing it" he spoke the last part barely above a whisper.
"Then okay" I couldn't believe what I was allowing to come out of my mouth. "Friends" I stuck out my hand for him to shake it. Instead he grinned widely, pulling me in for a tight hug.
"Friends" he repeated. At his words I felt my heart shatter. I loved him so much I was allowing myself to be friends with him because he wanted it; because it would be easier on Avery. He pulled away, just as his phone rang on the table across the kitchen.
I was thankful as he distanced himself from me to go answer it; I didn't think I could take having him so closely to me anymore. I spent the time he was on the phone to go over the conversation that had just transpired. I analyzed every little detail; like I always did when it came to Tyler.
"Looks like Avery had an appointment she forgot about, she won't be home for another few hours" Tyler interrupted my thoughts as he set his phone down, a little disappointingly.
"Oh..." I trailed off awkwardly. "I can come back tomorrow or something then" I got up from my seat and was about to walk back out of the house before I noticed a sad look on Tyler's face. "Ty? Are you okay?" I asked, approaching his figure slowly.
"We've been arguing a lot lately" he confessed. That much I didn't even know; Avery always let on that their relationship was perfect.
"What about?" I asked curiously.
"She's been kind of been going all Bridezilla on everyone" he scoffed a little with a light laugh. "Especially to you" he added with a sympathetic smile.
"Maybe a little" I shrugged with a laugh. "But she's just excited" I reasoned, thinking of no other logical reasoning behind Avery's recent actions.
"She still doesn't have to be such a bitch" Tyler let slip, eyes going wide. "I mean- she could be nicer about it, you know?" he tried to cover up the fact he called his fiancee a bitch.
"Is that what you guys argued about?" I asked with a sympathetic smile.
"Yeah, she's pissing a lot of people off" Tyler blew out the breath he was holding. "It's getting frustrating. She probably doesn't even have an appointment; she just doesn't want to argue about it anymore, you know?"
"I get it, Ty, trust me" I assured him. "If you want, I can maybe talk to her about it? If that would help?" Honestly it'd be nice to tell Avery just how I was feeling with her actions lately.
"That would be really appreciated, Em" Tyler nodded approvingly. "You're a great friend" he smiled despite being a little bummed out Avery wouldn't be returning home until a later time.
"And I know you probably want to get your mind off this, so I've got the perfect idea" I smirked, remembering the way I used to get his mind off of something when he was stressed out. "Please tell me you still have it"
"I'm surprised you remembered" he smiled brightly with a laugh. "Of course I still have it" he grinned from ear to ear, leading me into the living room and pulling the familiar box out of its keeping place.
"See if you're as good as you used to be" I laughed, tossing a wink his way, taking a seat on the comfortable leather sofa. He set the game up quickly; it didn't require much assembly. There wasn't anything quite like getting your mind off of something with a game of connect four.
"You're on" he laughed, setting his blue disc in first.
You should totally make a sequel, I would love to read it!!
2/24/16