Caught Between Love
Chapter 4
*** Present Time ***
James crawled on top of me, his mouth trailing the contours of my body. His kiss was soft but eager, he loved to work me up. I moved my hips up, allowing him to remove my pants. He stared at me with lust.
"No panties. I like."
"I forgot to pack an extra pair after the game." I say trying to justify myself going commando. "Looks like my mistake came to good use." I winked at him.
James buried his face in between my legs without warning. His lips kissing the inside of my thighs as his thumb worked my center. His touch felt so good, so natural and his pace was perfect.
I moan in pleasure only to excite James even more. His thumb was reached with the pressure of his tongue. Slowly he was moving up and down, his right hand was massaging my inner thigh.
"My favorite dessert." He mumbles as I moan louder with every lick and nibble. The anticipation was killing me and my climax was coming soon. He could feel it. He inserted two fingers inside of me, a jolt of pleasure running throughout my body.
"Oh baby..." I gasp breathlessly. His pace quickened and his tongue worked fast as he began moaning inside me, almost taking me to my brink.
In and out, in and out, his fingers found the target zone and they weren't relenting.
"I'm gonna come, James." I warn him.
He stops suddenly, looking at me with hungry eyes. He licked his lips before sucking my juices off his fingers.
"You're to allowed to come yet, Tess." He kissed his way up to my neck before finding my mouth and shoving his tongue inside.
He was such a great kisser.
"I want you, Tess. All of you." He whispered in my ear. I sat up on the bed, grabbing James belt buckle and quickly undoing the clasp. In one shot he slipped my tank top off, throwing it to the floor.
James and I never went past foreplay before. For the first time since we've been dating, we were going to finally have sex, just a day later than we had originally planned.
I removed my bra as James ferociously took off his pants and boxer briefs. I let out a gasp when I saw him completely naked; his body was lean and his tattoo looking even more sexier than I had imagined.
"Can you work with this?" He asked curious. As if I couldn't.
"I think I'll manage just fine." I couldn't stop staring at him. I probably looked like some timid virgin.
"You're such a smart ass." He falls onto me, his hands forcefully grabbing my hips and pulling towards him.
"I think you deserve some personal time." I push him off me to the side as I straddle him. "A late celebration for your hat trick the other night." I grabbed his hard cock, slowly licking from the base to the top in one stroke.
I worked my hands up and down his shaft, licking the bead of pre-cum from the tip. "Tasty." I say looking up at him. He was staring at me and he was tense. He was grabbing the sheets beneath him.
Sexually frustrated James is the sexiest James. I begin teasing his cock with my tongue, matching the pressure with my hands as his groans became huskier and loud.
"Jesus Tess..." I shift my eyes up to see his head laying flat and his bearded jaw clenched in arousal.
I loved teasing him, so much that I began feeling aroused. I needed to hurry and finish James off so I began increasing my pace. I took him in deep, deeper than I ever before. His moan was a sign of approval. His hand found my head as he grabbed my hair, twisting it around his fist.
A few seconds more and he would climax. "Babe, I'm gonna..." Before he could finish his load filled up my mouth. Salty and sweet, I swallowed the creamy liquid before cleaning up his cock with my tongue.
He wasted no time switching activities. He flipped me over so I was on my knees. "Feisty Nealer." I squeal as his hands squeezed my hips. I could feel his cock rub against my sweet spot.
Again with the teasing.
"I've been waiting all week to do this, Tess." His finger was massaging me from behind. I cradled my head in between my arms which were resting beneath me.
"Enough talking." I stammer. He gently slapped my ass before thrusting deep inside me. I yell out a cry. "Fuuuuuuck!" I heard a laugh from behind. It was by far the most painful thing I've ever felt, he was so rough but it felt so damn good. Unlike anything I've ever felt before.
He withdrew his cock, flipping me on my back. He grabbed my left leg, hiking it over his right shoulder as he readjusted himself.
"Ready?"
I nod in reply. This time his thrust was even quicker and it felt like my insides erupted. It didn't take long for him to find my pleasure zone. I moaned with every thrust and I began circling my hips counter clockwise.
"You feel so tight, baby." He pants. He leaned down, his hand massaging my breast. I took my free hand, setting it between my legs, stroking my clit as he penetrated.
I could feel my release coming. I began tightening myself around him making James groan. "Fuck baby. Do that again." He pleads and I oblige. He tilts his head back, his pace never faltering and his thrusts going deeper and deeper.
"James...." I whisper. I pull James closer to me, the angle of his cock changing making it even more unbearable. "James, I'm close." I whimper. My legs were feeling numb and my back was arched.
"Together, Tess." He slows down, the change of pace being exactly what I needed.
"James!" I yell out, not giving one care of who could hear. Seconds later James found his release. "Fuuuuck Tess!" He collapsed on top of me, both of us out of breath like we just finished a marathon.
I looked over at him, his chest heaving and his breath strained. James leaned over, his left hand resting on my stomach as he kissed me.
"I'm glad we waited, all the build up made it completely insane!" I kissed him back, my fingers playing with his curls.
"I love you." I say without hesitation. They say you connect deeply with someone who you've had great sex with and James was that guy. Minutes ago I was telling him that I could love him and now, I do love him. I wasn't afraid for him to know it and I wasn't afraid to say it.
His finger swept my hair out of my face and he looked into my eyes.
"I'm madly in love with you Tess Mariot."
*** One year ago ***
Rumors circulated that Sid and I were dating. It was all over the news and Internet, photos of us hanging out at Local were plastered around fan sites and tumblr.
"It only took the media two years to start questioning us?" I was munching on some popcorn that Sid made for our weekly afternoon movie marathon.
"Apparently we make the perfect couple." He pulled up a hockey girlfriends message board. Of course, he had his own. I walked over to see him scrolling through the comments.
"She is soooooo pretty! They look adorable together."
"She's just with him for the fame. Money grubbing bitch."
"Her brothers play in the NHL too, I doubt she's looking for fame with Sid. They look happy together."
I rolled my eyes. Some people just have nothing better to do than talk about other people's personal lives.
"Sid, I'm only with you for your millions." I say planting a kiss on his cheek. That was one thing about Sid I loved, we were so comfortable around each other.
"I gotta go anyway, I have a hot date with a soccer ball." Sid stands up quickly, grabbing my arm just as I'm about to exit his house.
"Hey! What the-" Sid plants his lips on mine, his tongue spreading my mouth. I felt my legs go weak as his hand was holding me upright.
He pulled away looking for a response.
"Ummm. Sid. I have to go." I left as soon as I could trying to remain as calm as I could.
Pulling out of his driveway, Sid was still standing there. From what I could see, he looked hopeless.
As I got to the stadium for practice my phone started ringing.
"Hello?"
"Hey it's Nealer!" I tried to compose myself, I was still shocked from what happened.
"What's up?"
"I was wondering if you'd wanna catch a movie later? My treat."
"Not sure that's a good idea right now." I needed to talk to Sid about what happened.
"Oh come on. It's just a movie. I promise I don't bite, unless you're into that."
I started laughing. God he was so adorable. How could I say no to that?
"Charming. I have practice till 5. Make it dinner and a movie and I'll say yes."
"It's a date. I'll be at your house around 5:45."
I couldn't help from smiling. I don't know what it was but James was so persuasive.
"Tess!" I hear a call from behind me. I see Max running towards me.
"Why the huge smile?" She nudged my arm.
"You know that guy that plays with Sid? James Neal?"
She nods. "The guy you met like a year ago? The cutie?"
"Yeah! Well, I have a date with him tonight." I must have stopped smiling because Max began pressuring me for information.
"Tess. What did you do this time?"
"Sid kissed me. Like really kissed me."
Her eyes looked like they were going to pop out of her head.
"This could be an issue."
James crawled on top of me, his mouth trailing the contours of my body. His kiss was soft but eager, he loved to work me up. I moved my hips up, allowing him to remove my pants. He stared at me with lust.
"No panties. I like."
"I forgot to pack an extra pair after the game." I say trying to justify myself going commando. "Looks like my mistake came to good use." I winked at him.
James buried his face in between my legs without warning. His lips kissing the inside of my thighs as his thumb worked my center. His touch felt so good, so natural and his pace was perfect.
I moan in pleasure only to excite James even more. His thumb was reached with the pressure of his tongue. Slowly he was moving up and down, his right hand was massaging my inner thigh.
"My favorite dessert." He mumbles as I moan louder with every lick and nibble. The anticipation was killing me and my climax was coming soon. He could feel it. He inserted two fingers inside of me, a jolt of pleasure running throughout my body.
"Oh baby..." I gasp breathlessly. His pace quickened and his tongue worked fast as he began moaning inside me, almost taking me to my brink.
In and out, in and out, his fingers found the target zone and they weren't relenting.
"I'm gonna come, James." I warn him.
He stops suddenly, looking at me with hungry eyes. He licked his lips before sucking my juices off his fingers.
"You're to allowed to come yet, Tess." He kissed his way up to my neck before finding my mouth and shoving his tongue inside.
He was such a great kisser.
"I want you, Tess. All of you." He whispered in my ear. I sat up on the bed, grabbing James belt buckle and quickly undoing the clasp. In one shot he slipped my tank top off, throwing it to the floor.
James and I never went past foreplay before. For the first time since we've been dating, we were going to finally have sex, just a day later than we had originally planned.
I removed my bra as James ferociously took off his pants and boxer briefs. I let out a gasp when I saw him completely naked; his body was lean and his tattoo looking even more sexier than I had imagined.
"Can you work with this?" He asked curious. As if I couldn't.
"I think I'll manage just fine." I couldn't stop staring at him. I probably looked like some timid virgin.
"You're such a smart ass." He falls onto me, his hands forcefully grabbing my hips and pulling towards him.
"I think you deserve some personal time." I push him off me to the side as I straddle him. "A late celebration for your hat trick the other night." I grabbed his hard cock, slowly licking from the base to the top in one stroke.
I worked my hands up and down his shaft, licking the bead of pre-cum from the tip. "Tasty." I say looking up at him. He was staring at me and he was tense. He was grabbing the sheets beneath him.
Sexually frustrated James is the sexiest James. I begin teasing his cock with my tongue, matching the pressure with my hands as his groans became huskier and loud.
"Jesus Tess..." I shift my eyes up to see his head laying flat and his bearded jaw clenched in arousal.
I loved teasing him, so much that I began feeling aroused. I needed to hurry and finish James off so I began increasing my pace. I took him in deep, deeper than I ever before. His moan was a sign of approval. His hand found my head as he grabbed my hair, twisting it around his fist.
A few seconds more and he would climax. "Babe, I'm gonna..." Before he could finish his load filled up my mouth. Salty and sweet, I swallowed the creamy liquid before cleaning up his cock with my tongue.
He wasted no time switching activities. He flipped me over so I was on my knees. "Feisty Nealer." I squeal as his hands squeezed my hips. I could feel his cock rub against my sweet spot.
Again with the teasing.
"I've been waiting all week to do this, Tess." His finger was massaging me from behind. I cradled my head in between my arms which were resting beneath me.
"Enough talking." I stammer. He gently slapped my ass before thrusting deep inside me. I yell out a cry. "Fuuuuuuck!" I heard a laugh from behind. It was by far the most painful thing I've ever felt, he was so rough but it felt so damn good. Unlike anything I've ever felt before.
He withdrew his cock, flipping me on my back. He grabbed my left leg, hiking it over his right shoulder as he readjusted himself.
"Ready?"
I nod in reply. This time his thrust was even quicker and it felt like my insides erupted. It didn't take long for him to find my pleasure zone. I moaned with every thrust and I began circling my hips counter clockwise.
"You feel so tight, baby." He pants. He leaned down, his hand massaging my breast. I took my free hand, setting it between my legs, stroking my clit as he penetrated.
I could feel my release coming. I began tightening myself around him making James groan. "Fuck baby. Do that again." He pleads and I oblige. He tilts his head back, his pace never faltering and his thrusts going deeper and deeper.
"James...." I whisper. I pull James closer to me, the angle of his cock changing making it even more unbearable. "James, I'm close." I whimper. My legs were feeling numb and my back was arched.
"Together, Tess." He slows down, the change of pace being exactly what I needed.
"James!" I yell out, not giving one care of who could hear. Seconds later James found his release. "Fuuuuck Tess!" He collapsed on top of me, both of us out of breath like we just finished a marathon.
I looked over at him, his chest heaving and his breath strained. James leaned over, his left hand resting on my stomach as he kissed me.
"I'm glad we waited, all the build up made it completely insane!" I kissed him back, my fingers playing with his curls.
"I love you." I say without hesitation. They say you connect deeply with someone who you've had great sex with and James was that guy. Minutes ago I was telling him that I could love him and now, I do love him. I wasn't afraid for him to know it and I wasn't afraid to say it.
His finger swept my hair out of my face and he looked into my eyes.
"I'm madly in love with you Tess Mariot."
*** One year ago ***
Rumors circulated that Sid and I were dating. It was all over the news and Internet, photos of us hanging out at Local were plastered around fan sites and tumblr.
"It only took the media two years to start questioning us?" I was munching on some popcorn that Sid made for our weekly afternoon movie marathon.
"Apparently we make the perfect couple." He pulled up a hockey girlfriends message board. Of course, he had his own. I walked over to see him scrolling through the comments.
"She is soooooo pretty! They look adorable together."
"She's just with him for the fame. Money grubbing bitch."
"Her brothers play in the NHL too, I doubt she's looking for fame with Sid. They look happy together."
I rolled my eyes. Some people just have nothing better to do than talk about other people's personal lives.
"Sid, I'm only with you for your millions." I say planting a kiss on his cheek. That was one thing about Sid I loved, we were so comfortable around each other.
"I gotta go anyway, I have a hot date with a soccer ball." Sid stands up quickly, grabbing my arm just as I'm about to exit his house.
"Hey! What the-" Sid plants his lips on mine, his tongue spreading my mouth. I felt my legs go weak as his hand was holding me upright.
He pulled away looking for a response.
"Ummm. Sid. I have to go." I left as soon as I could trying to remain as calm as I could.
Pulling out of his driveway, Sid was still standing there. From what I could see, he looked hopeless.
As I got to the stadium for practice my phone started ringing.
"Hello?"
"Hey it's Nealer!" I tried to compose myself, I was still shocked from what happened.
"What's up?"
"I was wondering if you'd wanna catch a movie later? My treat."
"Not sure that's a good idea right now." I needed to talk to Sid about what happened.
"Oh come on. It's just a movie. I promise I don't bite, unless you're into that."
I started laughing. God he was so adorable. How could I say no to that?
"Charming. I have practice till 5. Make it dinner and a movie and I'll say yes."
"It's a date. I'll be at your house around 5:45."
I couldn't help from smiling. I don't know what it was but James was so persuasive.
"Tess!" I hear a call from behind me. I see Max running towards me.
"Why the huge smile?" She nudged my arm.
"You know that guy that plays with Sid? James Neal?"
She nods. "The guy you met like a year ago? The cutie?"
"Yeah! Well, I have a date with him tonight." I must have stopped smiling because Max began pressuring me for information.
"Tess. What did you do this time?"
"Sid kissed me. Like really kissed me."
Her eyes looked like they were going to pop out of her head.
"This could be an issue."
Aghh I need an update! This is great!
2/3/21