His Teammate's Sister

Aly still couldn't believe she had sex with her brother's teammate and felt extremely ashamed by doing so. Jacob was always a protective older brother and wanted to make sure his sister's dates and eventually boyfriend would live up to and abide by his standards. Despite feeling ashamed at times, Aly really enjoyed being with Chris and felt safe with him.

While Chris, Jacob, and the team had practice up in Tarrytown, Aly met up with Kelly for lunch on the Lower West Side. She was excited to finally have a sister and was able to talk to her, but really felt nervous about what she was going to say.

"Aly! There's my soon to be sister. How are you?" Kelly squealed, hugging her.

Aly nodded, "I'm good, I'm good."

The girls sat at their table and ordered drinks. Kelly could tell something was bugging her future sister and even though prying wasn't her thing, she was concerned, "Aly? Is something bothering you? You look flushed."

"Huh? Oh uh, no, I'm okay. What do you want to eat?" Aly asked, trying to avoid eye contact.

Kelly took Aly's hand, "Sis, I know something's bothering you. You barely touched your drink and you're not even picking at the bread. You can tell me anything."

"But you're going to tell Jacob and I can't have that," Aly worried.

"No I won't. You can trust me, sister to sister," Kelly assured.

Meanwhile, at the MSG Training Facility, the guys were gearing up for practice and miscellaneous chatter was among the locker room. Ryan Strome perked up, "Yo, Kreids, I heard you banged some chick last night. Damn, you move on fast."

Chris was really worried now because it's possible someone knows his secret, "What are you talking about?"

"Oh come on, Sydney told me you had a date last night and you banged her. Nice one bro," Ryan nudged.

"Yeah, whatever dude," Kreids shrugged off.

"I heard your sister has a new beau, too, Jacob," Brady added.

Jacob scoffed, "Dude, please. If she had a boyfriend, I'd know about it. Come on, let's go practice."

Chris had a sick feeling in his stomach because he knew he'd be screwed if Jacob found out that he was his sister's boyfriend.

Back at the restaurant, Aly eventually admitted to her future sister-in-law about what happened last night. She felt so ashamed, but at this point, Kelly was the only family she had in New York and told her.

"Aly, honey, you have to tell Jacob," Kelly said.

Aly shook her head, "Hell no. He's been so protective of me for eleven years. I just want to be free and date who I want."

"And that is what you have to tell him. We'll tell him together, tonight," Kelly promised.

Does Jacob finally loosen his grip or will hell break loose?

Notes