Login with:

Facebook

Twitter

Tumblr

Google

Yahoo

Aol.

Mibba

Your info will not be visible on the site. After logging in for the first time you'll be able to choose your display name.

Never Gonna Happen

First Choice

"And this is how it feels when I ignore the words you spoke to me,
and this is where I lose myself when I keep running away from you,
and this is who I am when, when I don't know myself anymore,
and this is what I choose when it's all left up to me."
~Red

~James~

She was quiet the entire ride back to my apartment. Quiet, but crying. Even when we went inside and up the stairs, she cried silent tears.

“Jenna,” I said softly, realizing that we were just standing in my kitchen. She sniffled and looked up at me through reddened eyes. I opened my arms, and reluctantly, she accepted my hug, pressing her tear-streaked face into my shoulder.

“I’m sorry for hitting you.” I almost laughed. Of all things she could’ve said to me, she decided to apologize for the surprisingly understandable slap she delivered to my face this morning.

“I’m fine, Jenna, it’s o-” She pulled away a little, cupping my cheek to check over my skin. I blushed. “Really, Jenna, I’m fine.” But she was close. So close. All I wanted was to kiss her beautiful, sad lips right then and there. But she pulled back almost as soon as the moment had begun, just as soon as she saw to it that I was all right.

She took a deep breath before speaking. “Sid and I are finished,” she muttered, swallowing hard, “for good.” I wasn’t sure whether or not I should be optimistic or shocked. Both, I supposed. I certainly was surprised. After all, despite their recent rocky streak, Sid and Jenna were…well, they were indestructible. Inseparable. Solid. And suddenly it was over.

Part of me - a very selfish part of me - was happy. This could be my chance to finally be with Jenna, the girl I’ve drooled over practically since I got traded to Pittsburgh. Part of me felt sickened to know that I was part of the reason for their breakup, and therefore part of the reason that Jenna was so heartbroken.

I could see another fresh set of tears coming, so I hurried to put my arms around Jenna once more. As I held her, I glanced at the clock across the room. “Oh fuck, Jenna,” I exclaimed.

“W-what?”

“I have a game! I have to be at Consol in…” I counted quickly in my head, “half an hour. Shit.”

“I’ll leave,” said Jenna sadly.

“What?! No!” I let go of Jenna to look her in the eye. “You can come. If you want.” I knew it might be the last thing she wanted, but at least if she went to the game, I could keep an eye on her. Or Lia, or Veronique. One of the girls. Someone.

But she shook her head. “No, thank you. I think I’ll just go back to our - Sid’s - apartment and…get my stuff. You know.”

“Well,” I said, a little disappointed, “you know you can stay here as long as you want. I don’t mind at all.” She shrugged.

Damn, I thought. About as bad as a rejection.

~Jenna~

As soon as James left, I exhaled deeply. I still couldn’t believe it. How? How could Sid cheat on me after all we’d been through? After telling me day after day that he loved me? After he held me every night as we slept? After he kissed me good morning each day? I just didn’t understand. I didn’t want to understand. All I wanted was for it to be a dream. A bad dream that I could just wake up from and forget.

I’d told him he was supposed to be perfect. He was, and somehow, he failed me. Sidney Crosby, the kid, the golden boy, my one true love, had been…a mistake. A horrible, heartbreaking mistake.

But James, on the other hand… Well, the past few weeks, James had been everything Sid wasn’t. He was kind and understanding and sympathetic. And he asked me, practically begged me, to stay with him. I would. Part of me wanted to. But what would that help? If anything, it would make a bigger mess of the already shitty nightmare that was supposed to be my life.

Instead of accepting his welcoming invitation, though, I made my decision. I’d go to our - SID’S - apartment, gather my things, and head to Lia’s.

~James~

Overtime losses were the worst. You got your hopes up - maybe, just maybe, things would work out, and you could pull it off in the end. And then, just like that, it’d be over. Done. A loss. And usually after overtime losses, I’d dread going home, because all home would be is a bed to fall into and stay in until the losing feeling wore off. Or at least until I had to get up for practice.’

But tonight, I was looking forward to going home. Home was where Jenna was. Except after I rushed out of the arena, drove home, and hurried inside, my apartment was empty. I guessed she was still getting her things.

“Do you need help,” I texted, “or do you need a ride?”

As soon as it sent, though, the buzzer rang. Jenna. I quickly hit the button without even bothering to see who it was. After all, I was only expecting one person tonight. Moments later, there was a knock on the door. I couldn’t help but smile when I threw the door open. But that smile disappeared when I saw who it was.

“Oh,” I said, coming face-to-face with Becca, “it’s you.”

Her own smile flickered with a tinge of hurt. “James,” she said, doing her best to keep her happiness on. “I…you know, I always visit after…after losses.” But my comment hurt; even I could tell that.

“Yeah!” I said, flashing her a reassuring smile, even though my thoughts were still on Jenna. “Yeah, come on in.” This seemed to relieve her a little, and her soft smile returned as she stepped through the doorway.

“Sorry about the loss,” she said in a small voice. She always had been very understanding. A good friend, definitely.

“Yeah,” I sighed. I flopped on the couch, wondering when Jenna might text me back. Becca joined me, looking at me sympathetically.

My phone buzzed in my pocket and I sprang to answer it. “Important call?” laughed Becca nervously. I wasn’t sure if she was joking or not. I quickly read the text from Lia.

“Jenna’s spending the night here, just thought I’d let you know she’s ok.”

My heart sank, and Becca could tell. “Oh James, you’ll have the next game,” she said, trying to be optimistic. God, she still thought I was upset about THAT.

“Yeah,” I agreed, not wanting to explain about Jenna. “Yeah, we’ll just…play better. You know.”

“It’s about Jenna, isn’t it?” She knew, then. Fuck, Beck was smarter than I gave her credit for. But she didn’t ask anything else. “James…” she said softly. She reached over and took my hand, and I realized then just how much I wanted to feel that kind of touch. Gentle, caring. Even if it wasn’t Jenna. I leaned over and let her lips sooth the tension from my own, making a mental note to be thankful for an amazing, no-strings-attached, great friend like Becca.

~Becca~

I watched James sleep. He always looked the same. Flat on his back, one arm lazily draped over his chest, the other stretched up and curled above his head on his pillow. Everything, his messy hair, his tight abs, his perfectly-toned muscles…everything about him was just so incredibly attractive. I yawned tiredly and pulled a blanket over my now-unclothed body. He cared about me. I knew he did. But not in the same way as I cared about him. Tonight I was the one in his bed. Tonight I was his second choice.

All I wanted at all was to be his first.

Notes

Who here likes Becca? Tell me. :)

Prequel

Forever

NC-17 Romance Drama

Lia Morgan has had a lifelong battle against depression and anorexia. But once she meets Jordan Staal, could things change for the better?

1/6/13

Completed ✓
9.7 19 Votes

Comments

@nanshil87
I actually updated recently on Mibba and will try to post that here today. Glad you like the story!!

leecasper17
12/9/13
This is an interesting story. When are you going to update again?
nanshil87 nanshil87
12/5/13
This is such a great story, I love it. I still don't know who to choose Sid/Jenna or James/Jenna
Sidster87 Sidster87
4/9/13
Jenna/Sid!!
puckme69 puckme69
2/12/13
i am in love with jordan and lia. now i just want jenna to make up her mind of who she wants. someone has to give because the egos are a bit much...
ldw choice ldw choice
1/14/13