Never Gonna Happen
Misunderstandings #2
"...a love like ours is love that's hard to find,
how could we let it slip away?
We've come too far to leave it all behind,
how could we end it all this way?
When tomorrow comes and we'll both regret,
the things we said today..."
~Chicago
~James; April 11th, 2012~
I stretched my arms, waking up slowly and thinking of what had happened last night. We went out, Sid was a dick, Jordan and Lia were there, Jenna -
My eyes snapped open. Jenna. I glanced next to me and breathed a sigh of relief when I saw her, still sleeping peacefully. It was all coming back. Jenna was just a shell of herself, and it was all Sid’s fault. I’d never thought I could hate a teammate the way I hated Sid right now. But I wanted to kill him, just for hurting Jenna. For making her cry herself to sleep thinking everything was somehow her fault. Which it wasn’t. It was Sid’s fault. And I hated him.
I never got to look at Jenna the way I wanted to. If she was awake, I couldn’t stare at her, take in all of her beautiful features. But now, I could look at her. She really was gorgeous, the way her brown hair fell around her face, and her long eyelashes were flush against her closed eyes. But she looked sad as she slept. Upset. She’d be a wreck when she woke up, I knew that much. As much as I hated leaving her, I decided to get out of bed. At least when she woke up, now she’d be able to collect her thoughts to herself. I put on a pot of coffee, and a thought occurred to me? Was I lucky? Or was I unlucky? After all, Jenna was here. I was taking care of her. She was with me. But at the same side, she wouldn’t be here if she took me for any more than a helpful friend. So…she was here, but I was only a friend. That’s not what I wanted. I didn’t want to be the friend or the rebound or the whatever. I didn’t want her to run from Sid and end up with me. I wanted her to run to me because she cared.
~Sid~
I didn’t want to open my eyes. I felt a splitting headache coming on already, and that was without the bright light to complicate things. If I opened my eyes, all hell would break loose, hangover-wise. So I kept them closed, pulled Jenna closer, and sighed.
“Morning,” she mumbled. Except it wasn’t Jenna’s voice, it was -
“Ohfuck,” I swore, reluctantly opening my eyes to find not only a piercing pain in my head, but also a rather slutty-looking blonde next to me. No. No, this was not happening. I didn’t cheat on Jenna. I couldn’t. I wouldn’t. Yet…I did. “You need to leave,” I said quickly, my mind scrambling to figure out what to do.
“What?” the blonde asked. “But wh-”
“Just go!” I said, giving her a harsh nudge out of the bed. She scoffed, but quickly began to pick up her clothes from the floor. I sat up slowly and put my head in my hands. I’d fucked up with Jenna before. Bad. But never, ever as bad as this. “How am I going to fix this?” I mumbled. The blonde, finally realizing what was good for her, chose not to respond. Instead, she hastily left. At least the first of my problems was gone. But how could I ever, ever make it up to Jenna? And…where WAS Jenna?
I snatched my phone off the nightstand and quickly punched in the speed dial. But there was no answer. “Jenna!” I said once the tone sounded. “Jenna, call me. I’m so worried. Where are you? Please, baby, call me as soon as you get this.” I racked my brain for more options, deciding next to call Staal.
“Hello?” he answered on the first ring.
“Staalsy? It’s me. It’s Sid. Have you seen Jenna? I mean, do you know where she is? She’s not home, she’d not answering her -”
“Are you fucking kidding me Sid?” he said angrily. He sounded pissed. More than pissed.
“Staalsy…” I mumbled. “I just…need to find -”
“I told you not to take that girl home,” he said coldly. “I told you you were screwing up. This, all of this, is your own fucking fault. I’m not Jenna’s babysitter, and I’m not yours either. Get your shit together, and don’t call me again. I’m trying to enjoy my morning with Lia before the game.” He promptly hung up.
The game. Shit, we had a game. Against, the Flyers, too. Fucking Giroux. But that didn’t matter, even stupid pansy Giroux didn’t matter. I had to find Jenna. Reluctantly, I dialed Geno’s number.
“Hello?” he answered in a thick Russian accent.
“Geno, is Jenna with you? Or do you know where she is?”
“Sid? No… I… Jenna is not here.”
“But…” Oh, god. “Okay, thanks.” I hung up. That left one other option, seeing as few of my teammates were close enough with Jenna to have an idea of where she could be. Very unwillingly, I dialed James’ number.
There was no answer. My heart sank. It was my fault, of course, but if James took advantage of Jenna - my Jenna - I swear, I’d kill him.
~Jenna~
I woke up in a bed that wasn’t mine. My Sidney wasn’t lying beside me. A feeling of panic flooded through my body, and paired with the raging hangover I felt, I wanted to puke.
And then my heart stopped. If I was in someone else’s bed and I didn’t remember last night…then I had to have cheated on Sid. Tears came to my eyes. This couldn’t be happening. I would never… But who…?
Trying to ignore my headache, I got out of the bed and peered out into the kitchen, where, at the kitchen table, was…James. My blood boiled in my veins. I drank too much last night, that much was obvious. And I knew James had feelings for me. But I never, ever thought he would take advantage of me.
As if he knew I was watching, he glanced up from his coffee to find me there. A small smile appeared on his face. “Hi, Jenna,” he said gently, coming to greet me. And I slapped him. I hit him so hard across the face that even I was a little surprised.
“Jenna,” he said, stepping back a bit. “I…what?”
“How could you do this, James?” I yelled, hot tears stinging my eyes. “H-how could you take advantage of me? Y-you knew I was upset about Sid, you knew I -”
“No, Jenna, you don’t understand! I didn’t - we didn’t -”
“What do you mean, ‘we didn’t?’ We did, and it’s your fault! I can’t believe…I…I cheated on Sid…” I took a deep, shaky breath before glaring at him again. “And it’s YOUR fault! You had me when…when I was weak, and you -”
“You didn’t cheat on Sid, Jenna!” he yelled finally. “He cheated on you! And I was trying to help you.” His voice softened. “I took care of you.”
I blinked. “No,” I said simply.
“He did, Jenna,” he said carefully. “He…he left the club with some blonde girl.”
“Sid wouldn’t do that,” I said.
“He did, and we…we talked about it last night, remember?” I didn’t remember anything from last night. But this couldn’t have happened. “Jenna…he did.”
I shook my head silently and grabbed my things from last night. I had to go home. I had to find out the truth.
***
Sid was there, in the kitchen, when I opened the door. “Sid!” I ran in and threw my arms around him.
“Jenna!” he wrapped his arms around me, too. “I was so worried! I didn’t know where you were!”
“Oh Sid, I’m sorry,” I said, feeling that horrible feeling in my stomach. “I’m so sorry. I…I have to tell you something.”
“Jenna, I’m the one who should be sorry. Not you.”
And everything suddenly fit together. My heart dropped. James had been right. I let go and took a step back. “What?”
“I…I said I should be sorry, not you.” He looked at me nervously.
“Did you cheat on me?” I asked quietly, hoping he’d deny it. Hoping it was all a lie.
He opened his mouth, but no words came. So he nodded.
“How…” I whispered. “How could you do that?”
“Jenna -”
“You said you LOVED me!”
“I know, I’m sorry! I don’t know how to fix it -”
“You can’t!” I screamed, stepping away every time he tried to get closer to me. This was all wrong; I’d thought everything was my fault. Sid was supposed to be perfect. I never thought he could hurt me. “You CAN’T fix this! This…this is horrible! How could you sleep with another girl?”
“No, Jenna, please -”
“I hate you!” I walked out of our apartment and slammed the door in his face before running down the hall and down the staircase. I’d taken a cab here and had no way of getting anywhere else. It didn’t matter, I supposed, as long as I wasn’t here anymore. I blinked back tears. I couldn’t cry. I wouldn’t cry for Sid, not after what he’d done.
To my surprise, James’ car was parked in front of my building. He knew. He’d known all along. He did try to tell me, after all. Choking back more tears, I opened his car door and sat down inside. “Can you…” I sniffled. “Can you take me to Lia’s? I d-don’t want to b-bother you.”
“No,” he replied. “You’re never a bother, Jenna.” Something about his blue eyes was positively glimmering.
“But -”
“You can stay with me.” I nodded silently, and he put the car into drive.
“You know,” he said after driving in silence for several minutes. “It’s okay to cry, Jenna. There’s nothing wrong with feeling.”
I looked out the window, wanting to shut out his words. But as building after building passed by, I felt a hot tear, followed by many more, roll down my cheek.
how could we let it slip away?
We've come too far to leave it all behind,
how could we end it all this way?
When tomorrow comes and we'll both regret,
the things we said today..."
~Chicago
~James; April 11th, 2012~
I stretched my arms, waking up slowly and thinking of what had happened last night. We went out, Sid was a dick, Jordan and Lia were there, Jenna -
My eyes snapped open. Jenna. I glanced next to me and breathed a sigh of relief when I saw her, still sleeping peacefully. It was all coming back. Jenna was just a shell of herself, and it was all Sid’s fault. I’d never thought I could hate a teammate the way I hated Sid right now. But I wanted to kill him, just for hurting Jenna. For making her cry herself to sleep thinking everything was somehow her fault. Which it wasn’t. It was Sid’s fault. And I hated him.
I never got to look at Jenna the way I wanted to. If she was awake, I couldn’t stare at her, take in all of her beautiful features. But now, I could look at her. She really was gorgeous, the way her brown hair fell around her face, and her long eyelashes were flush against her closed eyes. But she looked sad as she slept. Upset. She’d be a wreck when she woke up, I knew that much. As much as I hated leaving her, I decided to get out of bed. At least when she woke up, now she’d be able to collect her thoughts to herself. I put on a pot of coffee, and a thought occurred to me? Was I lucky? Or was I unlucky? After all, Jenna was here. I was taking care of her. She was with me. But at the same side, she wouldn’t be here if she took me for any more than a helpful friend. So…she was here, but I was only a friend. That’s not what I wanted. I didn’t want to be the friend or the rebound or the whatever. I didn’t want her to run from Sid and end up with me. I wanted her to run to me because she cared.
~Sid~
I didn’t want to open my eyes. I felt a splitting headache coming on already, and that was without the bright light to complicate things. If I opened my eyes, all hell would break loose, hangover-wise. So I kept them closed, pulled Jenna closer, and sighed.
“Morning,” she mumbled. Except it wasn’t Jenna’s voice, it was -
“Ohfuck,” I swore, reluctantly opening my eyes to find not only a piercing pain in my head, but also a rather slutty-looking blonde next to me. No. No, this was not happening. I didn’t cheat on Jenna. I couldn’t. I wouldn’t. Yet…I did. “You need to leave,” I said quickly, my mind scrambling to figure out what to do.
“What?” the blonde asked. “But wh-”
“Just go!” I said, giving her a harsh nudge out of the bed. She scoffed, but quickly began to pick up her clothes from the floor. I sat up slowly and put my head in my hands. I’d fucked up with Jenna before. Bad. But never, ever as bad as this. “How am I going to fix this?” I mumbled. The blonde, finally realizing what was good for her, chose not to respond. Instead, she hastily left. At least the first of my problems was gone. But how could I ever, ever make it up to Jenna? And…where WAS Jenna?
I snatched my phone off the nightstand and quickly punched in the speed dial. But there was no answer. “Jenna!” I said once the tone sounded. “Jenna, call me. I’m so worried. Where are you? Please, baby, call me as soon as you get this.” I racked my brain for more options, deciding next to call Staal.
“Hello?” he answered on the first ring.
“Staalsy? It’s me. It’s Sid. Have you seen Jenna? I mean, do you know where she is? She’s not home, she’d not answering her -”
“Are you fucking kidding me Sid?” he said angrily. He sounded pissed. More than pissed.
“Staalsy…” I mumbled. “I just…need to find -”
“I told you not to take that girl home,” he said coldly. “I told you you were screwing up. This, all of this, is your own fucking fault. I’m not Jenna’s babysitter, and I’m not yours either. Get your shit together, and don’t call me again. I’m trying to enjoy my morning with Lia before the game.” He promptly hung up.
The game. Shit, we had a game. Against, the Flyers, too. Fucking Giroux. But that didn’t matter, even stupid pansy Giroux didn’t matter. I had to find Jenna. Reluctantly, I dialed Geno’s number.
“Hello?” he answered in a thick Russian accent.
“Geno, is Jenna with you? Or do you know where she is?”
“Sid? No… I… Jenna is not here.”
“But…” Oh, god. “Okay, thanks.” I hung up. That left one other option, seeing as few of my teammates were close enough with Jenna to have an idea of where she could be. Very unwillingly, I dialed James’ number.
There was no answer. My heart sank. It was my fault, of course, but if James took advantage of Jenna - my Jenna - I swear, I’d kill him.
~Jenna~
I woke up in a bed that wasn’t mine. My Sidney wasn’t lying beside me. A feeling of panic flooded through my body, and paired with the raging hangover I felt, I wanted to puke.
And then my heart stopped. If I was in someone else’s bed and I didn’t remember last night…then I had to have cheated on Sid. Tears came to my eyes. This couldn’t be happening. I would never… But who…?
Trying to ignore my headache, I got out of the bed and peered out into the kitchen, where, at the kitchen table, was…James. My blood boiled in my veins. I drank too much last night, that much was obvious. And I knew James had feelings for me. But I never, ever thought he would take advantage of me.
As if he knew I was watching, he glanced up from his coffee to find me there. A small smile appeared on his face. “Hi, Jenna,” he said gently, coming to greet me. And I slapped him. I hit him so hard across the face that even I was a little surprised.
“Jenna,” he said, stepping back a bit. “I…what?”
“How could you do this, James?” I yelled, hot tears stinging my eyes. “H-how could you take advantage of me? Y-you knew I was upset about Sid, you knew I -”
“No, Jenna, you don’t understand! I didn’t - we didn’t -”
“What do you mean, ‘we didn’t?’ We did, and it’s your fault! I can’t believe…I…I cheated on Sid…” I took a deep, shaky breath before glaring at him again. “And it’s YOUR fault! You had me when…when I was weak, and you -”
“You didn’t cheat on Sid, Jenna!” he yelled finally. “He cheated on you! And I was trying to help you.” His voice softened. “I took care of you.”
I blinked. “No,” I said simply.
“He did, Jenna,” he said carefully. “He…he left the club with some blonde girl.”
“Sid wouldn’t do that,” I said.
“He did, and we…we talked about it last night, remember?” I didn’t remember anything from last night. But this couldn’t have happened. “Jenna…he did.”
I shook my head silently and grabbed my things from last night. I had to go home. I had to find out the truth.
***
Sid was there, in the kitchen, when I opened the door. “Sid!” I ran in and threw my arms around him.
“Jenna!” he wrapped his arms around me, too. “I was so worried! I didn’t know where you were!”
“Oh Sid, I’m sorry,” I said, feeling that horrible feeling in my stomach. “I’m so sorry. I…I have to tell you something.”
“Jenna, I’m the one who should be sorry. Not you.”
And everything suddenly fit together. My heart dropped. James had been right. I let go and took a step back. “What?”
“I…I said I should be sorry, not you.” He looked at me nervously.
“Did you cheat on me?” I asked quietly, hoping he’d deny it. Hoping it was all a lie.
He opened his mouth, but no words came. So he nodded.
“How…” I whispered. “How could you do that?”
“Jenna -”
“You said you LOVED me!”
“I know, I’m sorry! I don’t know how to fix it -”
“You can’t!” I screamed, stepping away every time he tried to get closer to me. This was all wrong; I’d thought everything was my fault. Sid was supposed to be perfect. I never thought he could hurt me. “You CAN’T fix this! This…this is horrible! How could you sleep with another girl?”
“No, Jenna, please -”
“I hate you!” I walked out of our apartment and slammed the door in his face before running down the hall and down the staircase. I’d taken a cab here and had no way of getting anywhere else. It didn’t matter, I supposed, as long as I wasn’t here anymore. I blinked back tears. I couldn’t cry. I wouldn’t cry for Sid, not after what he’d done.
To my surprise, James’ car was parked in front of my building. He knew. He’d known all along. He did try to tell me, after all. Choking back more tears, I opened his car door and sat down inside. “Can you…” I sniffled. “Can you take me to Lia’s? I d-don’t want to b-bother you.”
“No,” he replied. “You’re never a bother, Jenna.” Something about his blue eyes was positively glimmering.
“But -”
“You can stay with me.” I nodded silently, and he put the car into drive.
“You know,” he said after driving in silence for several minutes. “It’s okay to cry, Jenna. There’s nothing wrong with feeling.”
I looked out the window, wanting to shut out his words. But as building after building passed by, I felt a hot tear, followed by many more, roll down my cheek.
@nanshil87
I actually updated recently on Mibba and will try to post that here today. Glad you like the story!!
12/9/13