Never Gonna Happen
Saying No
"...but go on and take it,
Take it all with you.
Don't look back,
at this crumbling fool..."
~Adele
~Jenna~
I followed James out of the living room, down the hall, and into Jordan and Lia’s kitchen. It was quiet, thankfully; you couldn’t hear the group of teammates and friends who sat, stunned by James and Sid’s behavior, down the hall. Lia’s kitchen was quaint but pretty. I knew Jordan had let her decorate it herself. The main part was neat and organized; the small sitting room to the side was adorable. There was a clean glass coffee table placed in front of two wicker armchairs, and a single long bench adorned with a white cushion.
“Jenna, we need to talk,” said James, taking my hand. He led me to the bench, where we both sat down. After taking a deep breath, he began to speak. “I don’t like the way Sid’s been treating you lately.” I instantly opened my mouth to speak, but he wouldn’t let me. “I’ve been watching you guys fight,” he continued. “He’s my teammate, my friend, but I can’t stand to watch him mistreat you.”
“It’s fine, James,” I said hotly. “He gets overprotective sometimes, but he’s not MISTREATING me. You don’t even understand, anyway. You don’t know what it’s about.” He gave me a sullen look that suggested otherwise, but I continued. “It’s a phase,” I explained. “I’ll have him in his place soon enough.”
He looked at me, his eyes filled with frustration. “You don’t understand, Jenna,” he said. “I’m…I’m worried about you. The way he yells at you, and calls you out for things that are out of your control…it’s just not right. He shouldn’t do that to you. I would never do that to you.”
I sighed. Games of comparison were not what I needed right now. “I’m sure you wouldn’t, James,” I said.
“Sometimes I think I care about you more than he does.”
I blinked. “James…what? Sid…Sid’s my boyfriend.”
“He doesn’t act like it,” said James.
“You don’t understand,” I said again.
“YOU don’t understand!” said James. Not angrily. But he was frustrated. “Jenna, I care about you. More than you think. Sid, he…he’s got it right. I care about you a lot.”
“James!”
“Just listen to me, for once!” he said, running his hand through his hair in frustration. “I care about you, not because I’m some scumbag girlfriend-stealer! I care about you because I know how much better I’d be than Sid is. I know that…that if you were with me, you’d be the most important thing. It wouldn’t matter what I think, you’d come first. I really like you, Jenna. Really. You’ve never noticed, and it kills me, because I know that if you took the time to -”
“Are you drunk, James?” I asked shakily. I felt lightheaded. Sick. For so long, I’d tried to prove Sid wrong…only to find that I was the one who’d been wrong. “You don’t know what you’re saying.”
“No, Jenna…I…” Unsure of what else to do, James took my hands and pressed his lips against mine.
~Lia~
Just as soon as the living room had returned to an almost-comfortable buzz of chatter, Jenna’s sharp, furious voice cut through the conversation.
“Don’t EVER do that to me again, James!” she yelled, her voice approaching the living room. “I have a BOYFRIEND!”
“Mon dieu…” muttered Claire beside me.
Jenna burst into the room, trailed hopelessly by James. “I want to go home,” she said to Sid, fuming. He was immediately at her side. They got their coats quickly, but just as they were leaving, Sid turned to glare at James.
“I don’t know what you did,” he said. “But you’re a fucking son of a bitch.” He slammed the door, and once again, the living room was a mess of tense silence. James was left standing speechless by the entrance to the hall. For a while, no one spoke.
“James?” Becca said shyly after having gathered her courage. “It’s…it’s getting late.” James nodded silently. “Do you want to, um…?”
“Sure,” he said quietly. Becca stood up and got not only her coat, but James’ jacket also.
“Here,” she said in a near-whisper, handing it to him. She looked at all of us, all of James’ teammates and their wives and their girlfriends. “It-it was nice meeting you all,” she stammered.
“It was nice to meet you, too, Becca,” said Veronique, the first to speak. The rest of us could only murmur in agreement. The two left quietly, and the room resumed its silence.
“That’s fucked up,” someone said simply.
~Becca~
I volunteered to drive James’ car. Honestly, I didn’t think he was capable of doing much besides staring out the window in miserable regret.
“Do you want to talk about it?” I asked after we’d been driving for several minutes.
Silence.
I knew James was utterly head-over-heels for Jenna. He had been for a while, from what he’d told me. She’d seemed like a nice girl when I met her, but I just didn’t understand. Her boyfriend really did seem like a dick. Why wouldn’t she want someone better? Someone sweet, and funny, and handsome, and kind, all rolled into one? Someone like James. What girl wouldn’t want someone like James to love her?
I shook my head sadly and slowed the car as we came to a red light. “Maybe…” I mused. “Maybe it’s because you forced it on her all at once, you know?”
“No,” he mumbled. Well. At least he said anything at all. “No, Bec, this is what I get. It doesn’t matter how nice I am to her. How much I tell her I care. She’s just going to go back to him.” I wasn’t quite sure how to respond to that, but in the end, it didn’t matter. He had more to say. “And now, I’m going to have to go back, and see them all. After all of that, I still have a team to play for. People to see. And they all saw what happened tonight. Bec, they must think I’m an idiot.”
“No,” I said kindly. But for all I knew, they would. Maybe they saw James as the idiot who chased his teammate’s girlfriend. Maybe they saw ME as the idiot who chased the idiot who chased his teammate’s girlfriend. Maybe I was the idiot. And yet, when I looked at him, so sad and hopeless, I couldn’t fight the want, no, the need to be with him.
“Well…” I said, pulling into the parking lot of his building. “Want me to come in for a while?”
“Sure,” he said. I followed him into his apartment, but once we were inside, he simply stripped to his boxers and went to bed.
“James,” I said, laughing nervously. “You wanted me to come inside just to watch you sleep?”
“Stay, Becca,” he mumbled into his pillow. I couldn’t help but smile as I felt the warm rush of butterflies in my heart. I washed up quickly in his bathroom and took off my clothes, leaving just my pale pink lace bra and panties on. I climbed into James’ bed next to him.
“You sleeping, James?” I asked softly.
“Nhn,” he replied. All I wanted was to crawl into his arms and be close to him. But this was James. James, my “fuck buddy.” My “friend with benefits.” No matter how much I wanted more, he’d never know. I couldn’t tell him. I wouldn’t. He was sweet and funny, and all my life I’d wanted a guy like him, but I agreed to this on friendly terms. Nothing more. Maybe, just maybe, I’d tell him how I felt, if he wasn’t looking elsewhere. But he wanted Jenna. Beautiful, perfect Jenna. I wasn’t her. I’d never be her.
Sometimes, I wondered why I even bothered anymore. I was just letting myself be hurt every time I got into his bed. I knew tomorrow morning he’d want sex. I should say no. But this was James. I couldn’t say no to him.
Take it all with you.
Don't look back,
at this crumbling fool..."
~Adele
~Jenna~
I followed James out of the living room, down the hall, and into Jordan and Lia’s kitchen. It was quiet, thankfully; you couldn’t hear the group of teammates and friends who sat, stunned by James and Sid’s behavior, down the hall. Lia’s kitchen was quaint but pretty. I knew Jordan had let her decorate it herself. The main part was neat and organized; the small sitting room to the side was adorable. There was a clean glass coffee table placed in front of two wicker armchairs, and a single long bench adorned with a white cushion.
“Jenna, we need to talk,” said James, taking my hand. He led me to the bench, where we both sat down. After taking a deep breath, he began to speak. “I don’t like the way Sid’s been treating you lately.” I instantly opened my mouth to speak, but he wouldn’t let me. “I’ve been watching you guys fight,” he continued. “He’s my teammate, my friend, but I can’t stand to watch him mistreat you.”
“It’s fine, James,” I said hotly. “He gets overprotective sometimes, but he’s not MISTREATING me. You don’t even understand, anyway. You don’t know what it’s about.” He gave me a sullen look that suggested otherwise, but I continued. “It’s a phase,” I explained. “I’ll have him in his place soon enough.”
He looked at me, his eyes filled with frustration. “You don’t understand, Jenna,” he said. “I’m…I’m worried about you. The way he yells at you, and calls you out for things that are out of your control…it’s just not right. He shouldn’t do that to you. I would never do that to you.”
I sighed. Games of comparison were not what I needed right now. “I’m sure you wouldn’t, James,” I said.
“Sometimes I think I care about you more than he does.”
I blinked. “James…what? Sid…Sid’s my boyfriend.”
“He doesn’t act like it,” said James.
“You don’t understand,” I said again.
“YOU don’t understand!” said James. Not angrily. But he was frustrated. “Jenna, I care about you. More than you think. Sid, he…he’s got it right. I care about you a lot.”
“James!”
“Just listen to me, for once!” he said, running his hand through his hair in frustration. “I care about you, not because I’m some scumbag girlfriend-stealer! I care about you because I know how much better I’d be than Sid is. I know that…that if you were with me, you’d be the most important thing. It wouldn’t matter what I think, you’d come first. I really like you, Jenna. Really. You’ve never noticed, and it kills me, because I know that if you took the time to -”
“Are you drunk, James?” I asked shakily. I felt lightheaded. Sick. For so long, I’d tried to prove Sid wrong…only to find that I was the one who’d been wrong. “You don’t know what you’re saying.”
“No, Jenna…I…” Unsure of what else to do, James took my hands and pressed his lips against mine.
~Lia~
Just as soon as the living room had returned to an almost-comfortable buzz of chatter, Jenna’s sharp, furious voice cut through the conversation.
“Don’t EVER do that to me again, James!” she yelled, her voice approaching the living room. “I have a BOYFRIEND!”
“Mon dieu…” muttered Claire beside me.
Jenna burst into the room, trailed hopelessly by James. “I want to go home,” she said to Sid, fuming. He was immediately at her side. They got their coats quickly, but just as they were leaving, Sid turned to glare at James.
“I don’t know what you did,” he said. “But you’re a fucking son of a bitch.” He slammed the door, and once again, the living room was a mess of tense silence. James was left standing speechless by the entrance to the hall. For a while, no one spoke.
“James?” Becca said shyly after having gathered her courage. “It’s…it’s getting late.” James nodded silently. “Do you want to, um…?”
“Sure,” he said quietly. Becca stood up and got not only her coat, but James’ jacket also.
“Here,” she said in a near-whisper, handing it to him. She looked at all of us, all of James’ teammates and their wives and their girlfriends. “It-it was nice meeting you all,” she stammered.
“It was nice to meet you, too, Becca,” said Veronique, the first to speak. The rest of us could only murmur in agreement. The two left quietly, and the room resumed its silence.
“That’s fucked up,” someone said simply.
~Becca~
I volunteered to drive James’ car. Honestly, I didn’t think he was capable of doing much besides staring out the window in miserable regret.
“Do you want to talk about it?” I asked after we’d been driving for several minutes.
Silence.
I knew James was utterly head-over-heels for Jenna. He had been for a while, from what he’d told me. She’d seemed like a nice girl when I met her, but I just didn’t understand. Her boyfriend really did seem like a dick. Why wouldn’t she want someone better? Someone sweet, and funny, and handsome, and kind, all rolled into one? Someone like James. What girl wouldn’t want someone like James to love her?
I shook my head sadly and slowed the car as we came to a red light. “Maybe…” I mused. “Maybe it’s because you forced it on her all at once, you know?”
“No,” he mumbled. Well. At least he said anything at all. “No, Bec, this is what I get. It doesn’t matter how nice I am to her. How much I tell her I care. She’s just going to go back to him.” I wasn’t quite sure how to respond to that, but in the end, it didn’t matter. He had more to say. “And now, I’m going to have to go back, and see them all. After all of that, I still have a team to play for. People to see. And they all saw what happened tonight. Bec, they must think I’m an idiot.”
“No,” I said kindly. But for all I knew, they would. Maybe they saw James as the idiot who chased his teammate’s girlfriend. Maybe they saw ME as the idiot who chased the idiot who chased his teammate’s girlfriend. Maybe I was the idiot. And yet, when I looked at him, so sad and hopeless, I couldn’t fight the want, no, the need to be with him.
“Well…” I said, pulling into the parking lot of his building. “Want me to come in for a while?”
“Sure,” he said. I followed him into his apartment, but once we were inside, he simply stripped to his boxers and went to bed.
“James,” I said, laughing nervously. “You wanted me to come inside just to watch you sleep?”
“Stay, Becca,” he mumbled into his pillow. I couldn’t help but smile as I felt the warm rush of butterflies in my heart. I washed up quickly in his bathroom and took off my clothes, leaving just my pale pink lace bra and panties on. I climbed into James’ bed next to him.
“You sleeping, James?” I asked softly.
“Nhn,” he replied. All I wanted was to crawl into his arms and be close to him. But this was James. James, my “fuck buddy.” My “friend with benefits.” No matter how much I wanted more, he’d never know. I couldn’t tell him. I wouldn’t. He was sweet and funny, and all my life I’d wanted a guy like him, but I agreed to this on friendly terms. Nothing more. Maybe, just maybe, I’d tell him how I felt, if he wasn’t looking elsewhere. But he wanted Jenna. Beautiful, perfect Jenna. I wasn’t her. I’d never be her.
Sometimes, I wondered why I even bothered anymore. I was just letting myself be hurt every time I got into his bed. I knew tomorrow morning he’d want sex. I should say no. But this was James. I couldn’t say no to him.
@nanshil87
I actually updated recently on Mibba and will try to post that here today. Glad you like the story!!
12/9/13