Never Gonna Happen
Yogurt, Mochas, and Stefon
“…so here we are, fighting and trying to hide the scars.
I’ll be home tonight, take a breath and softly say goodbye…”
~Breaking Benjamin
~Sid~
“What went on in there?” I asked Jenna as she rummaged through her bureau. “What happened between you and James?”
She took out a nightgown and looked at me coldly. “Nothing, Sidney,” she replied. Before I could say anything more, she swept into the bathroom and closed the door shut. I sighed, with nothing to do but lie back on our comforter and listen. The faucet ran on and off; I could hear her brushing her teeth; her makeup bag zipped open and closed. She emerged a few minutes later having changed into her nightgown and cleaned the makeup off her face. Without saying a word to me, she put her clothes away and got into bed silently, turning off the lamp on her dresser. I hastily stripped down to my boxers and followed suit. She lay on the far right, something she rarely did. We always lay together, and usually on my side.
“Jenna, baby,” I murmured, reaching a hand out to rub her arm. “What happened? Something’s wrong. You’re upset.” I knew she’d do this. She always shut her feelings out to everyone. She hardly ever opened up.
She pulled her arm away. “Nothing,” she said in that same icy tone. My heart ached. I didn’t want her to be like this, to be so unhappy. If she only told me what she was feeling, I could help her. I knew I could. But she refused to say anything.
“Jenna,” I pressed, wondering what it would take to get through to her. “Tell me what’s wrong. I can’t help you if you won’t even speak to me.”
She turned over and looked at me hard. “Why are you suddenly kissing my ass, Sid?” she snapped. I opened my mouth to speak, but she went on. “Why do you think you can ‘help’ me? Don’t you remember? It was you who yelled at me in the first place. ‘Way to go, Jenna, now everyone’s talking.’ That’s what you said. Remember?”
“Jenna…I’m really sorry. Really, I shouldn’t have -”
“It’s like you thought it was entirely my fault! Maybe everyone was talking, but it’s not just me, Sid. I didn’t force this over all of us. You might think I did and you might say I did, but I didn’t. It’s not my fault.”
“I know, baby, I know it isn’t. I’m sorry. I’m really sorry, I -”
“How long do you think you’re going to get away with a quick ‘I’m sorry?’” she yelled, sitting up. “It doesn’t work that way, Sid! ‘Sorry’ isn’t going to cut it all the time.” She threw the covers off of her, grabbed a throw blanket from the foot of the bed, and stormed out of the room.
“Jenna!” Fuck. This wasn’t going well. I hopped out of bed and went after her, following her to the living room, where she’d set herself up on the couch. Taking a deep breath, I picked up her light body. She placed her hands on my chest, pushing me away, resisting, but I simply sat down on the couch and held her. Frustrated and angry, she resumed her laying position. I followed, laying behind her, letting her body slowly sink into mine. I wished she’d talk to me. I wished she’d open up. What would it take? What would I have to do, to make her trust me? Growing tired and running out of options, I sat up a bit, cupped her cheek, and turned her head to mine. And I kissed her, softly, gently.
Taken aback and a little surprised, Jenna kissed me back. She let her lips part a little, and I could taste the sweetness of her mouth, her smooth, soft lips. “No,” she said, suddenly pulling away. So close. So, so close. “No, Sid, you can’t get out of this with kisses and sex. That’s what you always do. It’s not working this time.”
“Why are we even arguing, Jenna?” I sighed. “I don’t want this; I just want to be happy.”
“We’re arguing because we’re having problems.” It was the truth, but it hurt all the same. “You know that, Sid. And you can’t keep pretending our problems don’t exist. You can’t hide from the truth.” Even so, she leaned back against me, silent, but not exactly angry.
After a few moments, I closed my eyes. And then it occurred to me. Isn’t that what Jenna did all the time? Hide from the truth and pretend there was nothing wrong?
***
When I woke up to the bright morning sunlight, Jenna was no longer lying beside me. I sat up sharply, looking around to see where my girlfriend had gone. I was relieved to see her sitting at the counter and eating yogurt. She wasn’t with me, but she wasn’t gone. “Good morning,” I said, yawning and joining her in the kitchen. She only nodded. “That looks good,” I said, pointing to her yogurt and opening the fridge. She shrugged. “Jenna,” I sighed. “Now what? Why are you being quiet?”
And she said the two words I was getting very, very used to. “It’s nothing.”
Now I was annoyed. I thought we’d patched things up as much as we could last night, but now, in the morning, it felt like we were starting from square one again. “Is it because you finally realized you were wrong?” I asked quietly.
Jenna looked up from her cup of yogurt. “What?”
“Did you finally realize you’ve been wrong the whole time?”
“Sid,” she said slowly, “what are you talking about?”
“About James. I was right and you were wrong. He told you last night, didn’t he? He told you he was in love with you. And now you’re upset because you can’t go on denying the truth!” She said nothing. Absolutely nothing. And for that, I knew my assumption was correct. “I knew it,” I told her. “Now you’re just upset because you were wrong.”
“That’s not why I’m upset,” she said, her voice returning to that cold, emotionless tone. “I just think I treated James too harshly last night. I regret it.”
Bullshit. Bull. Shit. She was going to end up falling for James. She had to. Hell, EVERY girl seemed to fall for James. James attracted girls because apparently he was just so fucking “cute” and “funny” and “charming.” Now I was going to lose Jenna, my Jenna. To him.
My girlfriend sensed my tension. “I’m going out,” she said, grabbing her purse and tossing her yogurt into the trash.
“What? Where?”
“Out, Sidney.” She took her keys, glanced at me once more, and exited.
Fuck my life.
~Lia~
I sat at a small table in one of our local Starbucks, clutching my purse and the money Jordan had given me for coffee. “Don’t be silly,” I’d told him before leaving, “I have money.”
“Why can’t I treat my girlfriend?” he’d replied with a grin.
He was so cute, I thought to myself, looking out the window. It was a good day. Jordan made pancakes for breakfast. I ate two. And then, almost as soon as we’d finished cleaning up, Jenna called and asked if I wanted to go to Starbucks. And NO ONE says no to Starbucks, which I why I found myself sitting and looking out the window to the sidewalk, waiting for my friend.
“Lia!” I glanced around to find her standing, rosy-cheeked, in the doorway. I’d missed her. Ah, well. I gave her a quick hug and we proceeded to purchase our café mochas.
“How are things?” she asked me once we were sitting again.
I beamed. “Great!” I said happily. “Jordan’s been looking for newer homes in Thunder Bay. You know, for when the season’s over. Because…he wants me to live with him there, too.”
“That’s great!” she said with a smile, but something seemed slightly off.
“How are you?” I asked, curious. “How are thing with Sid and James?”
“Just fine,” she replied quickly. Too quickly.
“You’re lying,” I said outright. Jenna blinked, clearly not having expected me to speak so bluntly.
“No, Lia -”
“Jenna,” I said, a little frustrated. “Don’t try to hide your feelings. It’s not good.”
“Really, Lia, we’re fine.”
“It’s not good,” I repeated, a little louder. She looked at me, finally understanding. “It isn’t,” I said, a little more softly now. “Trust me, Jenna. I’ve suppressed my thoughts and feelings far more than I ever should have. It isn’t healthy. It makes it impossible to repair stable relationships. Or build new ones. And when you don’t talk about things, when you don’t share your feelings, you can end up hurting people. Or yourself.”
“I know, Lia,” she said quietly, looking don at the table. “I just…let’s talk about something else.”
Hoping that I got through to her, I relented. We chatted about the weather, the most recent SNL episode, the new issue of Cosmo. Just small talk really. But behind Jenna, I spotted two very familiar faces. I prayed my friend wouldn’t turn around. Because there, coming through the doorway, were James and his friend, Becca. I’d forgotten she worked here.
“…love the way Bill Hader does that Stefon character…” Jenna continued, and I nodded, but continued to look at James and Becca.
“Bye, Bec,” he said, giving her a friendly peck on the cheek.
“Bye,” she said softly. James didn’t see it, but I did. She looked like she’d wanted so much more in that one kiss. So much that James didn’t give her.
I’ll be home tonight, take a breath and softly say goodbye…”
~Breaking Benjamin
~Sid~
“What went on in there?” I asked Jenna as she rummaged through her bureau. “What happened between you and James?”
She took out a nightgown and looked at me coldly. “Nothing, Sidney,” she replied. Before I could say anything more, she swept into the bathroom and closed the door shut. I sighed, with nothing to do but lie back on our comforter and listen. The faucet ran on and off; I could hear her brushing her teeth; her makeup bag zipped open and closed. She emerged a few minutes later having changed into her nightgown and cleaned the makeup off her face. Without saying a word to me, she put her clothes away and got into bed silently, turning off the lamp on her dresser. I hastily stripped down to my boxers and followed suit. She lay on the far right, something she rarely did. We always lay together, and usually on my side.
“Jenna, baby,” I murmured, reaching a hand out to rub her arm. “What happened? Something’s wrong. You’re upset.” I knew she’d do this. She always shut her feelings out to everyone. She hardly ever opened up.
She pulled her arm away. “Nothing,” she said in that same icy tone. My heart ached. I didn’t want her to be like this, to be so unhappy. If she only told me what she was feeling, I could help her. I knew I could. But she refused to say anything.
“Jenna,” I pressed, wondering what it would take to get through to her. “Tell me what’s wrong. I can’t help you if you won’t even speak to me.”
She turned over and looked at me hard. “Why are you suddenly kissing my ass, Sid?” she snapped. I opened my mouth to speak, but she went on. “Why do you think you can ‘help’ me? Don’t you remember? It was you who yelled at me in the first place. ‘Way to go, Jenna, now everyone’s talking.’ That’s what you said. Remember?”
“Jenna…I’m really sorry. Really, I shouldn’t have -”
“It’s like you thought it was entirely my fault! Maybe everyone was talking, but it’s not just me, Sid. I didn’t force this over all of us. You might think I did and you might say I did, but I didn’t. It’s not my fault.”
“I know, baby, I know it isn’t. I’m sorry. I’m really sorry, I -”
“How long do you think you’re going to get away with a quick ‘I’m sorry?’” she yelled, sitting up. “It doesn’t work that way, Sid! ‘Sorry’ isn’t going to cut it all the time.” She threw the covers off of her, grabbed a throw blanket from the foot of the bed, and stormed out of the room.
“Jenna!” Fuck. This wasn’t going well. I hopped out of bed and went after her, following her to the living room, where she’d set herself up on the couch. Taking a deep breath, I picked up her light body. She placed her hands on my chest, pushing me away, resisting, but I simply sat down on the couch and held her. Frustrated and angry, she resumed her laying position. I followed, laying behind her, letting her body slowly sink into mine. I wished she’d talk to me. I wished she’d open up. What would it take? What would I have to do, to make her trust me? Growing tired and running out of options, I sat up a bit, cupped her cheek, and turned her head to mine. And I kissed her, softly, gently.
Taken aback and a little surprised, Jenna kissed me back. She let her lips part a little, and I could taste the sweetness of her mouth, her smooth, soft lips. “No,” she said, suddenly pulling away. So close. So, so close. “No, Sid, you can’t get out of this with kisses and sex. That’s what you always do. It’s not working this time.”
“Why are we even arguing, Jenna?” I sighed. “I don’t want this; I just want to be happy.”
“We’re arguing because we’re having problems.” It was the truth, but it hurt all the same. “You know that, Sid. And you can’t keep pretending our problems don’t exist. You can’t hide from the truth.” Even so, she leaned back against me, silent, but not exactly angry.
After a few moments, I closed my eyes. And then it occurred to me. Isn’t that what Jenna did all the time? Hide from the truth and pretend there was nothing wrong?
***
When I woke up to the bright morning sunlight, Jenna was no longer lying beside me. I sat up sharply, looking around to see where my girlfriend had gone. I was relieved to see her sitting at the counter and eating yogurt. She wasn’t with me, but she wasn’t gone. “Good morning,” I said, yawning and joining her in the kitchen. She only nodded. “That looks good,” I said, pointing to her yogurt and opening the fridge. She shrugged. “Jenna,” I sighed. “Now what? Why are you being quiet?”
And she said the two words I was getting very, very used to. “It’s nothing.”
Now I was annoyed. I thought we’d patched things up as much as we could last night, but now, in the morning, it felt like we were starting from square one again. “Is it because you finally realized you were wrong?” I asked quietly.
Jenna looked up from her cup of yogurt. “What?”
“Did you finally realize you’ve been wrong the whole time?”
“Sid,” she said slowly, “what are you talking about?”
“About James. I was right and you were wrong. He told you last night, didn’t he? He told you he was in love with you. And now you’re upset because you can’t go on denying the truth!” She said nothing. Absolutely nothing. And for that, I knew my assumption was correct. “I knew it,” I told her. “Now you’re just upset because you were wrong.”
“That’s not why I’m upset,” she said, her voice returning to that cold, emotionless tone. “I just think I treated James too harshly last night. I regret it.”
Bullshit. Bull. Shit. She was going to end up falling for James. She had to. Hell, EVERY girl seemed to fall for James. James attracted girls because apparently he was just so fucking “cute” and “funny” and “charming.” Now I was going to lose Jenna, my Jenna. To him.
My girlfriend sensed my tension. “I’m going out,” she said, grabbing her purse and tossing her yogurt into the trash.
“What? Where?”
“Out, Sidney.” She took her keys, glanced at me once more, and exited.
Fuck my life.
~Lia~
I sat at a small table in one of our local Starbucks, clutching my purse and the money Jordan had given me for coffee. “Don’t be silly,” I’d told him before leaving, “I have money.”
“Why can’t I treat my girlfriend?” he’d replied with a grin.
He was so cute, I thought to myself, looking out the window. It was a good day. Jordan made pancakes for breakfast. I ate two. And then, almost as soon as we’d finished cleaning up, Jenna called and asked if I wanted to go to Starbucks. And NO ONE says no to Starbucks, which I why I found myself sitting and looking out the window to the sidewalk, waiting for my friend.
“Lia!” I glanced around to find her standing, rosy-cheeked, in the doorway. I’d missed her. Ah, well. I gave her a quick hug and we proceeded to purchase our café mochas.
“How are things?” she asked me once we were sitting again.
I beamed. “Great!” I said happily. “Jordan’s been looking for newer homes in Thunder Bay. You know, for when the season’s over. Because…he wants me to live with him there, too.”
“That’s great!” she said with a smile, but something seemed slightly off.
“How are you?” I asked, curious. “How are thing with Sid and James?”
“Just fine,” she replied quickly. Too quickly.
“You’re lying,” I said outright. Jenna blinked, clearly not having expected me to speak so bluntly.
“No, Lia -”
“Jenna,” I said, a little frustrated. “Don’t try to hide your feelings. It’s not good.”
“Really, Lia, we’re fine.”
“It’s not good,” I repeated, a little louder. She looked at me, finally understanding. “It isn’t,” I said, a little more softly now. “Trust me, Jenna. I’ve suppressed my thoughts and feelings far more than I ever should have. It isn’t healthy. It makes it impossible to repair stable relationships. Or build new ones. And when you don’t talk about things, when you don’t share your feelings, you can end up hurting people. Or yourself.”
“I know, Lia,” she said quietly, looking don at the table. “I just…let’s talk about something else.”
Hoping that I got through to her, I relented. We chatted about the weather, the most recent SNL episode, the new issue of Cosmo. Just small talk really. But behind Jenna, I spotted two very familiar faces. I prayed my friend wouldn’t turn around. Because there, coming through the doorway, were James and his friend, Becca. I’d forgotten she worked here.
“…love the way Bill Hader does that Stefon character…” Jenna continued, and I nodded, but continued to look at James and Becca.
“Bye, Bec,” he said, giving her a friendly peck on the cheek.
“Bye,” she said softly. James didn’t see it, but I did. She looked like she’d wanted so much more in that one kiss. So much that James didn’t give her.
@nanshil87
I actually updated recently on Mibba and will try to post that here today. Glad you like the story!!
12/9/13