Login with:

Facebook

Twitter

Tumblr

Google

Yahoo

Aol.

Mibba

Your info will not be visible on the site. After logging in for the first time you'll be able to choose your display name.

Never Gonna Happen

Misunderstandings

“Time to take her home
her dizzy head is conscience laden
time to take a ride
it leaves today no conversation
time to take her home
her dizzy head is conscience laden
time to wait too long
to wait too long
these conversations kill…”
- Stone Temple Pilots (see song here)

~Sidney~

She went “out.” Where was “out?” With James? I hoped not. I really, really hoped not. In fact, it was kind of freaking me out. What if Jenna were with James right now? No. No. She couldn’t be with James. But what if…? Almost panicking, I finally decided to text a third party, just to be safe.

“Hey,” I typed to Staalsy. “Can u text James and ask what he’s doing?”

“Sure…” he replied, just seconds later. And just a minute after that, he texted again. “Says he’s lying on the couch watching reruns of ‘Wipeout.’ Y?”

“Nothing…just wondering where Jenna is.”

“With Lia,” he replied quickly. “At Starbucks. Keep track of your girl, dammit.”

Okay. She was at Starbucks with Lia. At least she wasn’t with James. But…what if she was telling Lia about us? What if she was telling her how she didn’t want to be with me anymore? What if she was telling her that she was in love with James?

I took a deep breath. I wanted to trust Jenna I loved her. I just wanted us to be happy again. Carefree. But with James in the picture, there was no way I COULDN’T get defensive. He was like…competition. I wasn’t stupid; I knew girls found him attractive -- both physically and personality-wise. How long could it be before Jenna saw that in him?

Maybe an hour later, Jenna came home. “Hi!” I said quickly, feeling the nerves run through my voice.

She looked at me, expressionless. “Hi.” Well. “Hi” was better than her yelling at me like she had earlier in the morning.

“How was…” She didn’t know I knew she’d been with Lia. “How was wherever you went?”

“Fine,” she replied, placing her purse on the counter.

“Where DID you go, anyway?” I asked, making a somewhat desperate attempt at keeping our conversation going.

“Starbucks.”

“By yourself?”

“With Lia.”

“That’s good,” I said honestly. “I was…a little worried you might have gone out to see James.”

Anger flashed in her eyes. “Why can’t we go five minutes without you freaking out about James?” she asked hotly.

“I’m not freaking out, Jenna,” I said meekly, “you are.”

“Because YOU keep mentioning him. Just STOP, Sidney. For God’s sake, just stop WORRYING so much!”

I sat at the counter and sighed, running my hand over my hair in frustration. “I just…I can’t help it, Jenna. I feel like…I feel like any day, you might see something in him that you don’t see in me. It scares me.”

~Lia~

It was the last night before the playoffs, and here we were, in a nearby Pittsburgh club. The guys and their girls were all having a good time. I knew Jordan and I were. A year ago, I would never have even looked at a dance club. But now, we were dancing. I was having fun. It was great.

I didn’t drink, and the guys all restricted themselves to one or two because of the game tomorrow, but most of the girls weren’t afraid to let loose a little. I was used to girls like Vero getting a little buzzed on martinis and fruit spritzers. But I was shocked to see Jenna drink a second beer. Never, ever had I seen Jenna have more than one drink in public. But she sat alone at the neon-lit bar while Sid chatted with Pascal and Marc-Andre.

“Jordan?” I asked, having to raise my voice a little as we danced to the blaring rave music.

“Yeah?” he asked, placing his hands low on my hips as he stood behind me.

I promptly repositioned his hands a little higher on my waist. “I think something’s wrong with Jenna.”

Jordan glanced over to where I was looking. “Why?”

“She’s drinking a second beer.”

Jordan cracked up. “Lia, babe, that’s no big deal. It’s two. It’s not like she’s shit faced drunk.”

“She NEVER has more than one,” I said nervously.

Jordan gave me a quick kiss on the neck. “Don’t worry about it, babe.”

As we danced, I continued to look back at Jenna. I wanted to trust my boyfriend’s judgment, but something was off. Jenna had been on edge for weeks now. Maybe tonight, she’d crack.

~James~

“Come dance!” said a tall blonde, grabbing my hand.

I blinked at her. “No thanks, I’ll just…I’m going to stay here.” The blonde frowned and grabbed Matt Niskanen by the arm instead. Nisky was happy to join her in the crowd of grinding, hip-bumping people. I, on the other hand, much preferred the safe confines of the high top table where I was sitting with Geno and Tyler Kennedy.

“Earth to Nealer,” said TK. I realized, suddenly, that I’d been staring at Jenna. How couldn’t I? She was sitting at the bar only a few feet away, all alone. Even Sid was sitting and chatting with other people.

“Oh, sorry,” I muttered, but I continued to watch Jenna, downing drink after drink. Her eyes were red, but she wasn’t crying. I’d never seen her cry in public, but even without tears, she looked as distressed as ever right now. Lia went over and spoke a few words. Jenna gave her an unconvincing smile and brushed it off, but she was quite visibly drunk. Lia, unfortunately, could do nothing but leave her to her drinking.

“I’ll be right back,” I said, and before TK or Geno could ask where I was going, I quickly left.

“Jenna?” I said softly, taking the barstool next to her. “Are you…okay?”

She looked at me for a long moment before draining her drink and looking at me again. Politely hiding a small hiccup with her hand, she clear her throat. “I’m sorry, James.”

“Don’t be sorry!” I said quickly. “Don’t. You didn’t do anything wrong.”

“No, I did, I was horrible to you.”

“No, Jenna,” I said gently, “I never should have made a move on you in the first place. Especially because you’re with Sid, and all…” At the sound of her boyfriend’s name, Jenna’s eyes welled up.

“I still feel horrible,” she said, looking sadly into her empty glass. Cautiously, I leaned forward and wrapped my arms around the poor girl in an effort to comfort her.

“Don’t be upset,” I said soothingly. “I don’t want you to be sad.” I didn’t. Jenna had such a pretty smile. It killed me to see her so close to tears.

“I’m n-not,” she said. A signature Jenna move at disguising her feelings. “I’m okay. But th-thanks for l-listening, James.” She leaned over and kissed me softly on the cheek. “Y-you’re a good friend.”

~Sidney~

I’d been stealing glances at Jenna all night long. So when James showed up at her side, I immediately tensed up. I wanted to go over there, to shove him away, to tell him to never look at my girlfriend again. But then I remembered what Jenna had told me earlier. I needed to stop worrying. I couldn’t do that, but I could stop myself from going over there and causing a scene. So instead, I stayed where I sat and just watched. They talked. Jenna looked like she might cry for a moment, and I wanted to go over there and hug her, hold her, protect her. And then Nealer did instead. I felt my blood boil, but I stayed put. But then something happened that made me want to explode. Jenna, my Jenna, kissed my teammate on the cheek.

“Oh my God,” I muttered, fuming. No. This was exactly what I was afraid of. They’d been talking for a fair amount of time, and now, it was clear what had been said. She kissed him. She could’ve only just told him that she loved him. “Fuck!”

“Sid…” said Flower. He’d seen it, too. “It was only -”

“Don’t fucking tell me what it was. I SAW what it was!” I got up out of my seat and headed for the dance floor.

“Sid!” the Frenchman yelled. But I didn’t listen. I could think of only one way to get back, to counter just what Jenna had done to me. I grabbed the nearest slutty puck bunny and began to dance with her. She spoke. Some flirty whoreish shit. I didn’t listen. But it was enough. Soon, the blonde was clinging to my arm and grinning from ear to ear. I brought our dancing into Jenna’s view. I kissed the blonde slut.

~James~

“…but I just wanted to make sure you were okay,” I finished. But Jenna’s eyes were elsewhere.

“James…” she said in a near-whisper. I looked to where her shocked gaze led, only to see her boyfriend, Sid…with a blonde, slutty looking girl on his hip -- and, evidently, on his lips. After a moment of lusty kissing, Sid pulled away, glanced at Jenna, and whispered something to the girl. In a matter of seconds, they were gone. They left.

I whipped back around to look at Jenna, who appeared traumatized and desolate. “Jenna?” I said. She was silent. From her big, beautiful eyes, a single tear fell, followed by many, many more.

Prequel

Forever

NC-17 Romance Drama

Lia Morgan has had a lifelong battle against depression and anorexia. But once she meets Jordan Staal, could things change for the better?

1/6/13

Completed ✓
9.7 19 Votes

Comments

@nanshil87
I actually updated recently on Mibba and will try to post that here today. Glad you like the story!!

leecasper17
12/9/13
This is an interesting story. When are you going to update again?
nanshil87 nanshil87
12/5/13
This is such a great story, I love it. I still don't know who to choose Sid/Jenna or James/Jenna
Sidster87 Sidster87
4/9/13
Jenna/Sid!!
puckme69 puckme69
2/12/13
i am in love with jordan and lia. now i just want jenna to make up her mind of who she wants. someone has to give because the egos are a bit much...
ldw choice ldw choice
1/14/13