No Pain, No Gain
Valentine's Day
"My darling, you're such a child. You think that by saying, 'I'm sorry,' all the past can be corrected."
~Rhett Butler, "Gone with the Wind"
~Carey~
“I want to see you tonight.” I read and reread the text I’d sent to Bri fifteen minutes ago. She’d yet to reply, and the chances that my plan would work were becoming slimmer and slimmer as I waited. It was Valentine’s Day. I wanted to see her very much, to take her away from Shawn for a night and kiss her and hold her and - I sighed. I was getting ahead of myself. This was Bri, after all. Bri, who constantly fueled my hopes but evaded my pursuits.
I whipped my phone back out when it finally vibrated with a new text. It was for nothing, though, and my heart sank when I read the message. “We both know that can’t happen,” she’d written. Of course. Of course, it was Valentine’s Day, and she had to be with her beloved boyfriend.
It was all for nothing, I realized suddenly. Everything. All of the nights stolen away to my apartment, all of the “practicing” in my car, all of my hopes that one day, I would win Bri from Shawn. I’d hoped for so long that one day she might just realize that what we had was stronger than what they had. But in the end, it would never work. She would always go back to Shawn, whether it be from guilt or because deep down, she truly loved him more.
After reading her text one more time, I took a deep breath, hit “erase” and closed my phone. I felt defeated. It had never been a game for me, yet somehow, I felt like I’d lost. I looked at the clock. Before Bri, I’d never been much of a one-night stand guy. But tonight seemed like a good night to start.
~Bri~
I adjusted the straps of my dress and gave myself a once-over in my bathroom mirror. Not bad for Valentine’s Day. Shawn had announced he was taking me to my favorite restaurant for dinner. The least I could do was dress nicely. I’d been excited earlier, but as the day went on, I couldn’t help but think of Carey. “I want to see you tonight,” he written. My initial thought was no - I was in a relationship, and today was the most important day of the year to relationships everywhere. And to top it all off, I’d already wronged Shawn on several accounts - I wasn’t planning to do it again tonight. Or ever again, for that matter. But the more I thought about it, the more I couldn’t get the idea of me and Carey out of my mind. Me and Carey in his bed, the night I’d met him. Me and Carey during the snowstorm, kissing like love drunk, horny high schoolers. Several times throughout the day, I almost thought to cancelling on Shawn. Almost. But, as always, guilt overcame me. How could I say our relationship was failing when I wasn’t even trying?
When he knocked on the door, I gave my hair one last fluff and hurried to greet him. “You look beautiful,” he said sweetly. I smiled and hugged him as usual. It was warm and kind, but different than the way Carey hugged me. Carey’s hugged me tightly, and for a long time. Like he was worried he might not have another chance.
“Thank you,” I said anyway.
“Are you ready to go?” I nodded, grabbed my purse off the coat rack, and followed Shawn out the door. It was only a short ride to Le ___, and since Shawn had made reservations, we were seated almost as soon as we arrived.
“How was work?” he asked me once we were sitting comfortably at a tiny table for two. The tables were dressed in stark white cloths as usual, but today, each setting included a vase of two red roses and a candle. It was a nice touch, I supposed, but my mind was still hanging on to thoughts of Carey, and the more I thought about Carey, the less I wanted to be with Shawn.
“It was fine,” I replied, but I offered no more. The waiter came, and Shawn selected a wine. Once again, I made no comment.
“Is something wrong?” he asked me.
I swallowed. “No.”
“You seem quiet.”
“I was…thinking about something. Sorry.”
Shawn looked at me for a long moment. The wine came, and we each took our glasses, but once the waiter was gone again, he continued to stare. “So,” he said finally. “Joey drove you home the other day? During the snowstorm?”
No, Carey did. And we had sex. In his car. “Yes,” I said, deciding this was a good cover.
“Was the weather really bad enough to not drive yourself?”
“It was bad, Shawn. You should’ve seen the snow.” I tried to pass it off as the truth, but I could feel my face turning red.
“And Joey was right there to drive you home.”
“Yes.”
Shawn’s eyes bore into me. “Joey lives in your apartment building,” he said, almost not wanting to believe what he was saying. “He was just…in the area…?”
Fuck. Fuck, fuck, fuck. I’d been so stupid, trying to pass off Joey as my cover. Of course he didn’t live near the area I’d been delivering in. Fuck.
“Well…no,” I said, wondering if there was still some way I could wiggle out of this. “Okay, Joey didn’t drive me home.”
“Who did?”
I looked into his eyes, then down at my plate. I couldn’t tell him. How could I tell him?
“Please, Bri, tell me this isn’t what I think it is.”
I wouldn’t meet his gaze again. “I wish I could,” I whispered finally.
Another long moment of silence. Then, “How long?”
“Since December.”
“December,” he repeated. “Look at me.” I didn’t. “Bri, look at me.” Slowly, I raised my eyes up to meet his. They were bright and blue as always, but full of sadness and anger, and…jealousy, I guess. “Why?” That was what he wanted to know. Not who. Why.
“I was bored,” I said quietly. “And Ca-…I mean, he made things…exciting.”
“You couldn’t just talk to me about it?” I broke away from his gaze and stared blankly at the vase of roses. “You couldn’t tell me you were bored, could you? You just decided to find someone else to fill the void.”
“No!” I said, feeling tears of frustration pooling in my eyes. “I -”
“Look at me.”
I looked back up. “I didn’t mean for it to begin. But when we started, we…we couldn’t stop. I couldn’t.”
Shawn took a deep breath before standing up. “You should’ve just told me, Bri.” He turned and headed the way we’d come in.
“Shawn -”
“It’s over.”
I was left sitting in my seat. Nowhere to go, nothing to say. Except…Carey. I still had Carey.
***
I knocked on his apartment door, rocking back and forth on the balls of my feet nervously. Finally, it opened. But standing before me wasn’t Carey. Instead, it was a young blonde, holding a beer and giggling at some joke I must’ve missed.
“Hi,” she said, tugging at the plaid flannel shirt I knew belonged to Carey.
“Is Carey here?” I said, my heart sinking by the second.
“Care-bear!” she called. “Some girl for you.”
Seconds later, Carey came, dressed in nothing but a pair of sweatpants. “Bri,” he said, clearly tipsy. “What’s up? Shawn treating you okay?”
I shook my head, feeling the tears coming on again. “Shawn and I are over, Carey. He…he found out about us.”
Carey shrugged. “That blows.”
“No, Care…you don’t understand. We can be together now. That’s what you always wanted, right? You always wanted to win me over, and…” I gave him a small smile. “Here I am.”
He looked at me blankly for a moment before shaking his head. “Bri, YOU don’t understand. I made the offer a million times. But I’m sick of being your second choice. Your last resort. So the answer is no.”
“You’re not my last resort!” I said, almost pleading him.
“Would you have come here tonight if Shawn never found out about us?”
I opened my mouth to speak, then closed it.
“That’s what I thought.” He shook his head one last time and closed the door.
~Rhett Butler, "Gone with the Wind"
~Carey~
“I want to see you tonight.” I read and reread the text I’d sent to Bri fifteen minutes ago. She’d yet to reply, and the chances that my plan would work were becoming slimmer and slimmer as I waited. It was Valentine’s Day. I wanted to see her very much, to take her away from Shawn for a night and kiss her and hold her and - I sighed. I was getting ahead of myself. This was Bri, after all. Bri, who constantly fueled my hopes but evaded my pursuits.
I whipped my phone back out when it finally vibrated with a new text. It was for nothing, though, and my heart sank when I read the message. “We both know that can’t happen,” she’d written. Of course. Of course, it was Valentine’s Day, and she had to be with her beloved boyfriend.
It was all for nothing, I realized suddenly. Everything. All of the nights stolen away to my apartment, all of the “practicing” in my car, all of my hopes that one day, I would win Bri from Shawn. I’d hoped for so long that one day she might just realize that what we had was stronger than what they had. But in the end, it would never work. She would always go back to Shawn, whether it be from guilt or because deep down, she truly loved him more.
After reading her text one more time, I took a deep breath, hit “erase” and closed my phone. I felt defeated. It had never been a game for me, yet somehow, I felt like I’d lost. I looked at the clock. Before Bri, I’d never been much of a one-night stand guy. But tonight seemed like a good night to start.
~Bri~
I adjusted the straps of my dress and gave myself a once-over in my bathroom mirror. Not bad for Valentine’s Day. Shawn had announced he was taking me to my favorite restaurant for dinner. The least I could do was dress nicely. I’d been excited earlier, but as the day went on, I couldn’t help but think of Carey. “I want to see you tonight,” he written. My initial thought was no - I was in a relationship, and today was the most important day of the year to relationships everywhere. And to top it all off, I’d already wronged Shawn on several accounts - I wasn’t planning to do it again tonight. Or ever again, for that matter. But the more I thought about it, the more I couldn’t get the idea of me and Carey out of my mind. Me and Carey in his bed, the night I’d met him. Me and Carey during the snowstorm, kissing like love drunk, horny high schoolers. Several times throughout the day, I almost thought to cancelling on Shawn. Almost. But, as always, guilt overcame me. How could I say our relationship was failing when I wasn’t even trying?
When he knocked on the door, I gave my hair one last fluff and hurried to greet him. “You look beautiful,” he said sweetly. I smiled and hugged him as usual. It was warm and kind, but different than the way Carey hugged me. Carey’s hugged me tightly, and for a long time. Like he was worried he might not have another chance.
“Thank you,” I said anyway.
“Are you ready to go?” I nodded, grabbed my purse off the coat rack, and followed Shawn out the door. It was only a short ride to Le ___, and since Shawn had made reservations, we were seated almost as soon as we arrived.
“How was work?” he asked me once we were sitting comfortably at a tiny table for two. The tables were dressed in stark white cloths as usual, but today, each setting included a vase of two red roses and a candle. It was a nice touch, I supposed, but my mind was still hanging on to thoughts of Carey, and the more I thought about Carey, the less I wanted to be with Shawn.
“It was fine,” I replied, but I offered no more. The waiter came, and Shawn selected a wine. Once again, I made no comment.
“Is something wrong?” he asked me.
I swallowed. “No.”
“You seem quiet.”
“I was…thinking about something. Sorry.”
Shawn looked at me for a long moment. The wine came, and we each took our glasses, but once the waiter was gone again, he continued to stare. “So,” he said finally. “Joey drove you home the other day? During the snowstorm?”
No, Carey did. And we had sex. In his car. “Yes,” I said, deciding this was a good cover.
“Was the weather really bad enough to not drive yourself?”
“It was bad, Shawn. You should’ve seen the snow.” I tried to pass it off as the truth, but I could feel my face turning red.
“And Joey was right there to drive you home.”
“Yes.”
Shawn’s eyes bore into me. “Joey lives in your apartment building,” he said, almost not wanting to believe what he was saying. “He was just…in the area…?”
Fuck. Fuck, fuck, fuck. I’d been so stupid, trying to pass off Joey as my cover. Of course he didn’t live near the area I’d been delivering in. Fuck.
“Well…no,” I said, wondering if there was still some way I could wiggle out of this. “Okay, Joey didn’t drive me home.”
“Who did?”
I looked into his eyes, then down at my plate. I couldn’t tell him. How could I tell him?
“Please, Bri, tell me this isn’t what I think it is.”
I wouldn’t meet his gaze again. “I wish I could,” I whispered finally.
Another long moment of silence. Then, “How long?”
“Since December.”
“December,” he repeated. “Look at me.” I didn’t. “Bri, look at me.” Slowly, I raised my eyes up to meet his. They were bright and blue as always, but full of sadness and anger, and…jealousy, I guess. “Why?” That was what he wanted to know. Not who. Why.
“I was bored,” I said quietly. “And Ca-…I mean, he made things…exciting.”
“You couldn’t just talk to me about it?” I broke away from his gaze and stared blankly at the vase of roses. “You couldn’t tell me you were bored, could you? You just decided to find someone else to fill the void.”
“No!” I said, feeling tears of frustration pooling in my eyes. “I -”
“Look at me.”
I looked back up. “I didn’t mean for it to begin. But when we started, we…we couldn’t stop. I couldn’t.”
Shawn took a deep breath before standing up. “You should’ve just told me, Bri.” He turned and headed the way we’d come in.
“Shawn -”
“It’s over.”
I was left sitting in my seat. Nowhere to go, nothing to say. Except…Carey. I still had Carey.
***
I knocked on his apartment door, rocking back and forth on the balls of my feet nervously. Finally, it opened. But standing before me wasn’t Carey. Instead, it was a young blonde, holding a beer and giggling at some joke I must’ve missed.
“Hi,” she said, tugging at the plaid flannel shirt I knew belonged to Carey.
“Is Carey here?” I said, my heart sinking by the second.
“Care-bear!” she called. “Some girl for you.”
Seconds later, Carey came, dressed in nothing but a pair of sweatpants. “Bri,” he said, clearly tipsy. “What’s up? Shawn treating you okay?”
I shook my head, feeling the tears coming on again. “Shawn and I are over, Carey. He…he found out about us.”
Carey shrugged. “That blows.”
“No, Care…you don’t understand. We can be together now. That’s what you always wanted, right? You always wanted to win me over, and…” I gave him a small smile. “Here I am.”
He looked at me blankly for a moment before shaking his head. “Bri, YOU don’t understand. I made the offer a million times. But I’m sick of being your second choice. Your last resort. So the answer is no.”
“You’re not my last resort!” I said, almost pleading him.
“Would you have come here tonight if Shawn never found out about us?”
I opened my mouth to speak, then closed it.
“That’s what I thought.” He shook his head one last time and closed the door.