Login with:

Facebook

Twitter

Tumblr

Google

Yahoo

Aol.

Mibba

Your info will not be visible on the site. After logging in for the first time you'll be able to choose your display name.

No Pain, No Gain

Forgiveness

"...I'm learning to live without you now
But I miss you, baby
And the more I know, the less I understand
All the things I thought I'd figured out
I have to learn again
I've been trying to get down
To the heart of the matter
But everything changes
And my friends seem to scatter
But I think it's about...forgiveness, forgiveness
Even if, even if, you don't love me anymore..."
~Don Henley

~Brienne; a week later~

I’d finished my newspaper deliveries. It was only eight in the morning, but it was cold and wet outside. As soon as I arrived back at my apartment, I made hot cocoa, changed into pajamas, and curled up in bed in front of the TV. Sipping my cocoa, I settled on a rerun of Friends. The past week had been lonely and, quite honestly, depressing. At first, I’d been mad at Carey for going off on a one-night stand behind my back. But the more I thought about it, the more I realized it was never his fault. If anything, it was mine. Not only was managing two “relationships” at a time wrong and unfair, it was nearly impossible. There was no way all three people could ever be completely satisfied. Shawn never knew. I had to live through the guilt. And Carey…how could I have ever expected Carey, or Shawn for that matter, to share me? I was disgusted with myself. True, I’d never intended for the affair to happen, but once it did, I never stopped myself. I never took a pause and thought of the people I was hurting, and in the end, I ended up hurting myself. I ended up with no one.

As I mindlessly stared at Monica and Chandler on TV, my phone went off. “Hello?” I answered, placing my near-empty mug of hot cocoa on my nightstand.

“Bri?” My stomach flipped when I heard Shawn’s voice through the speaker. I hadn’t spoken to him since Valentine’s Day, and with all I’d done to him, I never expected him to speak with me again.

“Shawn…” I said. “Shawn, I’m -- I’m really sorry. I really -”

“Don’t,” he stopped me, sensing that I would’ve been babbling apologies for far longer if he’d let me. “I just called because…I’ve been thinking a lot about last week. What happened. I was angry at you, and at him…whoever he is… Are you even still with him?”

“No,” I answered honestly. Maybe with some regret, too, but I said nothing more.

“Okay. Well. I mean, I was really upset about it all. And I was hurt. But I think…I think I might have acted too harshly. Maybe too soon. I didn’t really hear you out. I mean, there isn’t much you can say that would excuse it, but… I just figured…everyone makes mistakes, you know?”

Well, then. I honestly didn’t think Shawn had acted too harshly. I guess I kind of…got what I deserved. But I supposed this was just a way for him to get closure. To finish up our relationship on a better note than we had.

“Well, I guess it’s just what I’d said then,” I said slowly. “I should never have let it happen, and I was wrong to let it continue to happen. And I’m so sorry for…everything, I guess. I know I should’ve talked to you about things. But that was the hard way…and I was an idiot and decided to take the easy way. I lost something good in you, Shawn. But I am sorry.”

He didn’t say anything for a long moment. Finally, he cleared his throat. “We had a lot of good times together,” he said. “We were happy, once. Remember?”

“Yeah,” I said truthfully, remembering when Shawn and I had begun dating.

“If you’d want to, I’d be willing to give it another shot.”

I felt a heavy weight fall over me. I wasn’t expecting this. And just as I was about to agree to it, I had a sudden realization. The reason I first slept with Carey was that I needed something exciting in my life. But the reason I stayed with him… That was because maybe, just maybe…I loved him. My heart pounded in my chest as I pondered this. Maybe I loved Carey the whole time. Maybe I only went back to Shawn because of guilt.

“Bri?” he asked uncertainly.

“Shawn, I can’t,” I said shakily. “I am sorry for everything. Really. But I don’t think I would be able to…” I took a deep breath. “I wouldn’t be able to put everything into a relationship with you. It’s not because of you, or anything. But…I wouldn’t be able to do it.”

There was a short pause. “All right,” he said heavily. If he knew my reasoning, he didn’t say it. “Well. Take care, Bri.”

“You too, Shawn.” I hung up and turned off the TV. I loved Carey. I’d loved Carey the entire time. After stripping out of my pajamas and throwing on jeans and a shirt, I grabbed my purse and keys and hurried out of my apartment.

~Carey~

In all honesty, road trips…sucked. So when I finally pulled into my driveway from the airport, I felt a sense of relief wash over me. No more stress. Well, that wasn’t entirely true. The season was still going, it was still the dead of winter, and Bri… Bri decided what she wanted and ended getting nothing. And as much as I still felt my heart flip whenever I thought of her, I knew things would never be right between us, because she would never make up her mind. She might have wanted me, but not completely. Never completely.

I threw a TV dinner into the oven and went into my room to unpack. But I’d hardly undone the zipper on my suitcase when the doorbell rang. Sighing, I trudged to the front to open it. And when I did, there stood…Bri.

“Hi,” I said, utterly taken aback by her sudden visit.

“Hi,” she replied.

Confused, I opened the door and let her inside. I knew I’d made myself clear last week, but still…there had to be some reason for her just showing up at my doorstep. Something important.

“Carey, I…um. I was wrong, to you.”

“To me and your boyfriend,” I corrected her.

“Ex-boyfriend,” she said quietly. “But yes. I was wrong to both of you. But almost more to you, I think.”

I crossed my arms and leaned against the wall. “Uh-huh.”

“Because…I led you on. I made you believe I was interested, and that I cared, and that wanted something more from us.”

“Even though you never did,” I said. But she shook her head. Bullshit, I thought. She never wanted more. But I let her make her case anyway.

“I don’t think it was because I never cared about you, and that I only loved Shawn.” Bullshit, bullshit, bullshit, I thought. “I think I just had to go back to him. You know? I felt so horrible about everything I was doing that I thought it would be better to stay with him and lie about us than to break up with him when it was never his fault. So…it’s not that I didn’t care about you, Carey. I did.”

She looked at me expectantly. “I wish I could believe that, Bri. But…it’s nothing new. It’s the same lie you’ve told me for months.”

“It’s not a lie.”

“That’s what the boy who cried wolf said.” I knew I was being harsh, but as far as I could see, it was what she deserved.

“But Carey, I’m being honest.”

“Prove it.”

Her eyes shined sadly in the light of my house. “Shawn wanted to take me back,” she said. “He asked me today. He called me and wanted to give it another chance.” She took a deep breath. “I turned him down, Care. Because I realized I loved you more. Despite the fact that everything I say here and now is probably falling on deaf ears, and you probably will just tell me to go home anyway. And you have every right to. But I turned him down because I love you.”

I blinked. Of anything she could have said, I never expected that. I wanted to believe her. I wanted it so much. But part of me still couldn’t let go of what she’d done in the past.

“I forgive you, Bri…” I said slowly. “But we can’t…do anything. It’s over. We lost whatever we had last week, okay?”

She blinked. Her eyes watered. But slowly, she nodded, and without another word, she turned around and walked out.

Comments

There are currently no comments