No Pain, No Gain
Let Me Try
“We both know I need to fall out of love with you. Would be great if you would let me try.”
~from “The Holiday”
~Carey~
I watched her leave, feeling a whirlwind of mixed emotions. I felt bad. Watching her cry right there was so real, so upsetting. I wanted to believe she meant it. I really, really wanted to. And yet, I couldn’t. Still, all I could remember was Bri getting phone calls from Shawn. Bri leaving my bed to go home to Shawn. Bri skipping me over because of Shawn. And to think that she was hurt because I wouldn’t commit myself to a potentially bullshit relationship like the last one we’d had. Nonetheless, things seemed different without her. I tried a few one-night stands, but nothing really came out of them. I never felt the same familiar comfort as I had with Bri. One day, against my better judgment, I decided to give her a call and see how she was doing.
“Hello?” she answered.
“Hi.”
It was quiet for a long moment. “Carey?” she asked finally.
“Yeah. I…I just wanted to ask…you know, how are you?”
Another long silence. “Carey, you said it was over.”
“Yeah, I know, I was just -”
“If you want it to be over, you need to let me get over you.”
“You aren’t over me?” I nearly choked. I wasn’t sure if I was surprised, or appalled, or…glad…?
“What matters is that we need to be on the same page,” she said quietly. “And since you wanted to end things, I need to want that too.”
Another awkward pause. God knows this conversation was full of them. “Are you back with Shawn?” I asked cautiously.
“No, Carey. I haven’t spoken with Shawn since I denied him the last time he called me.”
That was the day she visited me. That was a month ago, then. A long time for someone who’d been so flighty about her relationships - which made me wonder if she meant what she’d said about wanting me, and only me. There was only one way to find out.
“Have you been with anyone?” I asked, perhaps a little too forward.
“No,” she replied. “And not for lack of being pursued,” she added as an afterthought.
“But…then -”
“Carey, please just…stop. You said you wanted it to be over. I’m trying my best, and you’re not letting me.”
“Bri!” I said, but the line went blank. So, she really hadn’t seen anyone. Not Shawn, not any other guys. That was what I wanted, after all, after everything we went through. I wanted Bri to want just me. To be with just me. I never wanted to share her.
~Bri~
I stood quietly in line at the little café near my apartment. “Small mocha,” I said to the cashier when it was my turn.
“Let me buy that for you,” said a fairly attractive young man, stepping up next to me. He flashed me a warm smile, one I might have returned, had I not been so stuck on a certain Canadiens goaltender.
“No, thank you,” I said timidly. I took out my wallet and quietly handed over the due amount. “I mean, thank you, but I…”
“No, I understand,” he said brightly. He paid for his own drink and left. It had been a month since Carey told me he wanted to end things, and yet I still couldn’t stop thinking of him. Ever day I was more sure that he was the man I really wanted, just as every day, I questioned more and more why I’d even bothered to stay with Shawn for so long. Because I was a coward, I’d answer myself silently. I was afraid of letting someone down, even though in the end, I let everyone down. Even myself.
And even now, as I tried to move on, Carey wouldn’t let me. I realized now what it must have been like to be him. I’d tell him I didn’t want to continue things, then I’d show up a week later and sleep with him. Now I understood why he wanted to end it. It was horrible, being in love with someone who loved you one day and left you the next. I didn’t blame him. It was my own fault, no one else’s.
I took my steaming mocha and stepped out into the still-cold March air. With or without Carey, I needed to move on. I could learn from this. Somehow, I could. No pain, no gain, or so the saying went. I was young, I was attractive enough, and I was friendly. I had nothing to lose, and for that, I needed to get up and move on. I needed to go somewhere, do something, be someone. The only problem? I had no worldly idea where to go, or what to do, or who to be. I just knew that it had to be done.
~from “The Holiday”
~Carey~
I watched her leave, feeling a whirlwind of mixed emotions. I felt bad. Watching her cry right there was so real, so upsetting. I wanted to believe she meant it. I really, really wanted to. And yet, I couldn’t. Still, all I could remember was Bri getting phone calls from Shawn. Bri leaving my bed to go home to Shawn. Bri skipping me over because of Shawn. And to think that she was hurt because I wouldn’t commit myself to a potentially bullshit relationship like the last one we’d had. Nonetheless, things seemed different without her. I tried a few one-night stands, but nothing really came out of them. I never felt the same familiar comfort as I had with Bri. One day, against my better judgment, I decided to give her a call and see how she was doing.
“Hello?” she answered.
“Hi.”
It was quiet for a long moment. “Carey?” she asked finally.
“Yeah. I…I just wanted to ask…you know, how are you?”
Another long silence. “Carey, you said it was over.”
“Yeah, I know, I was just -”
“If you want it to be over, you need to let me get over you.”
“You aren’t over me?” I nearly choked. I wasn’t sure if I was surprised, or appalled, or…glad…?
“What matters is that we need to be on the same page,” she said quietly. “And since you wanted to end things, I need to want that too.”
Another awkward pause. God knows this conversation was full of them. “Are you back with Shawn?” I asked cautiously.
“No, Carey. I haven’t spoken with Shawn since I denied him the last time he called me.”
That was the day she visited me. That was a month ago, then. A long time for someone who’d been so flighty about her relationships - which made me wonder if she meant what she’d said about wanting me, and only me. There was only one way to find out.
“Have you been with anyone?” I asked, perhaps a little too forward.
“No,” she replied. “And not for lack of being pursued,” she added as an afterthought.
“But…then -”
“Carey, please just…stop. You said you wanted it to be over. I’m trying my best, and you’re not letting me.”
“Bri!” I said, but the line went blank. So, she really hadn’t seen anyone. Not Shawn, not any other guys. That was what I wanted, after all, after everything we went through. I wanted Bri to want just me. To be with just me. I never wanted to share her.
~Bri~
I stood quietly in line at the little café near my apartment. “Small mocha,” I said to the cashier when it was my turn.
“Let me buy that for you,” said a fairly attractive young man, stepping up next to me. He flashed me a warm smile, one I might have returned, had I not been so stuck on a certain Canadiens goaltender.
“No, thank you,” I said timidly. I took out my wallet and quietly handed over the due amount. “I mean, thank you, but I…”
“No, I understand,” he said brightly. He paid for his own drink and left. It had been a month since Carey told me he wanted to end things, and yet I still couldn’t stop thinking of him. Ever day I was more sure that he was the man I really wanted, just as every day, I questioned more and more why I’d even bothered to stay with Shawn for so long. Because I was a coward, I’d answer myself silently. I was afraid of letting someone down, even though in the end, I let everyone down. Even myself.
And even now, as I tried to move on, Carey wouldn’t let me. I realized now what it must have been like to be him. I’d tell him I didn’t want to continue things, then I’d show up a week later and sleep with him. Now I understood why he wanted to end it. It was horrible, being in love with someone who loved you one day and left you the next. I didn’t blame him. It was my own fault, no one else’s.
I took my steaming mocha and stepped out into the still-cold March air. With or without Carey, I needed to move on. I could learn from this. Somehow, I could. No pain, no gain, or so the saying went. I was young, I was attractive enough, and I was friendly. I had nothing to lose, and for that, I needed to get up and move on. I needed to go somewhere, do something, be someone. The only problem? I had no worldly idea where to go, or what to do, or who to be. I just knew that it had to be done.