Please Update
Chapter Three
The first thing Tyler realized when he woke up was that he was in an unfamiliar bed, in an unfamiliar room. The second thing he realized was whose bed he was in, and a huge grin broke across his face. Rolling over onto his side, he stretched out his arm, reaching for the girl he still only knew as Mandy. Maybe if he was lucky she’d be up for a morning round and help take care of the massive morning wood he was already sporting.
When all he found was cold sheets next to him, Tyler’s eyes popped open and he scanned the room. Nothing. He listened for noise – a shower running, the clink of a dish, a TV on in the other room – anything to clue him in on where she’d gone. All he heard was silence. Wandering out of her room and down the hallway, Tyler stopped to pick up his boxer briefs from where they’d been shed the night before and slipped them on. Every room he stopped to look for her only to find he was the only on there.
He finally saw the note on the kitchen table and frowned, his brow furrowing in confusion. Had he done something to upset her? He replayed the events of the night before and came up empty. She’d fallen asleep a satisfied customer, he was sure of it. This was the first time any girl had ever dine-and-dashed on Tyler. Usually he was the one slipping out in the cover of darkness, not the other way around. Who are you, Mandy? he wondered as he set about the business of finding the rest of his clothes and getting dressed.
Outside, the sun was already shining and it was unusually hot for late November, even in Texas. It was something he was still getting used to. Back home, the leaves would have fallen off the trees weeks ago and already the first few snow storms would have come through. Here, he could get by wearing shorts on most days and most of the trees were still green.
Tyler made the short walk of shame to where he’d parked his car the night before and climbed in. He thought about what Mandy had said last night when he’d asked her about having a boyfriend. What did she mean by she didn’t “do relationships very well”? Not that Tyler was one to talk. He hadn’t had a girlfriend, in the true sense of the word, since he was sixteen, and even then, he’d cheated on her. It didn’t mean he didn’t hold out hope that one day the right girl would come along. Someone who made every other girl seem dull by comparison. A girl he couldn’t imagine life without.
But hey, if all Mandy wanted was an occasional roll in the hay, Tyler was more than okay with that arrangement too. Two glorious nights with a girl whose real name he didn’t even know didn’t really spell out a good relationship. Heck, she probably did him a favor by taking off this morning. The fewer complications, the better, he reasoned.
He’d just pulled onto the highway when Tyler’s cell phone rang. The call ID read “Jamie” and he accepted the call. “What’s up, Chubbs?”
“Hey Ty. Jordie and I were headed out to grab some food. Want to join us?”
The mention of food made Tyler’s stomach rumble. “Sure. I have to swing by the house and let the dogs out first. I uh, had some errands to run this morning. Where were you guys thinking?”
He could hear muffled conversation in the background before Jamie responded, “Jordie says Idle Rich. Bring the pups; we can sit on the patio. It’s a nice enough day.”
“Sounds good man. See you guys in a bit.”
By the time Sara got home, her cheeks were bright pink and her shirt was completely soaked through with sweat. She’d jogged her normal route twice, praying her apartment would be empty when she returned. Breathing heavily, she stepped inside and called out, “Hello? Tyler?” Reassured by the silence, she latched the front door and headed to her bedroom to confirm he had in fact left. Empty. Thank goodness.
With a sigh, she stretched out across the foot of her bed. She could still smell him on the tangled sheets. Had she overreacted? They’d stayed up pretty late and even she had passed out after their last round. Maybe he hadn’t meant to fall asleep and spend the night. Maybe she was reading too much into it. This was Tyler Seguin she was talking about after all. The man had a well-documented reputation for being a party boy. Why would he look at her as anything more than another notch in his belt? This morning must have been a misunderstanding.
The funny thing was, Sara couldn’t even remember the last time she’d slept with the same guy twice. It wasn’t like she fucked every guy she met, but when her vibrator simply wasn’t cutting it, she preferred to seek out a one night stand and move on. Anything else led to feelings getting hurt and complications she’d rather avoid. The last thing she needed was to become Tyler Seguin’s fuck buddy. In the future, she would have to be more careful. No more booty calls, no more text messages. She would delete his number from her phone, take her story about “Mandy” off the internet and never look back.
Satisfied with her resolution, Sara peeled off her workout clothes and headed for the shower to get ready for the day. Once under the warm spray, however, Sara found her thoughts drifting back to the steamy scene that had played out in the same spot hours ago and she felt a warm tingle in her belly as her body betrayed her. Frustrated, she slammed the temperature gauge over to “cold,” gasping and sputtering as the water turned to icy daggers. Her hormones were not going to win this war if she had a say in it.
Teeth chattering and shivering, Sara turned off the water and swathed herself in a clean, fluffy towel and rang the excess water from her hair. She could hear her cell phone ringing in the other room and went to go answer it.
Relieved it wasn’t Tyler calling but rather her best friend Hailey, she accepted the call. “Hey girl, what’s up?”
“Sara! Not much,” her friend giggled, the tone in her voice implying there was indeed something going on. “What are you up to tonight?”
The truth was, Sara wasn’t much for making plans, preferring to live in the spur of the moment. “Hanging around the house, putting together some lesson plans. Why, what’s up?” She knew Hailey well enough to know she had something very specific in mind.
“Great! So you can come have drinks with James and I tonight at Nickel and Rye. I have some big news,” Hailey gushed. Even though Sara rarely went out, she knew there was little chance she’d be able to get out of this. Hailey was a pro at getting people to do what she wanted.
“Any chance I can get you to tell me your news now?”
“Nope! Sorry to kill your Quasimodo plans, but you’ll have to put on some lipstick and come find out in person.”
Sara laughed, “Well then, I guess I’ll be there. What time?”
“Eight o’clock. See you then!”
“Oh my gawwsh, your dogs are so cuuuuute. Can I pet them?” she drawled. Tyler did his best not to roll his eyes at the young lady standing before him, but it was not an easy task. Everything about her screamed fake. Fake hair. Fake nails. Fake boobs, spilling out of her top. Even her face was caked under so much makeup it was impossible to tell what she really looked like. In short, she was exactly the type of girl Tyler would have been drooling over in the past.
“Yeah, Marshall and Cash are friendly. Aren’t you boys?” he said, giving them both a scritch behind the ears. Across the table from where he sat, Tyler caught Jamie holding back a smirk. Everyone knew Tyler’s dogs were a chick magnet. The girl bent down to pet Marshall, and Tyler got a front row view down her shirt. Blushing, he looked away.
She cooed and talked baby talk to the dogs for a minute more before standing back up. Glancing around the table, a look of recognition flashed in her eyes. “Oh my gawwwsh!” There it was again, that accent that felt like someone was driving a spike through Tyler’s head. “You guys play for the Dallas Stars!”
By now, Tyler could see Jamie biting his lip to keep from laughing. Jordie was hiding his own thoroughly amused expression behind his hand. Not wanting to be rude to a fan, even if she was obnoxious, Tyler smiled. “Yep, would you like an autograph?”
Instead of saying yes, she took his smile as encouragement. “Why don’t I give you my number instead?” she purred.
“I don’t —“
Jamie cut him off. “That is an excellent idea. Here, you can put it into his phone,” he said, grabbing Tyler’s phone off the table and handing it to her before he could stop him.
“Oh my gawwwsh. Okay,” she giggled, typing her number into the phone. “And here, I called myself so I’ll know it’s you. Oh! My name is Nikki!” She handed back his phone and winked. “Call me sometime.” With that, she spun on her ridiculously high heels and sauntered off.
The three boys sat in silence until Nikki was out of view, and then Jamie and Jordie burst into a fit of giggles. Looking at each other, they both chimed in unison, “Oh my gawwwsh!” before losing it all over again.
“Ha. Ha. You guys are sooooo funny,” Tyler pouted. He scrolled through his phone to where she’d saved her number and pressed delete.
“Dude, did you see her tits?” Jordie said, still fighting off an occasional giggle.
“How could he have missed ‘em? She practically shoved them in his face,” the younger Benn teased.
Tyler rolled his eyes. “Are you two clowns done?”
“Are you feeling okay over there? Aren’t you the one who has photos of himself plastered on the internet with carbon copies of that girl? I thought we were helping you out,” Jamie quipped.
“I can work my own game, thank you very much,” he said, crossing his arms. “Besides…” Tyler almost started to tell them about Mandy and how she was the only thing he could see when he closed his eyes since he’d left her apartment this morning but quickly stopped when he realized the teasing he would get when he explained how he’d met her.
“Besides?” the elder Benn probed.
“Uhh... you know, I lost my train of thought,” he lied. Hoping to change subjects, Tyler asked, “What are you guys up to tonight?”
“I think some of the other guys were talking about checking out Nickel and Rye. You should call Nikki and see if she wants to come,” Jamie joked, earning a well-deserved glare from Tyler.
Sara scanned the crowded bar for any sight of Hailey and James, surprised at how busy the place was for a Sunday evening. Not seeing either of them, she frowned and looked at her watch. 8:15. She’d purposely taken extra time getting for this exact reason, and yet apparently she’d still managed to be the first one there.
Sighing, she made her way over to the bar to order a drink while she waited. She’d ordered a Manhattan from the bartender and was pulling out her phone to send Hailey a text message when a deep voice interrupted her.
“Care if I join you?” Sara looked up from the message she was composing at the man who’d sidled up next to her. He was about her age, maybe a little bit older, with dark hair and chiseled good looks, dressed in a pair of dark grey dress slacks and a white dress shirt. “My name’s Paul,” he said, offering his hand when she didn’t immediately respond.
Sara shook his hand delicately. “Sara. The seat isn’t taken if that’s what you’re asking,” she said, motioning to the bar stool next to her. “I’m just waiting for some friends to join me, though.”
“Ah, I see,” Paul said, taking the seat next to her. By then the bartender had returned with Sara’s drink, and Paul ordered a beer for himself. “Well, Sara, if you finish your drink before your friends get here, I hope you’ll let me buy your second one.” In the back of her head, Sara wondered if lines like this ever worked on girls.
“Thank you, but I’m probably going to nurse this one all night. Not much of a drinker,” she explained.
“If you change your mind…” Before he had a chance to finish his sentence, Sara heard Hailey shriek her name excitedly and felt two arms wrapped around her waist.
“SARA!!! Oh my god, hi!” her friend fussed. “You look so pretty! Doesn’t she look fantastic, James?”
Laughing, Sara untangled herself from Hailey’s grasp and gave James a hug. “Hi James. Hi Hailey.” Hailey and James had been dating for what seemed like forever. They were one of those slightly odd couples that were perfect for each other because their opposite personalities balanced each other out. Where Hailey was bubbly and outgoing, James was quiet and reserved. Both would move the sun and stars to make the other happy.
Picking up her drink, Sara followed Hailey and James to an open table, grateful for an excuse to cut things short with Paul. He was cute but not really her type. And after last night, she needed to cool things down for a bit.
“So, I’m here. What’s the big news you could only tell me in person?” Sara asked, looking from Hailey to James. Hailey looked like she was about to burst if she kept quiet any longer, and Sara knew her friend well enough to guess it must be something pretty big.
“We’re engaged!” Hailey cried, holding up her left hand. Resting on her ring finger was the biggest diamond Sara had seen in person.
“Whoa, way to go James!” she laughed, reaching over to give him a high-five “I always had a good feeling about you two lovebirds.” For Hailey, she leaned over the table and gave her friend a huge hug. “Oh, I’m so happy for you!” she said, wiping a tear from her eye. It was true. Normally weddings and mushy couples in love made Sara feel uncomfortable, but with Hailey it was different. Hailey had been there for her when she’d run away from her mom’s house. The girls had shared the high and low points of young adulthood together, and there was no one more deserving of happiness than Hailey. And she couldn’t do better than James.
A waiter stopped by their table to see if they needed anything, and despite Sara’s protest, Hailey insisted on a round of celebratory shots. Three shot glasses, rimmed in rock salt, a lime wedge perched on the edge, and full to the brim with tequila appeared shortly. One shot couldn’t hurt, right?
“To love and happiness!” she toasted, clinking her glass against her friends’. Before Sara could toss back the liquid fire, she saw a familiar face in the corner of her eye and felt her stomach drop. He was here. Tyler was here, and there was a barely dressed girl practically hanging off him.
Tyler blinked, his eyes adjusting to the dim light inside the bar, and gave the crowded bar a scan. He’d been here once or twice with the boys in the past and had to admit it was one of the better places in the area, even if it was a little on the hipster side. The drinks were good, and there were always plenty of good-looking, single women out for a ladies night. Tonight was no exception.
“I’ll go see if I can snag us a booth,” Cody offered and disappeared into the mass of people. The rest of them – Tyler, along with Jamie, Jordie and Ryan – made their way to the bar to get drinks.
“Oh my gawwsh!” Her voice cut through the din of the noisy bar like a hot knife, and Tyler instantly cringed. He counted to three before spinning on his heels to confirm his suspicion. The girl from earlier today – what was her name? Roxy? Buffy? Nikki. It was Nikki. There she was in a hot pink dress that barely covered her ass and a neckline so plunging it was a miracle her tits weren’t falling out. “Tyler! What a coincidence,” she purred, sideling up against his arm and planting a kiss on his cheek.
It took every last bit of willpower not to flinch. He racked his brain for a way to make it clear to this girl he was not interested without being completely rude. As much as puck bunnies talked on the internet, it always seemed to go double for the ones he rejected. Like a white knight savior, Cody reappeared and informed the guys he’d scored a booth.
“I guess I’ll see you around?” he stammered uncomfortably, prying his arm from Nikki’s grasp.
“Aw, okay,” she pouted. “I’ll be right over there with my girls.” She pointed to a table with three other girls who were equally as terrifying. But that wasn’t the thing Tyler noticed. A flash of blond hair caught his eye, and his eyes went wide. Sitting behind them was a face that had haunted his memory all day. Mandy. She was here.
Sara coughed, the tequila burning her throat and then welcome warmth spread through her belly. Okay, so what if he was here and had some girl on his arm? She’d already decided against any future hook-ups, and clearly he didn’t owe her anything. If he wanted to chase after the real life equivalent of a blow-up doll, it was his choice. Why did she find herself seething with annoyance? Reaching for her Manhattan, Sara found the glass empty and excused herself from the table.
In the restroom, Sara splashed cold water on her cheeks and forced herself to breathe. I need to go out there and ignore him. Tonight is about Hailey and James, not some stupid jock playboy I let in my panties, she told herself. The internal pep talk worked enough to keep her going, and Sara headed back to her friends.
She was walking past the bar when a large body stepped in her path. Her gaze roamed up a pair of jeans to a black t-shirt and finally rested on the caramel brown eyes staring intently back at her.
“Mandy,” Tyler grinned.
Please update soon. I'm curious to see how Sara & Tyler are going to work out.
9/21/15