Please Update
Chapter Four
Somehow, she looked better in the modest, black cocktail dress she was wearing than most girls did naked. Her matching black pumps had enough height to accentuate her toned calves but nothing to make someone worry about her falling over or tripping. A layer of flowing organza silk stopped below her knee, and Tyler felt his cheeks flush at the image of what he knew was underneath. The bodice of her dress was overlaid with delicate black lace, her pale flesh visible under the cut of the neckline. A shock of red on the buckle of the belt cinched tight around her waist was the only color. Her blond hair hung in waves down her back, a contrast to the dark palette of her outfit.
“Mandy,” Tyler grinned, stepping close enough to inhale the delicate floral bouquet of her perfume. Her eyes darted wildly across his face, and he could see her pulse beating like a tiny bird, flapping its wings underneath her snow white skin.
Without stopping to think, he leaned in close and covered her mouth with his, not giving a damn if anyone in the bar was watching them. His thoughts were on one thing, and one thing only: dragging her into the restroom and having his way with her right there on the sink counter.
She quietly moaned into his mouth, her tongue responding to his actions. And then her small hand was on the center of his chest, futilely trying to push him away. Tyler pulled back and stared down at her, puzzled by her action.
“Tyler, we can’t…” she gasped, heat rising and spreading across her cheeks like wildfire. So there had been more to her disappearing act this morning, he realized.
He recoiled from her sudden change in mood. As far as Tyler knew, everything had been going great. “Did I do something to offend you?”
She looked down at her shoes, shifting her weight uncomfortably between feet. When she finally picked her head back up, he saw longing and indecision dancing on the surface of her eyes. There was something else, too. Swimming below in those cobalt pools, he recognized the unmistakable swirling maelstrom of fear.
He looked at her like she was the last drink of water in a barren desert wasteland, and Sara felt her panties instantly soak through. She cursed herself, angry that all it took was a look, a glance, and she was questioning her resolve. And then he kissed her. It was a kiss full of passion, speaking more than any words possibly could, and she could feel her toes curl as a jolt of electricity coursed through her body. She returned the kiss, instinct and hormones taking over for logic and reason.
She wanted to throw away her convictions and demand her take her home, right now, and fuck her until she couldn’t think anymore. He could do that, she knew. But then her thoughts fast forwarded to the next morning, when sense would return, and she would be right back at square one. She had to stop delaying the inevitable.
“Tyler, we can’t…” she gasped. The words were like plunging into an ice cold lake – a shock to the senses that left her breathless and weak. She saw the look of confusion in his eyes and wished for an easy way to make the cut.
“Did I do something to offend you?” His tone was so sincere, Sara had to look away. Stop being so perfect, she silently pleaded.
“No. You’ve been amazing,” she said honestly. Before he could cut her off, Sara continued. “This,” she said, motioning between them, “is getting too… comfortable. I think it’s better if we went our separate ways.” The look of hurt in his eyes steeled Sara’s resolve. Better to stop things now before they were in too deep. “Besides,” she added with a grin, hoping to soften the blow. “Aren’t you here with another girl?”
“What?” Tyler shook his head in confusion. “I’m here with my teammates.” He said it with a hint of annoyance, frustrated by the way she could switch gears so quickly when only seconds ago she was kissing him like she never wanted it to stop.
“Oh really?” she asked, her head cocked to one side. “Then, who is she?” Tyler spun and followed where her finger was pointing and felt his stomach drop. There, piled into the booth with the guys was Nikki, winking and blowing him a kiss.
When Tyler turned back around, Mandy was gone.
Sara slid back into her chair across from Hailey and James, smoothing the fabric of skirt, her hands shaking lightly. “Sorry I took so long. Huge line for the bathroom,” she lied. Thankfully, Hailey and James were so smitten with each other, lost in each other the way only young couples in love can be, neither noticed the flustered look on Sara’s face.
She did her best to focus on her friends, smiling and nodding at the appropriate times while Hailey prattled on some story about her job, but mostly drifted in her own thoughts. She replayed the two crazy nights she’d spent with Tyler and had to admit, he’d been amazing. They’d worked together like a finely-tuned machine, each part working in unison to achieve maximum results. Sexual chemistry was well and good – important even, but Sara’s stomach went queasy the second she considered anything more serious.
She tried not to look over at where she knew he was sitting, but the angle of her chair made it impossible. Out of the corner of her eye, Sara could see Tyler and the guys she recognized as Jamie and Jordie Benn, Cody Eakin, and Ryan Garbutt. And of course, there was that girl. She was nearly sitting on Tyler’s lap, constantly touching his arm and shoulder, giggling at every word he said. I’m not jealous, she insisted to herself.
“Dude, Sara, there is a total hunk checking you out at the bar,” Hailey’s voice cut through her thoughts.
Sara did her best to nonchalantly glance behind her. Sure enough, the guy from earlier, Paul, was looking at her intensely. When he caught her looking at him, Paul grinned and raised his glass in a mock cheer.
“I told you!” Hailey cried triumphantly. “He’s cute, and you know, you’re going to need a date for my wedding.”
Sara laughed, “Hails, do you even have a date picked out yet? You got engaged last night. And besides, his name is Paul and he already tried hitting on me before you got here.”
“And let me guess, you ignored him like you do every guy who tries to talk to you?”
Sara bowed her head like she was a little girl being scolded. “Maybe,” she replied sheepishly.
“Girl, you need to go talk to him. He’s obviously into you, and you’re never going to find someone unless you put yourself out there.” Sara wanted to tell Hailey she’d done enough putting herself “out there” for a while, but that would have led to a lengthy explanation about Tyler. Not a conversation she wanted to have at the moment. There was only one way out of this.
“Fine,” she said in mock exasperation. “I’ll give him five minutes, but if he turns out to be a loser, I get full veto over any bridesmaid dress.”
Tyler dragged his feet like a man with a death sentence on the way back to the booth where the girl of his nightmares had taken up residence. He wanted to punch Jamie and Jordie, certain they’d had a hand in this. Not only was Nikki a stage 5 clinger, but now Mandy thought he was really into girls like that. Talk about rubbing salt in an open wound.
“Look who joined us,” Jamie said with a twinkle in his eyes. Tyler made a mental note to kill him later.
“Hi, Ty Ty,” Nikki crooned, patting the only empty spot in the booth next to her. Tyler felt himself groan internally and slid into the booth, instantly feeling Nikki’s hand reach for his thigh. Without thinking, he slammed the remainder of his drink and motioned for the bartender to bring him another. This was going to be a long night.
“So, Ty Ty,” Cody said while stifling a giggle. “Nikki here was telling us how she’s a huge fan and never misses a game. Isn’t that so?”
“Oh yes! It’s so amazing how you guys score those touchdowns,” she said, making it painfully obvious she’d never really watched a sporting event, let alone a period of hockey, in her life. Despite his annoyance with all the events of the evening, Tyler was beginning to feel bad about the guys making this poor, dumb girl the butt of their jokes.
Fuck it, Tyler decided. If everyone thinks I’m some man whore who will fuck anything, I’ll show them. Turning to Nikki, he turned on his best panty-dropping smile and wrapped an arm around her shoulder. He was going to give her a night to remember.
He did his best to follow the conversation as Nikki prattled on about Gucci or Kim Kardashian or whatever other inane topic came to her head, but before he knew it, Tyler was looking around the bar for Mandy. She was no longer at the table with the couple he assumed were he friends, and instead found her perched on a bar stool, deep in conversation with another guy. He felt his gut sink as she placed a hand delicately on his arm, her eyes twinkling as he talked. He clenched a fist in anger as she leaned forward, whispering in his ear before kissing him, long and slow.
“Excuse me,” he mumbled, prying Nikki’s hand off his leg and bolting for the restroom. He had to get away from the sight before he was sick, feeling anger rising like a red curtain over his brain. In the men’s room, he paced, his thoughts jumbled like a tangle of wires. How did she manage to get so thoroughly under his skin? He wanted to go rearrange that guy’s face with his fist and claim his territory. The thought occurred to Tyler that he didn’t even know her real name, and he laughed, feeling himself move away from the edge of anger.
And then the door to the restroom opened and in walked the guy whose mouth had just been on Mandy’s. Tyler felt his fist curl, and he forced himself to pay attention to the mirror and breathe. Just breathe.
“Hey honey.” Tyler’s ears pricked up as the man began talking on his cell phone. He pretended to wash his hands while eavesdropping. “Yeah, sorry I missed your call. Carl found out his wife has been cheating on him…. Yeah, I know, she seemed so sweet…. Yeah, so he’s pretty messed up about it. I think I’m just going to crash at his place tonight. You know, make sure he’s okay…. Yeah, I will… Okay, love you too.” Putting his phone back in his pocket, the guy caught Tyler’s eye in the mirror. “Chicks. So gullible,” he smiled, and then he was gone.
Tyler’s first thought was “What a sleeze bag.” His second thought was Mandy. Did she know this guy was a cheating piece of shit? Somehow, he doubted she was the type of girl who would do that sort of thing. Which meant, she was about to be totally played by a slick motherfucker. Mandy might have rejected him, but Tyler’s first instinct was to protect her.
It’s not my place, he reminded himself. She’s a big girl who can take care of herself. Instead, he shifted his attention back to Nikki. She was irritating, but there wouldn’t be much talking once he got her out of her clothes. And really, she wasn’t too bad on the eyes once you got past the make-up and hair extensions. At least she had a banging body. Maybe a good lay would get Mandy out of his head.
The rest of the night was a blur. Sara hadn’t meant to get drunk, but every time she looked over at Tyler and Nikki pawing at each other, she had the irresistible urge to numb her emotions. Paul hadn’t helped, either. Whenever she set down an empty glass, he was quick to order her a new one.
She remembered getting into the cab with Paul but couldn’t recall whose idea it had been to leave the bar. Everything else flashed by in disconnected wisps, like someone had punched large holes in her memory. Closing her eyes, she could see the cabbie giving them dirty looks in the rearview mirror as hands roamed and mouths teased. In a glimpse she saw herself stumbling up the stairs to her door and collapsing onto the couch where Paul wasted no time in pushing his hand up the skirt of her dress.
Sara shuddered, the rest coming back to her in a flood. Paul was in the middle of taking his pants off when a ring fell out of his pocket, the “cling” of the metal hitting the hardwood floor getting her attention. She’d stopped, immediately frozen when she saw the gold band, undeniably a wedding band, on the floor.
The worst part had been his nonchalance about it. He’d immediately confessed he was married but assured Sara, “It’s okay, baby. She’ll never know.” She had to fight back the urge not to kick him in the balls before throwing him out, praying to hell she never saw his face again.
And then Sara collapsed into a heap on the kitchen floor, her knees pulled tight to her chest as her body was racked with sobs. How could I have been so stupid? Sara scolded herself. She’d given into her emotions and got drunk; she’d lost control of her judgment. And now for her efforts she was a hot mess, crying on the floor about guys. It was like she hardly knew herself.
At first she didn’t hear the knock on the door, but when it became louder, her head snapped up. If it was Paul coming back for something he “forgot,” he could go fuck himself. “Fuck off you son of a bitch!” she yelled. But the knocking grew more persistent, and then Sara heard a familiar voice calling through the thin aluminum door.
Wiping away tears with the back of her hand, Sara pulled herself up off the floor. She was keenly aware how obvious it was she’d been crying, but if she didn’t answer the door soon one of her neighbors was bound to call the cops. With a deep breath, she undid the lock and pulled open the door.
The light in her living room was on, and Tyler sat in his car trying to decide if it was a good thing or a bad thing. He wasn’t even entirely sure what he was doing here in the first place. He’d left the bar with Nikki, sufficiently drunk enough to ignore her cringe-worthy laugh and non-stop chatter.
They’d made it to his car where she proceeded to give him the most unappealing blow job Tyler had ever received. It was a feat he would have previously said was impossible. if he was being honest, it probably wasn’t her fault. All he could think about was Mandy and the guy she’d left with. He should have done something. He should have stopped them.
Frustrated, he had stopped Nikki and feigned a headache. She seemed disappointed and made sure to let him know it while they waited for the cab he’d called her. Tyler considered it a small price to pay to be free from her once and for all. And then he was in his car, definitely not driving home. His brain was on auto pilot and before he knew it, he was parked outside Mandy’s apartment, debating whether or not to go knock on the door.
He wasn’t worried about the other guy being there, confident he could kick his ass if it came to a physical altercation. He was, however, worried about Mandy’s reaction. Was this overstepping his bounds? Tyler considered it for a moment before realizing he didn’t really care. He wanted to see her and show her what a huge mistake she was making.
Knocking on the door, he listened for sounds and heard nothing. After a few minutes he knocked again, louder. From behind the door he could hear Mandy yell something he couldn’t make out. “Mandy, it’s me,” he said, suddenly feeling foolish for pounding on her door in the middle of the night. He was about to turn and leave when the door opened a crack.
Everything he’d rehearsed saying to her on the drive over fled his mind in an instant. It was clear she’d been crying, her eyes rimmed red and her cheeks aflame. She sniffled, opening the door wide enough for Tyler to come inside. He no longer cared if she’d left the bar with another guy or that she’d rejected him before. Obviously, something bad had happened, and all Tyler wanted to do was be her white knight protector. Wordlessly, he wrapped his arms around her and pulled her in close to his chest, feeling her dissolve into a fresh round of sobs.
Sara had no idea how he knew, but the look on Tyler’s face when she opened the door said he knew why she was crying. She wanted to be angry, to tell him she didn’t need him to save her, but his look of concern melted her resolve. She opened the door to let him in, not wanting to put on a scene for the neighbors, and then she was in his long arms, like a soft fuzzy blanket on a cold night. The dam broke, and she was crying again, feeling herself spin out of control.
Tyler rubbed her back tenderly, his touch taking on a new dimension. In the past, any physical connection between them had been purely carnal. This was different, full of concern and caring. Choking back her tears, Sara tried to regain power over her emotions. “How did you know?” she asked, her face still buried in the shoulder of his jacket.
“Overheard him in the bathroom talking on the phone. I’m sorry I didn’t stop things sooner,” he explained, smoothing her hair with his hand.
“It’s not your job to save me,” she said, perhaps more briskly than she meant. Breaking away from his grasp, Sara moved to the couch. Tyler followed behind, quick to pull her close to him again like he was afraid if contact was broken for too long all would be lost.
“I know,” he said softly. There was a long pause before Tyler continued. “Mandy, I like you. It’s more than just how incredible you are in bed. I don’t know why but I can’t stop thinking about you. It’s driving me crazy, and I know you said you don’t want something serious, but I can’t walk away.”
Sara was quiet, taking in everything he’d said. Most girls would probably be giddy with excitement upon hearing such a confession. She felt numb, paralyzed by fear. Time to lay her cards on the table, she realized.
“Sara,” she said, clearing her throat. “My real name is Sara. I have reasons for not wanting to get close, ghosts from my past I’d rather not relive. I’m afraid one of us will get hurt.” It was lame but the truth, and she hoped he could understand.
“Every relationship is a risk. What could have possibly happened to make you so gun shy?”
She had no idea what it was about Tyler, but Sara found herself wanting to tell him the truth. Maybe he’d earned it, maybe it was the alcohol, or maybe she was just tired of running.
Whatever it was, Sara found herself confessing to Tyler about her fucked up childhood. She told him about how her dad left her mom for another woman when she was a baby and died in a car crash shortly after. She talked about her alcoholic mother and the revolving door of men she brought home. Sara explained how she ran away from home when she was sixteen because she’d woken up to her mom’s latest boyfriend trying to crawl into her bed one night. The truth poured out of her, each word building momentum as she went along.
When she was done, Sara felt freer than she had in years, maybe even ever. “I didn’t mean to lay my baggage at your doorstep,” she continued. “But, you asked, and maybe now you can see why I’m afraid to put myself in a position to get hurt.”
Tyler considered everything Mandy… no, Sara, had told him. He couldn’t imagine living through the horrors she told him and admired her strength for making it out. In the past, if a girl had told him a story like that, he would have run for the hills. Too much work. But there was something different about Sara. The more he learned about her, the more he wanted to know. It was like she was a drug, and he couldn’t get enough.
Maybe he’d regret this later, but Tyler realized there was only one thing he could do. “I can understand,” he said. “What about friends? Do you think you have room in your life for me as a friend?”
Please update soon. I'm curious to see how Sara & Tyler are going to work out.
9/21/15