Login with:

Facebook

Twitter

Tumblr

Google

Yahoo

Aol.

Mibba

Your info will not be visible on the site. After logging in for the first time you'll be able to choose your display name.

When We Were Young

Tyler Tells All

Sarah’s P.O.V.

“He knows doesn’t he?” Brittany asked the moment we both got into the car.

“Yeah. They figured it out. I mean, it was kind of obvious.” I said laughing. “So what did you and Tyler talk about?”

“You actually wont believe it.” She said starting to laugh. It was a laugh she always did when she had a funny story to tell me.

“Oh gosh. What did he do?”

“We were talking and he started hitting on me. I didn’t want to be one of those vein girls so I kind of just ignored it and told myself he was just being nice. But then he asked me if I wanted to go out with him and the other guys tonight. I told him no and that I am seeing someone. He then asked me if I actually was seeing someone or if I was just saying that. Who asks that?”

This caused us both to crack up laughing. I then said “good thing he learned his lesson” which caused Brittany to then get confused. “The first time I met Tyler we were at a bar celebrating a win and he was hitting on me. I told him I was seeing someone and in his head he thought that when girls said that, it was just because they didn’t want to sound slutty. He kept trying to get me to go out with him and it actually ended up causing a huge fight between him and Jamie.”

“Really?

“Yeah,” I said laughing, “It got physical and everything”

“Well shit!”

When we got back to the apartment I went straight to bed and fell asleep almost instantly. I didn’t wake up until ten the following morning and it felt great. I walked out to see Brittany cleaning up the craft throw up from the recital costumes and went to help her. After we got our living room back, we sat on the couches talking more about what had happened last night.

“Do you think you guys are going to date again?” Brittany asked.

“It looks like it might lead to that. I love Jamie and I always have. I’m just very cautious. I put up walls after we broke up and I’m very cautious to let them down again because I don’t want to be hurt again.”

“What are you afraid of?”

“Him cheating on me again. It’s easy for him to since he is always on the road. He cheated on me with that girl in Florida and who knows how many other times. I’m just scared of falling completely again. I love him and always have, but there’s part of me that is not letting me love him because I want to know he will love me all the way”.

“Did he ever tell you his story of what happened that night?” she questioned.

“No, but that’s because I didn’t let him. He was kissing that girl and there’s no denying that. He tried calling and texting me for almost two weeks straight but stopped when I didn’t respond or pick up.”

“How do you know he actually kissed her back?”

“I’ll find the picture and show you.” I grabbed my phone and went on the Internet searching for the picture that proved to be my worst nightmare. I found it and slid it over to Brittany as her mouth dropped open.

“He’s definitely into that kiss,” she said as she handed the phone back to me. “You can totally tell if someone is into a kiss and kissing back or if they are just being kissed.”

“Yeah, exactly” I responded.

Brittany’s phone started ringing and while she went into her room to take the call, I went to take a shower to get ready for the day. As I walked out of my bathroom, Brittany was sitting on my bed asking, “Want to go get breakfast with one of my friends?”. I agreed and quickly got dressed, threw my hair on top of my head, put some mascara on and walked out the door with her.


We walked into our favorite breakfast spot in Dallas and as soon as we walked in the door, Brittany spotted who we were meeting. She hadn’t told me who it was but as soon as I looked in the direction we were heading, I saw a face that I recognized.

“Hey girls” he had said as we got to the table.

“Hi Tyler” Brittany and I both said in unison.

“Let me guess, Jamie is going to be showing up too?” I asked. I for sure thought that Brittany and Tyler had planned this when they were off talking last night. I would show up with Brittany and Tyler would bring Jamie. We would have breakfast and work out our differences just like I had made Tyler and Jamie do a couple of years ago.

“Actually, no.” he said “it was going to be just me, but I’m sure I can get Jamie here if you want.”

“No, I’m good.” I told him. I was kind of mad that I was wrong. I was never wrong about these things. Must be the lack of sleep this past week that has thrown me off of my game.

“Tyler has something to tell you, Sarah” Brittany said after we had ordered our food.

“Oh yeah?” I said as I sipped my coffee.

“You need to get back with Jamie” he told me. I can’t say I was surprised that this was his motive, but I was surprised how forward he was about it so soon into breakfast. I just gave him a look that basically said ‘where are you going with this?’.

“He just hasn’t been the same this last year. When you guys were getting ready to move into the house you bought, he was so excited to move into it. He loved that house and it made it that much better that he would be living there with you. After a month of not hearing from you, he finally put it on the market and it sold right away. He then extended his lease at the apartment because he had nowhere else to go, but he spent most nights with me because the apartment reminded him too much of you. Finally he saw a house a couple blocks away from me go on sale and he bought that thinking that he would be able to start a new life there.” Tyler told me.

I just sat there taking everything in. Brittany hadn’t made a peep yet and I was kind of surprised. I looked at her and she just told me, “He told me all of this last night.” I then looked back to Tyler while he continued.

“He bought the new house and for about a week after he moved in, it started to look like old Jamie was coming back. Not that he was forgetting about you, but he had accepted the terms that you were no longer his. Then he had heard that you were dating someone and before I knew it, I felt like we were back at square one, worse than that actually. He instantly started ‘dating’ this beauty queen, Emma, but really he was only using her for sex. He knew that. Everyone knew that. And for a while, whenever we stayed in a hotel somewhere, he would always find a puck bunny to sleep with. He never brought back random girls or cheated before and it worried both Jordie and I. Even though Emma wasn’t a real relationship, it was still one and he cheated every chance he could.”

“Then how do you explain Florida?” I questioned, starting to get emotional.

“That isn’t what you thought”

“Tyler, I saw the picture….”

“He thought it was you.”

“Yeah, because I clearly look like a slutty blonde.”

“I promise he never wanted to hurt you. We went out the last night to forget about the playoff elimination. In the cab on the way to the club, we told each other that after that night, we could no longer sulk about being eliminated. We were going to leave that in the past and become an even better team for the next season. Since Jamie obviously took it the hardest, Jordie started feeding him drinks the moment we walked inside. After about twenty minutes, a girl started hitting on Jamie. He told her that he had a girl back home that he was in love with and that he was sorry. She kept saying anything to try and get him to take her back to the hotel with him and the drunker he got, the harder she persisted. I was talking to a girl when I looked up and saw the girl grab his face and crash her lips into his. I screamed his name as loud as I could and started walking towards him. Jordie heard me, causing his head to turn in Jamie’s direction and his mouth just dropped when he witnessed what I had moments before. Jamie pulled away and looked at me saying, ‘what? It’s just Sarah. She apparently is really good at surprises’ I told him to look at the girl again because she wasn’t you. He turned to her and his eyes became wider than I’d ever seen them. Before he could say anything else, I dragged him out of the bar and as soon as we got into the cab, he freaked out about what he had just done. He felt horrible and wanted to call you right away. I told him that it wasn’t a good idea because of his current state and that he should just wait until he was back with you tomorrow. So if you want to be mad at anyone for him not telling you right away, blame me. He made out with that girl but he thought it was you.”

“How can you make that mistake though? We look nothing alike.” I started to cry at this point reliving the night that broke my entire life.

“He said that she kissed him just like you do when you’re really horny and want to have sex so in his mind, she was you. When he realized what he had done, he felt bad. The entire cab ride home, he was going crazy. He kept saying how you were going to be upset and how he had hurt the only girl he ever loved.”

Holy shit. This was a lot to take in. Was Tyler telling the truth? Was that really what happened? Sure he still kissed her, but it’s not as bad as I thought it had been. Everything was just happening at once: meeting with Jamie for the first time in a year, David and Chicago, and now this. My head was spinning and I was more confused than ever.

Notes



In my perfect world, Sarah would just go running back to Jamie and everything would be perfect. But of course, she is going to debate what she wants to do!

Sorry for the late post!

Comments

No yay I love this!!

lovexpink
4/7/16

holy crap

lovexpink
3/24/16

OMG WHAT

lovexpink
3/23/16

Ahhh I need answers!!

lovexpink
3/18/16

Not going to lie - I wanted a screaming match between her and Megan!

wen.muller wen.muller
3/17/16