Login with:

Facebook

Twitter

Tumblr

Google

Yahoo

Aol.

Mibba

Your info will not be visible on the site. After logging in for the first time you'll be able to choose your display name.

When We Were Young

All The Way

Sarah’s P.O.V.

A week has passed since breakfast with Tyler and my head is still spinning. I decided that he had no reason to lie to me and maybe Jamie didn’t mean to cheat on me. He must have known I was thinking about him because mid thought, his name graced my screen for the first time in a while.

Jamie: I’m leaving to go back to Victoria tomorrow and I want to talk. Dinner tonight?

Me: Sure. What do you have in mind?

Jamie: In N’ Out? I’m going to miss it when I’m gone.

Me: Sounds good. I’ll pick it up and come over. 7?

Jamie: Perfect

Me: Your usual?

Jamie: Of course :)

Some things you just don’t forget, a person’s food order is one of them. Didn’t help that Jamie got the same exact thing every time we went to a restaurant.


The day went by rather quickly and before I knew it, I was on my way to Jamie’s. I pulled in the driveway and made my way to the front door. I wasn’t sure if it was okay for me to walk in without knocking so I rang the doorbell and waited for him to answer. It actually was better this way because my hands were full with our food and drinks.

“Hey Sarah!” Jamie said while opening the door and taking the drinks out of my one hand, “I got these”.

I walked into Jamie’s house and we both devoured our food. I hadn’t eaten all day and was starving. I broke the awkward silence by telling Jamie about my meeting with Tyler.

“I got breakfast with Tyler last week” I said.

“He told me.”

“Did he tell you that he told me everything that happened in Florida?” I asked.

“He left that part out. I’m surprised you’re still here knowing how awful of a person I am.” He said putting his head down like a dog does when he knows he did something wrong.

“Hey, look at me” I told him as his head moved back up to mine. “He told me that Jordie kept giving you drink after drink and a girl just happened to be just as amazing of a kisser as I am. I’m not saying that what you did was okay, because it wasn’t. Yes, you were drunk, but that is not an excuse. However, I wanted to apologize for blowing up at you the day you came back. I should have heard your side of the story but I didn’t listen at all.”

“How can you be so perfect?” he asked me after a brief moment of silence.

“What?” I asked confused.

“I’m the one who fucked up. I’m the one who cheated on you. I’m the one who made out with someone else. I’m the one who was unfaithful. I’m the one who broke your heart by being the biggest dick in the world, and you’re the one apologizing.”

“We both made mistakes back then. I should have given you a chance to tell me your side of what happened and I should have trusted that you would never intentionally hurt me.”

“Hurting you killed me inside. I tried so many things to mask the hurt but nothing worked. Seeing you cry and be that upset with me, felt like I was in a fight where I was just getting punched in the stomach repeatedly and I couldn’t fight back.”

“You really hurt me because I thought you were the one. I fell so hard for you and once I saw the news stories about it, I put up so many walls when it came to you. I knew I still loved you and because of that, I knew that you were the only one who could hurt me as bad as you did.”

“I’d go back and change it if I could.” He said. I could tell that he truly was sorry for what he had done. The look in his chocolate brown eyes was one that showed that hurting me was one of his biggest regrets and that he loved me.

“I forgive you” I told him. “I forgive you for what happened in Florida and I forgive you for what was said after the fact.”

“And I forgive you. I forgive you for not giving me a chance to speak and for walking away; although, I do not blame you at all for it. So can we go back to being Sarah and Jamie now? This last year has been the worst year of my life.”

“I don’t know” I said trailing off.

“What’s stopping you?” he asked me. I knew that at this point, he would do anything he could to get me to change my mind and be back with him again.

“I want your heart before we go too far into this again. I know that you would give it to me right now, but I want to know that you will love me all the way. I can’t completely fall for you again knowing that what happened in Florida might happen again. I’m not asking you to be perfect, but I want you to love me and only me.”

“I’ve only ever loved you and no one else. I will never do what I did in Florida again. If it means never drinking again and giving up hockey, then so be it!” Jamie said. “I want to be with you”
This caused me to chuckle. “You don’t have to give up drinking, and you are definitely not giving up hockey” I told him.

“I will if it means I’d get you back”

“What kind of person would I be if I made you choose between me and something else? Especially something you love. I’m not saying that we are ‘Sarah and Jamie’ again, but we can take things slow and see where it takes us. After all, you’re going back to Canada and I’m staying here all summer.”

“I don’t have to go, you know. Plus, you could always come visit. When was the last time you were home?”

“The only time I ever went home was the week after we broke up.”

“Seriously?”

“Yes. The studio is just really busy and I can’t get myself to spend that much on a plane ticket with all the bills I need to pay. Brittany and I had talked about going on a road trip, but that has yet to happen.”

“You’re more than welcome to join me tomorrow.” He offered.

“Thank you, but no. I start summer classes next week and I still have plenty of things that need to be done before they start.”

“I will be there all summer if you change your mind.”

“Thank you.” I said smiling. I really did miss home, mainly Megan. Unlike my parents, Megan didn’t have the opportunity to come visit me in Dallas so I only saw her when I was home last year. I missed that girl like crazy.

“Do you want to watch a movie?” Jamie asked.

“Only if I get to pick it out”

“Some things never changed.” He said chuckling after telling me I could.

I really wanted to watch a classic chick flick but I knew Jamie would hate me for that, so I settled on ‘We Are Marshall’. To my surprise, Jamie had never seen it; he had always loved these types of movies.

About halfway through the movie I was falling asleep so I decided to that it was time for me to call it a night. I looked at Jamie who was already fast asleep on the couch. I grabbed the blanket from the back of the couch and put it over him while placing a kiss on his forehead. I knew Jamie Benn was the man for me; I just needed him to show me that he knew that too. He could tell me a million times, but a word is just a word until you mean what you say.

Notes

Comments

No yay I love this!!

lovexpink
4/7/16

holy crap

lovexpink
3/24/16

OMG WHAT

lovexpink
3/23/16

Ahhh I need answers!!

lovexpink
3/18/16

Not going to lie - I wanted a screaming match between her and Megan!

wen.muller wen.muller
3/17/16